Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Jimmy said:
TDS has tiger in his blood, if he develops well api could be relegated to the bench in his final year. He is the future 9 of this club for the next 10 years…hooker is a position you don’t wanna rush the young guys in. The club has been very direct with him and he knows where he stands. Zero chance he leaves for another club but like every young guy he’ll be up for a big upgrade come next contract(we will give it to him).
Click to expand...
I am not knocking api , but I thought that TDS out played him last week , Apis running from dummy half is not up to his previous standards
 
bptiger 0 said:
I am not knocking api , but I thought that TDS out played him last week , Apis running from dummy half is not up to his previous standards
Click to expand...

It was Api’s first game. Give him a few weeks and will be fine. We were very different structured wise and defensive sound with Api on the park than with TDS they are different style of players.

I think TDS has a huge future but also has a massive amount of improvement needed to be a starting hooker week in week out.
 
Vicious said:
True what you are saying in regards to Dylan Brown, but even with an expected salary cap increase, we would be struggling to stay under 12 million if paying Galvin 1 million per season and that’s factoring in a medical retirement for Olam.
Click to expand...
Based on what, exactly?
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Why would our club release TDS early from his contract? We also have Galvin for another 2 years. Richardson will not release some of our best young starts so other clubs can benefit.
Click to expand...
The problem is how can an organization stand in the way of a young guy getting, say a $500 or $800k pay increase? How would you feel as the player? The NRL need to act. These inflated contracts new are only going to stifle development clubs. It’s a continuous cycle for the cellar dwellers.
 
Vicious said:
True what you are saying in regards to Dylan Brown, but even with an expected salary cap increase, we would be struggling to stay under 12 million if paying Galvin 1 million per season and that’s factoring in a medical retirement for Olam.
Click to expand...
There is another issue with that 1.2m figure, that issue is Bula. He is one of the best players WTs has produced in recent times.
 
The-moP said:
I believe we will lose TDS come end of 2026 if not sooner. There are already 6 .. if not more clubs that are lining up to secure his signature. The way contracts for players are going TDS could becoming the richest number 9 in the game come the end of the 2026 season.
Click to expand...
So you think a hooker who plays 20-30 minutes a game off the bench who has played about 20 first grade games and had an impact on very few of them will be the richest player in his position by the end of next season? Why is he going to be worth more than Mahoney, Api, Grant, Kenny, Brandon Smith, Robson, Marshall King?
 
Vicious said:
A basic calculation on what alll the players on our roster and expected to be on our roster in 2026 are rumoured to be earning.
Also taking into consideration Jayden Sullivan will be back on our books.
Click to expand...
Redo the calculation.

Cap space has been widely reported to not be one of our issues moving forward. In fact, it has been suggested that we have a fair bit around to plug our gaps, particularly with the moving of Klemmer and the seemingly imminent medical retirement of Olam.

Perhaps your numbers are off.
 
Tiger-ferret said:
The problem is how can an organization stand in the way of a young guy getting, say a $500 or $800k pay increase? How would you feel as the player? The NRL need to act. These inflated contracts new are only going to stifle development clubs. It’s a continuous cycle for the cellar dwellers.
Click to expand...
Contractually the club can set boundaries.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Contractually the club can set boundaries.
Click to expand...
Of course and I don’t disagree with that but that only creates discontent personally and throughout the squad. I doubt any player would play their absolute best on 250k for a full 26 rounds when they know they can get 800k. Especially when there are managers and family in their ear.
 
Vicious said:
A basic calculation on what alll the players on our roster and expected to be on our roster in 2026 are rumoured to be earning.
Also taking into consideration Jayden Sullivan will be back on our books.
Click to expand...

“Rumoured” lol …This is all no doubt based on your gut feels for what players are earning …no one knows outside a few at the club and the NRL what the real numbers are
Did you take into consideration Olam’s money? They also have freed up considerable money moving on from Klemmer as well,,,,,I think they will be fine…Galvin isunder contract in 2026 anyway
 
Tucker said:
So if he didn’t ask for a release, was he sacked?
Click to expand...
Prob told he won't get his 14 games to automatically renew his contract, so left cause if he didn't chances are noone next year would pick him up and its retirement. At least this way he is running around in first grade and is in the shop window and might get a 1 or 2 year deal elsewhere, someone his age would find it alot harder to do from reserve grade, while he's still running around in N.R.L not too many questions about his age and body while people still see him running around and keeping up. Not sure if he only got this year or next year at the Dragons aswell.
 
The-moP said:
I believe we will lose TDS come end of 2026 if not sooner. There are already 6 .. if not more clubs that are lining up to secure his signature. The way contracts for players are going TDS could becoming the richest number 9 in the game come the end of the 2026 season.
Click to expand...
He's the one I'm least concerned about losing, he has orange, black and white blood, he loves the Tigers and is a Tigers die hard fan. As long as we are around the ballpark figure of another club he's not going anywhere. He has said multiple times he loves the club and doesn't want to leave.
 
liltiger said:
Prob told he won't get his 14 games to automatically renew his contract, so left cause if he didn't chances are noone next year would pick him up and its retirement. At least this way he is running around in first grade and is in the shop window and might get a 1 or 2 year deal elsewhere, someone his age would find it alot harder to do from reserve grade, while he's still running around in N.R.L not too many questions about his age and body while people still see him running around and keeping up. Not sure if he only got this year or next year at the Dragons aswell.
Click to expand...
Reports I saw was saying it was just for this year which some would say was a bit of a risk, but as you say, it looks like St.George will be utilising him in first grade so he will still be in the shop window.

Wish him luck and hope he goes okay and manages to pick up another season or 2 somewhere even if the dollar amount is coming down in comparison to what it once was.
 
Stevec said:
Nrl tonight seem to want to create story's around Galvin and even Luai
Truth is there is no story !!
They don't let truth get in the way of a headline
If you don't have a headline then make one up and as soon as someone replies then your story gains "traction "
Fact :not one of the 16 other clubs can even talk to these guys till Nov 1
IMO they seem happy and proud to be part of this big Tigers Resurrection
Click to expand...
Yeah it's disgusting if there are no actual facts to report why not make stuff up to create controversy, notice it's same offenders with low credibility trying to attract the spotlight.
Notice the great reporters of the past would hardly ever use these underhanded tactics it is something that has crept in to the present, they will do anything to get attention.
 
TDS is still a long way to proving he is a NRL No9, time will tell, but the signs look good. Keep him, and in 3 years API goes to the PNG side as a franchise player on big money.
 
liltiger said:
He's the one I'm least concerned about losing, he has orange, black and white blood, he loves the Tigers and is a Tigers die hard fan. As long as we are around the ballpark figure of another club he's not going anywhere. He has said multiple times he loves the club and doesn't want to leave.
Click to expand...
Not only that, he's got a seemingly straightforward path to the starting hooking role by the time he's 21. There is then Haywood behind him. Even if Api goes around for another year, I don't think that affects a whole lot of anything.

I'll be highly, highly surprised if he entertains going anywhere.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 727 (members: 25, guests: 702)
Back
Top