Paul Green

@kingrobbie said in [Paul Green](/post/1467366) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467313) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467268) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467207) said:
I must be in the ultra ultra minority because I'd be happy with Flanno.
He still denies he knew about the peptides but let's just assume he did. He's paid his penalty, he's a bloody good coach and his players all supported him.
Don't we give people a second chance?

Morals aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

It is more than morals mate, it is about the safety of players.

I know you want him gone too but imo Madge is 10x more of a threat to player safety than Flanagan.

I do subscribe to the theory that he knew about the drug program but do you really think there is any chance at all he would start it again here when every single person/player in rugby league knows about what happened? I agree player safety is a huge factor but I just struggle to think of any scenario at all where he’d even contemplate doing anything along those lines again.

Honest question.

I struggle to think of a scenario where a decent person would do it in the first place? So no I don't know that he would never do it again.
 
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467437) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467313) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467268) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467207) said:
I must be in the ultra ultra minority because I'd be happy with Flanno.
He still denies he knew about the peptides but let's just assume he did. He's paid his penalty, he's a bloody good coach and his players all supported him.
Don't we give people a second chance?

Morals aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

It is more than morals mate, it is about the safety of players.

I doubt he'd do it again.

So player safety aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

You can't put player safety aside, he is not worth the risk.
 
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467437) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467313) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467268) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467207) said:
I must be in the ultra ultra minority because I'd be happy with Flanno.
He still denies he knew about the peptides but let's just assume he did. He's paid his penalty, he's a bloody good coach and his players all supported him.
Don't we give people a second chance?

Morals aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

It is more than morals mate, it is about the safety of players.

I doubt he'd do it again.

So player safety aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

Might need more than peptides here
 
@willow said in [Paul Green](/post/1467444) said:
Can't see the WT gambling on Green, he's had a real fall from grace over the past couple of years. My preference would be for Ciraldo, I think the defensive structures he's put in place at the Panthers have clearly worked over the past couple of years and from what I've heard he has good rapport with the players.

I don't like how things transpired at the Sharks, but I've got no doubt Flanagan could get more out of our mob than Madge, and I'm pretty confident we would play with some type of structure and shape in attack and defence. Above all else, we need fresh assistant coaches to come in with the new coach.

The only coaching staff I'd be keeping is the KOE coach and Wayne Lambkin from Flegg.

My vote is for Ciraldo (assuming Madge is toast). My concern is that he is not going to want to kick off his career at such a potentially dangerous position. Also no doubt Cleary would be in his ear and not painting an attractive picture. Might have to finally pay overs to get him.
 
Pual Green next WTs coach.....please Doc can I have a repeat prescription for my valium...its going to be a long off season...
 
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467451) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467437) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467313) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467268) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467207) said:
I must be in the ultra ultra minority because I'd be happy with Flanno.
He still denies he knew about the peptides but let's just assume he did. He's paid his penalty, he's a bloody good coach and his players all supported him.
Don't we give people a second chance?

Morals aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

It is more than morals mate, it is about the safety of players.

I doubt he'd do it again.

So player safety aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

You can't put player safety aside, he is not worth the risk.

It would take very poor or non existent management not to see a drug program going on. So I see your point.
 
@willow said in [Paul Green](/post/1467444) said:
Can't see the WT gambling on Green, he's had a real fall from grace over the past couple of years. My preference would be for Ciraldo, I think the defensive structures he's put in place at the Panthers have clearly worked over the past couple of years and from what I've heard he has good rapport with the players.

I don't like how things transpired at the Sharks, but I've got no doubt Flanagan could get more out of our mob than Madge, and I'm pretty confident we would play with some type of structure and shape in attack and defence. Above all else, we need fresh assistant coaches to come in with the new coach.

The only coaching staff I'd be keeping is the KOE coach and Wayne Lambkin from Flegg.

Agreed mate. Ciraldo is very well liked by the younger generation of players coming through which would suit our young core group we've got coming through. Unfortunately don't see him coming over, Flanagan might be our best bet or we look to England at Woolf or McNamara
 
@willow said in [Paul Green](/post/1467444) said:
Can't see the WT gambling on Green, he's had a real fall from grace over the past couple of years. My preference would be for Ciraldo, I think the defensive structures he's put in place at the Panthers have clearly worked over the past couple of years and from what I've heard he has good rapport with the players.

