Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

And just on Api in a mentor role, he is one of those extraordinarily rare footballers.

He can teach certain things, but he has a natural flair and instinct for the game.

He processes in-game scenarios faster than most other players and fashioning his game accordingly as he slows down.

Im not sure you can neccessarily teach this explosive game in processing.

It is a gift hes got.

And his humility and short selling himself in interviews is always extremely impressive.

Hes slowing down but mentally i reckon hes sharper than 90% of players.
 
Last edited:
Funny how the club decided to discuss Galvin early release right when Richo was meant to be telling us about the 2 or 3 new signings , ( 2 to 3 weeks has passed and crickets , nothing zero , buying time maybe as this Galvin shat can still go on for another 5 weeks before June 30 even , I don’t think he has secured anyone as good reading now about players still wanting to come hear even with Galvin crap n background
 
Brent Rwad on Triple M just stated Api’s manager is wanting confirmation if we are re-signing him past 2026 and says he believes we will offer him an extra 2-3 years and says that will likely mean we lose Da Silva, possibly an early release at the end of this year.
Api will be 33 while in the final year of his current contract in 2026, so if we extend him it means we are re-signing him as a 34-36 year old
Ready also thinks we will release Galvin before June 30 this season and does not think we will receive another player in return.
He also mentioned Adam Reynolds clearly wants to remain in Brisbane, that along with his recent dip in form meaning there is not much interest in him from Wests Tigers.
All this being said and done, do we think re-signing Api and losing Da Silva is the right decision? I know Api was great for us again last Sunday, but it’s not his attack that is the problem, he is a target for opposing teams defensively due to his lack of size and that will not get any easier as he gets older. As much as Api has been great for us, I would be prioritising Da Silva and letting an ageing Api sign with the Perth Bears.
Could one become a ball playing lock? 🤷
 
And just on Api in a mentor role, he is one of those extraordinarily rare footballers.

He can teach certain things, but he has a natural flair and instinct for the game.

He processes in-game scenarios faster than most other players and fashioning his game accordingly as he slows down.

Im not sure you can neccessarily teach his explosive game in processing.

It is a gift hes got.

And his humility and short selling himself in interviews is always extremely impressive.

Hes slowing down but mentally i reckon hes sharper than 95% of players.

Sounds like our coach
 
  • Like
Reactions: TSP
Sounds like our coach
I think Api is our most talented individual player by some distance.

But age and a league battered body take its toll.

Benji cant sing his own praises until hes in the clear. Hes trying to muddle through i guess.

He was another gifted player. Not just the passe pass.
 
Super dumb question... What if:
We let Da Silva go,
Let Galvin go...

Be a third club to go for DCE? He wants to stay in Sydney and we would be a non-easts option. Yes this would mean serious cap space. It would be a huge signing and a massive stretch, but would add a stack of professionalism to this club.
Just like Cronk 8 years ago, DCE won't even be considering us. Even if we offered him two million dollars a year. He wants to slot into a team that is ready to compete for a premiership.
 
Funny how the club decided to discuss Galvin early release right when Richo was meant to be telling us about the 2 or 3 new signings , ( 2 to 3 weeks has passed and crickets , nothing zero , buying time maybe as this Galvin shat can still go on for another 5 weeks before June 30 even , I don’t think he has secured anyone as good reading now about players still wanting to come hear even with Galvin crap n background
If things keep going this why , Richo will be no better than PASCO , let’s face it , he said 5-6 weeks ago NO early release, now we are going to give the little brat a get of jail card , said big signings coming in 3weeks been more than 3weeks and nothing , our club really doesn’t look after there supporters, it’s all well for us to buy jumpers and shirts , go to games , but we roll over when ever another club wants one of our players , it’s a disgrace
 
If things keep going this why , Richo will be no better than PASCO , let’s face it , he said 5-6 weeks ago NO early release, now we are going to give the little brat a get of jail card , said big signings coming in 3weeks been more than 3weeks and nothing , our club really doesn’t look after there supporters, it’s all well for us to buy jumpers and shirts , go to games , but we roll over when ever another club wants one of our players , it’s a disgrace
🤣🤣🤣🤣 chill out mate. What Richo has done in a year is impressive and tops what Pascoe did in 8. It is very unlike Richo in his tenure here to not deliver on his word. So I'd say those signings are going to eventuate and any release of Galvin is going to lead to something beneficial for our team.
 
