Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Nonotmeagain]

"The DV charge was only withdrawn because the prosecution witnesses didn’t come to court. It wasn’t withdrawn because the Police thought they didn’t have a case. They just couldn’t prove it."

It wouldn't be the first time that either party had to face the fact of providing the evidence under oath and under cross-examination - it's sort of confronting when you see the sentences for perjury.

 

[Kelce68]

Incase you aren’t aware, there are two of us. @batboy and I arguing the same point. So hardly contrarian.

Your points are tangential, and that is not a counter-argument, it's a red herring.

You have a well-established pattern of being a contrarian poster, as is your right. You do not need to be isolated to be so.

Try and keep up.

 

[jrtiger]

It’s hilarious how butthurt a lot of you are over this.
I never once saw this narrative from you or anyone else about this kid last year, he was the second coming of Fittler and could do no wrong.
Our recruitment is getting better but it’s still in deficit. We’ve lost more than we gained and of those we gained….
Luai - No where near earning his salary. Lost his Origin jersey for good reason.
May - excellent.
Turuva - really good, bordering on great at times.
Bird - average.
Hunt - lazy and ineffective
Skelton - good but missed twice as many games as he has played.
By my count we’ve had two really good wins in recruitment, and another 2 who could be great - one has to pull his finger out and the other needs to get healthy.
I’ll withhold judgement entirely until the season concludes but the hive mind opinion on here that our recruitment is kicking huge goals doesn’t hold much weight currently.

nice work trying to pile on when you, like GNR, completely missed the point. for such a high-level, pragmatic, conscientious businessman like you seem to tell everyone you are, you sure as hell know how to stir the pot when it's completely unnecessary.

Lachlan Galvin is a great player and I've never questioned his ability. feel free to go back and read my posts if you want. he'll do well, wherever he goes. the only 'narrative' that's been created is the one you've just tried to manufacture.

I'm disappointed with the fact that he's left the club, of course I am. he's a wonderful footballer. but we move on. it's time you did too.

 

[liltiger]

In Harold Matts it was Mason who was 5/8 when Galvin was second row but the point stands

Yeah sorry my bad, was schoolboys.

 

[iofthetigers]

A possible return by Junior Tupou now he has been given permission to explore his options?

 

[liltiger]

I’m not sure what happened at Westfields but Galvin played in the back row for one year in junior reps (Matt’s Cup). At that time, Latu Fainu was at Manly 🤷‍♂️

Your spot on, it was in schoolboys. But I cant get a team list from westfields sports high to confirm it. But pretty sure Latu was in the halves when Galvin was in the backrow. I could be wrong though.

 

[Kelce68]

Did you just compare him to the games best coach at the games best club who's probably been on a million a year or better the whole time?

Reckon a few players would prefer to pack shelves at Coles - Than move to Sydney, To play for the Tigers.

😂

Sure thing.

 

[Tucker]

state of origin u19’s is coming up this is zero tackles predicted team with a couple of our juniors !!! 🙂


1. Connor Votano (Newcastle Knights)
2. Aidan Gow (Newcastle Knights)
3. Heamasi Makasini (Wests Tigers)
4. Hayden Buchanan (St George Illawarra Dragons)
5. Luke Laulilii (Wests Tigers)
6. Mitchell Woods (Canterbury Bulldogs)
7. Toby Rodwell (Sydney Roosters)
8. Cody Hopwood (Newcastle Knights)
9. Jared Haywood (Wests Tigers)
10. Itula Seve (Sydney Roosters)
11. Jacob Halangahu (St George Illawarra Dragons)
12. Darcy Smith (Sydney Roosters)
13. Finau Latu (St George Illawarra Dragons)
14. Lorenzo Talataina (Parramatta Eels)
15. Cooper Clarke (Melbourne Storm)
16. Kaiden Lahrs (North Queensland Cowboys)
17. Ryda Talagi (Parramatta Eels)

That’s encouraging to have 3 out of the whole comp here.
We can’t stuff up their development.
Bring them in slowly and make sure they’re ready to go.
Congrats boys, hope you all make it.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Your points are tangential, and that is not a counter-argument, it's a red herring.

You have a well-established pattern of being a contrarian poster, as is your right. You do not need to be isolated to be so.

Try and keep up.