I don't like how things transpired at the Sharks, but I've got no doubt Flanagan could get more out of our mob than Madge, and I'm pretty confident we would play with some type of structure and shape in attack and defence. Above all else, we need fresh assistant coaches to come in with the new coach.

The only coaching staff I'd be keeping is the KOE coach and Wayne Lambkin from Flegg.

Flanagan sides were pretty dour, would fight over a bone and win 14-12 in ugly matches. Was that him or his playing group of Lewis, Ennis, Gallen etc.

Our team couldn’t play like that.
 
@gallagher said in [Paul Green](/post/1467456) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467451) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467437) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467313) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467268) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467207) said:
I must be in the ultra ultra minority because I'd be happy with Flanno.
He still denies he knew about the peptides but let's just assume he did. He's paid his penalty, he's a bloody good coach and his players all supported him.
Don't we give people a second chance?

Morals aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

It is more than morals mate, it is about the safety of players.

I doubt he'd do it again.

So player safety aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

You can't put player safety aside, he is not worth the risk.

It would take very poor or non existent management not to see a drug program going on. So I see your point.

Player safety....you mean like a coach leaving a 21 year old kid on the field after he was knocked out cold.
(Excuses about medical advice are bunkum. We all saw Cini get knocked out)
There was no advantage in replacing him so Madge left him out there.
He has no shame.
 
@truetiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467454) said:
Pual Green next WTs coach.....please Doc can I have a repeat prescription for my valium...its going to be a long off season...


It would be just the sort of pathetic decision the boys club would do.Replacing Madge who is being used as a scapegoat by another who is obviously another future scapegoat.Anything to cover their own culpability
 
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467463) said:
@gallagher said in [Paul Green](/post/1467456) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467451) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467437) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467313) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467268) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467207) said:
I must be in the ultra ultra minority because I'd be happy with Flanno.
He still denies he knew about the peptides but let's just assume he did. He's paid his penalty, he's a bloody good coach and his players all supported him.
Don't we give people a second chance?

Morals aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

It is more than morals mate, it is about the safety of players.

I doubt he'd do it again.

So player safety aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

You can't put player safety aside, he is not worth the risk.

It would take very poor or non existent management not to see a drug program going on. So I see your point.

Player safety....you mean like a coach leaving a 21 year old kid on the field after he was knocked out cold.
(Excuses about medical advice are bunkum. We all saw Cini get knocked out)
There was no advantage in replacing him so Madge left him out there.
He has no shame.

Seeing if he could catch better with concussion?
 
@jadtiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467467) said:
@truetiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467454) said:
Pual Green next WTs coach.....please Doc can I have a repeat prescription for my valium...its going to be a long off season...


It would be just the sort of pathetic decision the boys club would do.Replacing Madge who is being used as a scapegoat by another who is obviously another future scapegoat.Anything to cover their own culpability

Well jad,how come we can see it ,yet others cant wait to get rid of Madge because it doesnt suit their narrative ??
 
Can't see Greeny getting a job.
Shoulda stuck with the one he had.

Some of these wannabe first grade coaches should do some CRL coaching, give back to the game...

Imagine a team like Wyong Roos or Gundagai Tigers turning up for a season or two with Paul Green coaching em. Do wonders for them....

No huge salary and spotlight but really develope some country cup players that could improve and possible be the next Yeos or Martin's.
 
@truetiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467473) said:
@jadtiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467467) said:
@truetiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467454) said:
Pual Green next WTs coach.....please Doc can I have a repeat prescription for my valium...its going to be a long off season...


It would be just the sort of pathetic decision the boys club would do.Replacing Madge who is being used as a scapegoat by another who is obviously another future scapegoat.Anything to cover their own culpability

Well jad,how come we can see it ,yet others cant wait to get rid of Madge because it doesnt suit their narrative ??


A few posters on here are blinded by dislike,they are certainly entitled to their opinion but i try to look at the detail not the headlines
 
@gallagher said in [Paul Green](/post/1467456) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467451) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467437) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467313) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467268) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467207) said:
I must be in the ultra ultra minority because I'd be happy with Flanno.
He still denies he knew about the peptides but let's just assume he did. He's paid his penalty, he's a bloody good coach and his players all supported him.
Don't we give people a second chance?