And just on Api in a mentor role, he is one of those extraordinarily rare footballers.

He can teach certain things, but he has a natural flair and instinct for the game.

He processes in-game scenarios faster than most other players and fashioning his game accordingly as he slows down.

Im not sure you can neccessarily teach this explosive game in processing.

It is a gift hes got.

And his humility and short selling himself in interviews is always extremely impressive.

Hes slowing down but mentally i reckon hes sharper than 90% of players.
It is a gift for sure, but there are a lot of cues that a good hooker uses to feel the game: to identify who has clocked off or who has positioned themselves in a manner that can be exploited. This is true for all other positions as well.

What separates the great hookers from the good ones is their ability to take in the whole situation, when to overule a call, when to exploit a close in weakness and bring others onto the ball and how to simply deliver service and keep the markers and A defender committed in order to provide time and space.

If TDS has the game feel, and everthing indicates that he does, then Api can fast track him from good to great by passing to TDS what he understands mentally. TDS already understand how to back away from the ruck and at the same time create space, he can identify the tired defender and has the speed to make them pay.

What he needs to learn now, and it is a criticism I have of Api (and Luai), is to use their ability to control the pace of the game; to slow it when we are hurting and speed it up when the opposition is out on their feet. He also needs to develop the ability to kick a 40/20 from the back of the ruck and to own that space in and behind the ruck.

TDS still has a lot to learn, and Api is the right guy to have mentoring him at this stage. I would hope that TDS has, or is, studying how Cam Smith and Harry Grant controlled the ruck in order to build on Api's cafty ways to become even better. He has time, and if he bides it, he could be a sensational hooker in season 28/29 if he does. If he chooses the fast track he is robbing himself of the opportunity to experiment in KOE, to hone his craft and become one of the greats.

TDS still has not developed into an NRL hooker; at the moment he is a great benchie and is learning. But playing 20 off the pine when the sting is out of the defence is not the same a managing a game over 80 minutes. If he is smart, and the club is too, we will negotiate a deal with both Api and TDS that is about mentorship, succession and the club.

If TDS is worried about a few beer sheckles now - he isn't the guy we need. Bring up the next kid and develop him properly. Api isn't holding us back yet and if we manage him and TDS properly this will be very fruitful of WT in the long run.
 
Last edited:
Didn't work too well againt Parra. It could be the issue though as his game has certainly gone off the rails. However, I think his attack has gone off the rails for the right reasons but in the wrong place.

He was guilty of passing too early and I expect that he has been instructed to dig into the line further to engage the defence. But at 19 he hasn't quite figured that out yet - he is now passing too late and as he tries to engage the line he also gets more sideways. He needs to develop this skill in ressies - not on the paddock in FG. He needs to be dropped for his development as his performance at NRL level has dropped right off.

On the defensive side he has been identified as a weak link and it looks like he and AD have been working on the issue. While AD's arm grabbing has improved a little, he gets away with his "style" because he is a much bigger body. Once he learns that his shoulders are handy in defence he will get better - but again the place to learn this is in Reggies not in FG.

Offering a kid with such glaring deficiencies a Mill is madness. I get that you are taking a punt on his supreme fitness making him eleite down the track - but for me it is a pretty big punt at this stage. I would prefer another club takes that risk and we focus on putting some NRL ready players on the paddock until we develop a consistent NRL capable side.
He was replaced in the halves by AD that's why it didn't work. Latu will work but he will need a few weeks to come up to speed.
 
