@jirskyr said:I agree, should have been penalty try.
I think the refs were trying to say that his foot was out before he would have grounded the ball, but they were wrong wrong wrong to say it happened before he even got hit.
The only reason his foot went out was because we was struck high. Richards loses control of his limbs after the contact, you see his arms drop and his legs fly out. His left leg literally flops over the line and he drops the footy as his arms hit the deck.
Patty doesn't dive for the corner, he absorbs the contact. So if you are 6 feet in the air when you get clobbered, you aren't going to touch down gracefully once your arms and legs stop working.
It was a dud call. Well more accurately the justification was incorrect. Personally I think it should have been a penalty try. If he doesn't get hit he scores and the contact was illegal. It was not as obvious as the 99 GF one but still.
With Pat and Nofa you get a good contrast between the old and new style of finishing for a winger. Pat's very much of the absorb the contact and plant the ball school. Part of is his size but a lot of I suspect is just a product of when his age.