jirskyr
Well-known member
The refs lack confidence, that's the main thing. I wonder if it's the quality of the candidates, because we are so far off the likes of Harrigan, Tim Mander, Greg McCallum etc. Those blokes were far from perfect, but you appreciated an authoritative and therefore fairly consistent ref.
The current crop of refs are really weak personalities, considering Klein and Sutton are the top of the reffing tree and they are both quite mercurial, inconsistent, alarmist, knee-jerk.
In some ways I agree with Phil Gould, who says the Bunker has taken so much responsibility and authority off the refs that they are afraid to make a mistake, so they end up making almost no decisions at all. Then blokes in the bunker, who don't have a feel for how the match is actually playing out at the field, give directives from the TV screen.
I am personally sad that Cecchin retired; I thought he was the best ref of the last few years.
The current crop of refs are really weak personalities, considering Klein and Sutton are the top of the reffing tree and they are both quite mercurial, inconsistent, alarmist, knee-jerk.
In some ways I agree with Phil Gould, who says the Bunker has taken so much responsibility and authority off the refs that they are afraid to make a mistake, so they end up making almost no decisions at all. Then blokes in the bunker, who don't have a feel for how the match is actually playing out at the field, give directives from the TV screen.
I am personally sad that Cecchin retired; I thought he was the best ref of the last few years.