Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Batmans Parents]

Hey @Vicious

Would you still prefer that we targeted Lomax over Turuva???

While you’re at it, ask @Vicious if he still can’t tell what Terrell May does better than Twal.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

I don’t see it. Does anyone think Seibs is a good coach?

no I think siebs is shocking

 

[mtd#2]

manly to have a big crack at galvin, 1 year with brooks, Brooks leaves 2028 Large takes over at 6 and galvin at 7.
potentially brooks to dragons could be on the cards if they don't get DCE.
manly will go all in on galvin, so will a few others though I guess

This all assumes a deal isn't done before November. If we keep playing like we have been then I reckon it'll be sorted and no one has a play at all.

 

[BAGNF05]

no I think siebs is shocking

Realistically I’d be worried about Canterbury, Penrith or Easts going after Galvin. I don’t think other options are better than the Tigers at present.

 

[Ermo]

I don’t see it. Does anyone think Seibs is a good coach?

He’s managed by Moses. I said it weeks ago, Moses will try and line up Galvin for another one of his clients

 

[Tiger-ferret]

This all assumes a deal isn't done before November. If we keep playing like we have been then I reckon it'll be sorted and no one has a play at all.

The only way (IMO) it is sorted before November is if there is a 10yr deal on the table from tigers. Is that what we want?

 

[BAGNF05]

He’s managed by Moses. I said it weeks ago, Moses will try and line up Galvin for another one of his clients

I hope the kids smart enough to know if he’s just being used.

 

[Canadian Club]

He’s managed by Moses. I said it weeks ago, Moses will try and line up Galvin for another one of his clients

Is Onitoni Large going to ask for another Galvin get out clause if that happens? 😀

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

The only way (IMO) it is sorted before November is if there is a 10yr deal on the table from tigers. Is that what we want?

No they are too long unless some of the clauses are in the clubs favour, look at the Jason T deal at the cows, they are dangerous.

 

[Vicious]

Hey @Vicious

Would you still prefer that we targeted Lomax over Turuva???

Well Lomax is the better all round player, but for half the contract value Turuva is doing brilliantly for us so far.
In a perfect world we would have Lomax at right centre with Turuva on the wing, but that never happened, so Taylan May would be a decent recruit rather than just sticking with two of your favourites in Doueihi and To’a, don’t you think ?

 

[Camel2281]

Will

DCE leaving Manly?

Will be hilarious if Brooks gets moved to 7 there next year and starts being Luke Brooks the Halfback. Spoon for Manly incoming

 

[Vicious]

While you’re at it, ask @Vicious if he still can’t tell what Terrell May does better than Twal.

I’m happy with both of them.
Terrell is getting all the accolades and rightly so, but Twal has been a very important part of our two wins so far and if you don’t like hearing it from me, rewatch Benji’s recent comments about him.
You are obviously a book of knowledge, back up your knowledge and let us all know if we have adequate forward back up currently in our roster outside our top 17 ?

 

[Vicious]

manly to have a big crack at galvin, 1 year with brooks, Brooks leaves 2028 Large takes over at 6 and galvin at 7.
potentially brooks to dragons could be on the cards if they don't get DCE.
manly will go all in on galvin, so will a few others though I guess

I agree I think Manly will be one of the highest bidders for Galvin.

 

[Merlot]

The only way (IMO) it is sorted before November is if there is a 10yr deal on the table from tigers. Is that what we want?

certainly not a shot at you T f ,thats - talk like that is madness ,id preferer to call him a cab then offer that

 

[hammertime]

Realistically I’d be worried about Canterbury, Penrith or Easts going after Galvin. I don’t think other options are better than the Tigers at present.

I don't get the dogs. They have Burton and Mitch Woods coming through.

 

[The Chad]

Manly's house of cards looking shakey.

Turbo already missing games with the hamstring.

DCE moving on.

Seibs will get harpooned IMO.

 

[Canadian Club]

Manly's house of cards looking shakey.

Turbo already missing games with the hamstring.

DCE moving on.

Seibs will get harpooned IMO.

Not even hating on Manly, I personally think Seibold is the worst coach in the competition. He's been carried by a talent filled roster. Even when you see the good things Manly do, its the same things/plays/habits that pre-dated Seibold. In my opinion, Seibold is the weakest link at Manly and has held them back from capitalising on the DCE-Turbo era. They're no better than when Des was there and would have been better sticking it out with Des for longer.

If Benji got sacked tomorrow and you gave me the pick of any of the other 16 coaches, Seibold would be my last pick.

 

[LeichhardtTiger]

Manly's house of cards looking shakey.

Turbo already missing games with the hamstring.

DCE moving on.

Seibs will get harpooned IMO.

Yeah, flogging Canberra was just a glitch in the Matrix.

 

[Buttface]

I don't get the dogs. They have Burton and Mitch Woods coming through.

There’s always room for better players.
But then again Gus is so loyal to his players….., sorry I wasn’t getting enough sarcasm into that comment.

 

[Buttface]

Manly's house of cards looking shakey.

Turbo already missing games with the hamstring.

DCE moving on.

Seibs will get harpooned IMO.

I’m not sure I’d be going anywhere near Siebs if I was playing.
There’s no loyalty in the NRL.