🤣🤣🤣🤣 chill out mate. What Richo has done in a year is impressive and tops what Pascoe did in 8. It is very unlike Richo in his tenure here to not deliver on his word. So I'd say those signings are going to eventuate and any release of Galvin is going to lead to something beneficial for our team.
I hope ur right , but really things are going back to PASCO days
 
And just on Api in a mentor role, he is one of those extraordinarily rare footballers.

He can teach certain things, but he has a natural flair and instinct for the game.

He processes in-game scenarios faster than most other players and fashioning his game accordingly as he slows down.

Im not sure you can neccessarily teach this explosive game in processing.

It is a gift hes got.

And his humility and short selling himself in interviews is always extremely impressive.

Hes slowing down but mentally i reckon hes sharper than 90% of players.
Agree
Much like Cliff Lyons in his day.
 
I hope ur right , but really things are going back to PASCO days
Pascoe was an easy bloke to dislike by many, but he obviously never intended to stuff things up.
It would appear Richo is now finding out how difficult it is to manage things correctly at a club such as Wests Tigers where players and their managers believe they can walk all over us.
No doubt Richo is working hard trying to get things right, but the lack of information being provided to long suffering fans is nowhere near good enough.
It’s understood he wants to keep player recruitment and retention negotiations a secret, but players such as Faagatu, Miller, Johanssen etc have all departed and fans get no official confirmation from Wests Tigers ?
BTR has virtually vanished this season.
When all we hear from the media is negativity about our club , it would be nice to hear some positivity from our own club media at times.
Richo’s regular feel good updates from last season have virtually disappeared, does that mean our clubs off field dramas are worse than what meets the eye ?
 
Last edited:
A pretty good source on X has implied that Tumeth, Matamua and someone else will be released this week. Joining the dots, they are implying that if the bullying accusations are dropped with Galvin they'll be dropped with other players and the club can let them go.

Handle is 'itsme'. He also knew ahead of time about Onitoni leaving and Makasini resigning.

If so, lots of spaces in the 30 to be filled...
 
A pretty good source on X has implied that Tumeth, Matamua and someone else will be released this week. Joining the dots, they are implying that if the bullying accusations are dropped with Galvin they'll be dropped with other players and the club can let them go.

Handle is 'itsme'. He also knew ahead of time about Onitoni leaving and Makasini resigning.

If so, lots of spaces in the 30 to be filled...
Tumeth shld go out and learn a trade..wont even make it in ESL
Matamua a talent,but we simply cant extract a NRL performance from him.Probably too small for Bellamy...but too underperforming for WTs
Maybe he can do a two for one at TAFE with Tumeth...?
We need to buy a lot of players...soon.Bears are going to impact weaker clubs like us on the player market
 
Just like Cronk 8 years ago, DCE won't even be considering us. Even if we offered him two million dollars a year. He wants to slot into a team that is ready to compete for a premiership.
Yes, and no.

Look I get it. Cronk was going out of Melbourne and he tried his hand at Easts and succeeded.
DCE hasn't made up his mind yet. Why?

I think we could offer him a wider appeal post football. The networks want ex-tiger players as were a very popular team... Ofcourse I am dreaming a little and unkle nick will slip in some sort of incentive.
 
A pretty good source on X has implied that Tumeth, Matamua and someone else will be released this week. Joining the dots, they are implying that if the bullying accusations are dropped with Galvin they'll be dropped with other players and the club can let them go.

Handle is 'itsme'. He also knew ahead of time about Onitoni leaving and Makasini resigning.

If so, lots of spaces in the 30 to be filled...

It’s clear that Tumeth and Matamua won’t be re-signed or even considered for first grade this season so no real surprise …allthough the timing is a little strange if there are no replacements due to come in mid season …. They are down to a Top 25 now…

Tumeth proved to be a great signing right people ? Cannot really remember one thing about him during his time at the club …on or off the field
 
Last edited:
Back
Top