Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Betterdays22]

Skelton has been good when available. Hopefully he can put injuries behind him.

Regarding Tupou, why would a player who has been given permission to leave a club because he is stuck in KOE come to another club to be depth and play mainly KOE?

From a club perspective the Dolphins surely are keen to get rid of him due to the size of his contract. I think Kade mentioned he is homesick - he is originally from Canberra i'm pretty sure.

Think for 250-300k he is a good value depth player who would strengthen our cup side. Tupou and Kepoa instead of Feledy and Lobb improved our cup side 10x. Just can't see Dolphins footing enough of the bill.

 

[crazycat]

Would prefer May over Tupou.
But for depth would take Tupou over the others.
But I would want to avoid him. He hasn’t lived up to potential, struggled when given chances and is 23 soon. He also ditched us easily (we offered him a very nice deal from reports) so he didn’t want to be here anyway.

The other thing, Tupou was there for most of our spoons.

Its why I wouldn't be asking for Joe O back either. Whatever we were doing back then was wrong. It was a loosing strategy with loosing effort and failing.

Start with fresh guys. The only person I saw try every game was Api.

 

[Demps]

It’s a shame we didn’t have Topou when he was a little younger so we could develop him correctly. 😎

No Ex girlfriends.

Helta Skelta rules.
When he’s on the field.

Our ex girlfriends are some of the best in the game


From players to coaching staff / coaches.
We've populated the entire NRL with former employees / "ex girlfriends"

Your welcome NRL.

From Teddy to Papz, Moses, Addo Car, Coaches Ivan / Webster / Payten.

I'd take heaps of em back 😬😆

 

[Nonotmeagain]

From a club perspective the Dolphins surely are keen to get rid of him due to the size of his contract. I think Kade mentioned he is homesick - he is originally from Canberra i'm pretty sure.

Think for 250-300k he is a good value depth player who would strengthen our cup side. Tupou and Kepoa instead of Feledy and Lobb improved our cup side 10x. Just can't see Dolphins footing enough of the bill.

That's what he's doing at the Titans so why would he do it for less money here ?? They are not going to kick in $200-$300k each year for the next 2 years.

 

[Betterdays22]

That's what he's doing at the Titans so why would he do it for less money here ?? They are not going to kick in $200-$300k each year for the next 2 years.

Agreed. Dolphins likely won't foot that much of the bill, but if he wants to return to Sydney maybe he has no choice but to take the haircut. We don't really have any information on who is pushing the exit and for what reasons at the end of the day.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

From a club perspective the Dolphins surely are keen to get rid of him due to the size of his contract. I think Kade mentioned he is homesick - he is originally from Canberra i'm pretty sure.

Think for 250-300k he is a good value depth player who would strengthen our cup side. Tupou and Kepoa instead of Feledy and Lobb improved our cup side 10x. Just can't see Dolphins footing enough of the bill.

The right price has been mentioned by most supporting Tupou's return.

As for May, the post from Tigers, copied on previous page, is a great analysis.

If Gagai is available, he would be a good short term option. I am unsure as to whether he was at Souths when Richardson was CEO.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I signed up to the broncos forum to see what they had to say
They seem resigned to the fact they will lose staggs or cobbo

Look at the depth of talent, with Ben Te Kura, a 205cm giant, the latest off the production line. The Broncos have always been able in most cases to keep their young players.

 

[Betterdays22]

The right price has been mentioned by most supporting Tupou's return.

As for May, the post from Tigers, copied on previous page, is a great analysis.

If Gagai is available, he would be a good short term option. I am unsure as to whether he was at Souths when Richardson was CEO.

Agreed regarding May. I think Richo and Benji have made the same assessment. Gagai would be a solid get for a year or 2.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Agreed regarding May. I think Richo and Benji have made the same assessment. Gagai would be a solid get for a year or 2.

Gagai has always been ultra competitive.

 

[Halbrowne61]

Our ex girlfriends are some of the best in the game


From players to coaching staff / coaches.
We've populated the entire NRL with former employees / "ex girlfriends"

Your welcome NRL.

From Teddy to Papz, Moses, Addo Car, Coaches Ivan / Webster / Payten.

I'd take heaps of em back 😬😆

But not Tupou !

 

[Jimmy Jazz]

Gagai has always been ultra competitive.

Gagai has extended at the knights for another season. Need to look elsewhere

 

[The Chad]

Tupou is overrated with butter fingers to boot

Yes & no.

He was overrated when here & being relied on as our prime outside back.

As the 4th/5th/6th option? He's perfect.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

The right price has been mentioned by most supporting Tupou's return.

As for May, the post from Tigers, copied on previous page, is a great analysis.

If Gagai is available, he would be a good short term option. I am unsure as to whether he was at Souths when Richardson was CEO.

Tupou ... no no no no no (to use a Gus phrase).

Has too many errors, lack of effort (this is a big no) & body language is passive (we have tooo many of these types). Personally an older Isaac Tui'tupou on a train & trial is just as good. We'd need to pay somewhere close to $400k for Tupou, no bloody way.

Gagai for a season whilst Makasini & Laulilii develop isn't the worse option. Just don't think he'd come here for one season.

 

[Harvey]

Junior Tupou given permission to leave the Dolphins.

I would take him in a heartbeat as long as they are paying some freight

 

[The Chad]

He’s only mildly better than Kepaoa

I agree with you, but I feel like our meaning is slightly different.

Kepaoa as our 5th/6th/7th option is great value.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I agree with you, but I feel like our meaning is slightly different.

Kepaoa as our 5th/6th/7th option is great value.

He might be 5th/6th or 7th at a club like the Storm. Here he’d be in contention for a spot after one injury.

 

[gregjm87]

If we obliterate qld in round 2, Laurie can call up his reserves and stragglers for soo 3 and hopefully we could see some wests tigerage in the big show.

That said, @Tucker, theres now a case for AD to play origin for his kicking skills.

We cant chill out and think kicking is optional -unless billy chooses the same soul deprived team.

Lol, just because Cleary had an off night you don't bring in a sub par centre because he is handy off the tee. Particularly when Mitchell, Crichton and Lomax are all decent goal kickers.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

He might be 5th/6th or 7th at a club like the Storm. Here he’d be in contention for a spot after one injury.

Only take Tupou as a last resort G, if the intended targets fall through.

 

[Canadian Club]

Kini's new deal with the Gold Coast sounds like its more than 1million a season.

"Kini’s new mega deal will see him join the likes of elite NRL stars Reece Walsh, Kalyn Ponga, Nathan Cleary, Daly Cherry-Evans and Titans teammate Tino Fa’asuamaleaui."

That would mean Kini, Tino and Fifita are all on more than 1million a season, with Brimson and Campbell also on big money. Surely that means Fifita is headed elsewhere?

 

[The Chad]

He might be 5th/6th or 7th at a club like the Storm. Here he’d be in contention for a spot after one injury.

That would make him the 5th outside back....

I'd rather both Tupou & Kepaoa over Naden.