A contrarian would come into a thread like the Galvin thread and completely blow it up by defending him, saying he’s better off without the club. Yada yada yada. If you can find an instance where I have done that, go for it. That would be an example of saying something for the sake of it. There’s no opinion I give that I can’t justify or rationalise. I just take emotion out of the equation most of the time, which a lot of others don’t do at times. And because they can’t, they immediately think anything slightly left of status quo means you are against them or trying to rile them up. Forums like this are for die hards, so it’s no surprise they just accuse you of trying to get a reaction when you look at things from a different perspective.

 

[gregjm87]

Kaufusi for a season would be akin to Frizell. I'd take it. Still an effective player, although not as happy with him in the front row.

Gives us an edge in defence we don't have. Add KPP on the other side. Play big Sam in the middle.

That forward pack starts to look a little snarly.

Getting players on long term contracts sounds good- but we have that Godinet kid coming through, Broederlow, Sukkar- there HAS to be a path to 1st grade for these guys or you run the risk of losing them to other opportunities. So Kaufusi for a year or 2 might be a great bridge option. Maybe Frizell to play #13 as well?

I'm not against Frizell as a player (though again not sure he has much left) but I am against him as a leader/mentor. He is known as a guy who does everything right but is quiet as mouse and not suited to a mentor role.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

A possible return by Junior Tupou now he has been given permission to explore his options?

He would be good for our depth at the right price. I understood he received above market rate at the Dolphins and hopefully there will be a market correction.

 

[Tucker]

nice work trying to pile on when you, like GNR, completely missed the point. for such a high-level, pragmatic, conscientious businessman like you seem to tell everyone you are, you sure as hell know how to stir the pot when it's completely unnecessary.

Lachlan Galvin is a great player and I've never questioned his ability. feel free to go back and read my posts if you want. he'll do well, wherever he goes. the only 'narrative' that's been created is the one you've just tried to manufacture.

I'm disappointed with the fact that he's left the club, of course I am. he's a wonderful footballer. but we move on. it's time you did too.

I moved on weeks ago.
I do however enjoy laughing at you people who are so upset about a kid doing what he sees best for himself and wishing him the worst, calling his family every name under the sun and making up lies about him on your boring POS podcasts….you are a young bloke. Get a life FFS.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

He would be good for our depth at the right price. I understood he received above market rate at the Dolphins and hopefully there will be a market correction.

I can’t see him leaving the Dolphins. What club is going to want to pick up that contract? He couldn’t catch an STI in a brothel.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I can’t see him leaving the Dolphins. What club is going to want to pick up that contract? He couldn’t catch an STI in a brothel.

I read on this forum that he may be homesick. If true, it is a short drive from Campbelltown to the ACT.

 

[jrtiger]

I moved on weeks ago.
I do however enjoy laughing at you people who are so upset about a kid doing what he sees best for himself and wishing him the worst, calling his family every name under the sun and making up lies about him on you boring POS podcasts….you are a young bloke. Get a life FFS

you’re a miserable middle aged man openly dickriding a footballer who destabilised the very club you supposedly support. petty personal insults to try and pump up your fragile little ego won’t work here.

 

[Snidest 0]

you’re a miserable middle aged man openly dickriding a footballer who destabilised the very club you supposedly support. petty with personal insults to try and pump up your fragile little ego won’t work here.

Spot on!!

 

[KCtiger]

How do you know who they were pursued by? The only one Id say for sure would be Luai. The rest is just conjecture. Given how May seems to have been blackballed for Origin, whose to say other clubs didn’t take the same stance. Hunt definitely wasn’t pursued. He was retiring.

Luai was pursued by multiple clubs most notably us and the Dogs

Turuva had us and the dragons after him

May had us and the dogs after him

Makasini resigned when majority of the comp and rugby union wanted him

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Luai was pursued by multiple clubs most notably us and the Dogs

Yeah

Turuva had us and the dragons after him

If there is any club will are more appealing than

May had us and the dogs after him

Maybe

Makasini resigned when majority of the comp and rugby union wanted him

Not in the conversation. We’re talking established first graders.

 

[jrtiger]

Yeah

If there is any club will are more appealing than


Maybe

Not in the conversation. We’re talking established first graders.

you are hopeless 🤣

 

[KCtiger]

Yeah

If there is any club will are more appealing than


Maybe

Not in the conversation. We’re talking established first graders.

No maybe about it this article mentions multiple clubs interested in May

Terrell May signs three-year deal with Wests Tigers

The Tigers have edged out St George Illawarra for May’s services on a lucrative three-year deal that will see him remain at the joint venture club until at least the end of 2027.

www.smh.com.au