Morals aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

It is more than morals mate, it is about the safety of players.

I doubt he'd do it again.

So player safety aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

You can't put player safety aside, he is not worth the risk.

It would take very poor or non existent management not to see a drug program going on. So I see your point.

But our management delegates the football to the football department, they couldn’t be expected to know what happens outside their demountables.
 
@jadtiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467476) said:
@truetiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467473) said:
@jadtiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467467) said:
@truetiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467454) said:
Pual Green next WTs coach.....please Doc can I have a repeat prescription for my valium...its going to be a long off season...


It would be just the sort of pathetic decision the boys club would do.Replacing Madge who is being used as a scapegoat by another who is obviously another future scapegoat.Anything to cover their own culpability

Well jad,how come we can see it ,yet others cant wait to get rid of Madge because it doesnt suit their narrative ??


A few posters on here are blinded by dislike,they are certainly entitled to their opinion but i try to look at the detail not the headlines

You two are obviously just smarter.
 
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467463) said:
@gallagher said in [Paul Green](/post/1467456) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467451) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467437) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467313) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467268) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467207) said:
I must be in the ultra ultra minority because I'd be happy with Flanno.
He still denies he knew about the peptides but let's just assume he did. He's paid his penalty, he's a bloody good coach and his players all supported him.
Don't we give people a second chance?

Morals aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

It is more than morals mate, it is about the safety of players.

I doubt he'd do it again.

So player safety aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

You can't put player safety aside, he is not worth the risk.

It would take very poor or non existent management not to see a drug program going on. So I see your point.

Player safety....you mean like a coach leaving a 21 year old kid on the field after he was knocked out cold.
(Excuses about medical advice are bunkum. We all saw Cini get knocked out)
There was no advantage in replacing him so Madge left him out there.
He has no shame.

He wasnt knocked out cold. IMO he was bunging it on (no doubt it would have hurt like hell). He did it again (flopping to the ground "out") later in the game then sprung to his feet when he realised the play was racing on.

Having said that, I always think leaving Sam Burgess on the field in the GF (some reports that Madge told him he HAD to stay out there) was completely reckless and Burgess could have really have had some lifeline complications from that.
 
@tiger5150 said in [Paul Green](/post/1467481) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467463) said:
@gallagher said in [Paul Green](/post/1467456) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467451) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467437) said:
@cochise said in [Paul Green](/post/1467313) said:
@aturkey said in [Paul Green](/post/1467268) said:
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467207) said:
I must be in the ultra ultra minority because I'd be happy with Flanno.
He still denies he knew about the peptides but let's just assume he did. He's paid his penalty, he's a bloody good coach and his players all supported him.
Don't we give people a second chance?

Morals aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

It is more than morals mate, it is about the safety of players.

I doubt he'd do it again.

So player safety aside, he's the best coach available. He's better than Madge.

You can't put player safety aside, he is not worth the risk.

It would take very poor or non existent management not to see a drug program going on. So I see your point.

Player safety....you mean like a coach leaving a 21 year old kid on the field after he was knocked out cold.
(Excuses about medical advice are bunkum. We all saw Cini get knocked out)
There was no advantage in replacing him so Madge left him out there.
He has no shame.

He wasnt knocked out cold. IMO he was bunging it on (no doubt it would have hurt like hell). He did it again (flopping to the ground "out") later in the game then sprung to his feet when he realised the play was racing on.

Doctor Coma upvoted, so my eyes must be wrong.
The doctor would know.
 
@dwight-schrute said in [Paul Green](/post/1467479) said:
@jadtiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467476) said:
@truetiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467473) said:
@jadtiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467467) said:
@truetiger said in [Paul Green](/post/1467454) said:
Pual Green next WTs coach.....please Doc can I have a repeat prescription for my valium...its going to be a long off season...


It would be just the sort of pathetic decision the boys club would do.Replacing Madge who is being used as a scapegoat by another who is obviously another future scapegoat.Anything to cover their own culpability

Well jad,how come we can see it ,yet others cant wait to get rid of Madge because it doesnt suit their narrative ??


A few posters on here are blinded by dislike,they are certainly entitled to their opinion but i try to look at the detail not the headlines

You two are obviously just smarter.


Not a matter of being smarter just having a more open mind.As i said people are entitled to their own opinions.You have yours and i have mine
 

Latest posts

Back
Top