Round 20 *Spoilers..

[innsaneink]

I'd love o give it to Moses but after last night I wont

 

[Cairnstigers]

I'd love o give it to Moses but after last night I wont

You dont need to give it to him because he will be given the spoon

 

[Tweed_Tiger]

Sounded like the touchie was saying that went forward so they had the bunker check for a knock on?

 

[diedpretty]

I'd love o give it to Moses but after last night I wont

You dont need to give it to him because he will be given the spoon

Its a hard choice - Moses who went to a club that could win a premiership or Manly scum of the earth who have never had the spoon. Parra have had the spoon enough - lets all pray it goes to Manly this year.

 

[Demps]

I'd love o give it to Moses but after last night I wont

You dont need to give it to him because he will be given the spoon

Its a hard choice - Moses who went to a club that could win a premiership or Manly scum of the earth who have never had the spoon. Parra have had the spoon enough - lets all pray it goes to Manly this year.

Nah, stick with Parra..
"I wanna play finals…." Moses.

 

[innsaneink]

Sounded like the touchie was saying that went forward so they had the bunker check for a knock on?

Yeah… We all heard the word 'forward".. Didn't we?

 

[Muffstar]

Gee Melbourne are such a well coached team, I really enjoy watching them.

 

[Russell]

I'd love o give it to Moses but after last night I wont

You dont need to give it to him because he will be given the spoon

Its a hard choice - Moses who went to a club that could win a premiership or Manly scum of the earth who have never had the spoon. Parra have had the spoon enough - lets all pray it goes to Manly this year.

Nah, stick with Parra..
"I wanna play finals…." Moses.

X2 (let's hope the princess wins)

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Gee Melbourne are such a well coached team, I really enjoy watching them.

They’d don’t look like much, but they get the job done week after week. I’m only just starting to believe now they are probably the team to beat.

 

[Tim Sheens]

Knights snatch defeat from the jaws of victory

Noticed that TMM was in the number one for the cows when I switched on to watch WT and was wondering how he went at the back?

To be honest the cows were terrible, but the knights stayed in the dressing room at half time. TMM is just not quick enough or tough enough to be a fullback. He has some smarts but the new 6 at the cows will keep him out of first grade if they buy a halfback.

Thanks

 

[Byron_Bay_Fan]

How can a knock forward whilst attempting a tackle be considered OK yet a touch of the ball whilst attempting a tackle always results in a restart of the tackle count to the attacking team? The try under the sticks to Cleary as a result was a bad call IMO. The refs made 2 or 3 horrible decisions at the end to gift Penrith the victory.

Yeah exactly, you see guys go in to make tackles and their hand hits the ball and they rule a knock on against the defender and six again to the attacking team.

So is it only a knock on (from the defender)if the attacking player is in the act of making a pass?

If not, then what's the difference between Kikau knocking the ball forward attempting a tackle and the Tigers player or any other players knocking the ball forward attempting a tackle.

It's a ridiculous rule, when you're going in and about to make contact it's a natural reflex to close your eyes, there's no way you know where exactly the ball is and are intentionally swinging your arm at it, you're swinging to make the tackle.
If you make contact with the ball it should be "play on" even if it goes forward, it's the attacking players responsibility to get a clean pass away, if they want to throw a pass with heat on them and it gets deflected in the act of making the tackle BAD LUCK.

Once upon a time a knock on was when the ball actually fell to the ground after being propelled in a forward direction. Now every tiny little bobble is considered to be a knock on even when the ball doesn't actually hit the ground! The rules of the game are so pedantic these days. I missed a few years of Rugby League, when did this all change?

Tonight at the Club I was claiming that was the old rule but no one remembered it, I much prefer as it allows for a little juggling that makes it more exciting and for less interruptions. When Hayne "scored" tonight that should be allowed too even if he knocked on a fraction before taking off - the ball had not hit the ground.

 

[Fade_To_Black]

Gee Melbourne are such a well coached team, I really enjoy watching them.

The only joy of season 2018 left would to be to see those pussy maggots get rolled. Great choices we have left: backroom-signing Storm, drug addled Sharks, salary cap exempt Roosters, refs-pet Broncos, Souths scum…...
Gee I hope Penrith or maybe even Dragons jag the title on GF night.

 

[innsaneink]

Oh look… It's that ref whose brother is ref's boss... the one who screwed up last week who's touchie and pocket ref got the arse

 

[innsaneink]

Speaking of nepotism & bias…wheres our tin-foil hat wearing mate.?

 

[innsaneink]

Speaking of nepotism & bias…wheres our tin-foil hat wearing mate?

 

[will1999]

are we still trying to get Anthony Don

 

[innsaneink]

Warriors getting done
Titans 24 ktc - NZ 12

 

[WT2K]

Brimson looks a good talent

 

[will1999]

Brimson looks a good talent

better than Gamble

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

Speaking of nepotism & bias…wheres our tin-foil hat wearing mate.?

Getting the tin foil hat readjusted or having his one on one meeting with Greenberg to fix up the game.