Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

BlackWhiteGold said:
Josh Feledy drops back to Jersey Flegg too this week.

EDIT: Tino Tavana returns on the wing in Flegg after an injury layoff.
Click to expand...
What do you reckon Feledys next move ?
He's top 30 and off contract.
Should he be kept as a flegg/ cup player or just let to explore opportunities elsewhere?

I haven't seen much progression from him.
 
Demps said:
What do you reckon Feledys next move ?
He's top 30 and off contract.
Should he be kept as a flegg/ cup player or just let to explore opportunities elsewhere?

I haven't seen much progression from him.
Click to expand...
Wouldn't be surprised if he finds another club before June 30. I think we have prioritised others in the centres.

He has progressed this season and offers good stats in NSW Cup but IMO his ceiling is not high. Could make a good squaddie at the Eels or Panthers.
 
Well if Benji is running with this team , he has lost the plot
Hunt should be on the bench and Staines has been good , doing a lot of dirty hit ups and getting zero good ball , gonna be a long game flogging ,
And Add Richo with his bullshit signings , zero for the nrl side who is struggling and only able to sign woman comp players , where are the signings for first grade nrl that he said we will be surprised , couple weeks , etc , not good enough from both Benji and Richo , it’s time to show what we have and both are failing , don’t write off the spoon again
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
Wouldn't be surprised if he finds another club before June 30. I think we have prioritised others in the centres.

He has progressed this season and offers good stats in NSW Cup but IMO his ceiling is not high. Could make a good squaddie at the Eels or Panthers.
Click to expand...

Lot of hype about this kid Feledy when they got him from Manly a few years back ….another one that has failed to be developed at the WT
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
Wouldn't be surprised if he finds another club before June 30. I think we have prioritised others in the centres.

He has progressed this season and offers good stats in NSW Cup but IMO his ceiling is not high. Could make a good squaddie at the Eels or Panthers.
Click to expand...
I can see him being like a Marion Seve type, who plays 20-30 games between the ages of 27-30 after toiling in the lower grades .
I think he should to the goldy play a couple of years for Burleigh or Tweed Heads , and just develop himself .
He’s like a poor man’s Bradman Best . Including the bad defence and tuning out without anywhere near the consistent impact with the ball . He’s got talent, but yea , I think he’s honestly 2-3 years away .
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
Wouldn't be surprised if he finds another club before June 30. I think we have prioritised others in the centres.

He has progressed this season and offers good stats in NSW Cup but IMO his ceiling is not high. Could make a good squaddie at the Eels or Panthers.
Click to expand...
No -one is gonna pick him up...just too small too slow
Same as Tumeth
Unfortunately we need to move on from these never to be first graders
KOE shld be the province of genuine 1st grade back ups ,or high potential juniors with the high likelihood of moving up the next step
 
clontarfkid said:
No -one is gonna pick him up...just too small too slow
Same as Tumeth
Unfortunately we need to move on from these never to be first graders
KOE shld be the province of genuine 1st grade back ups ,or high potential juniors with the high likelihood of moving up the next step
Click to expand...
I’m not disagreeing with you as to what he turned into .. but at one time as a junior Feledy did have some wraps and played U19 for NSW …the previous admin poached him from Manly and probably had to offer him a Top 30 to deal to acquire him … club just needs to get better picking some of these kids
 
Demps said:
What do you reckon Feledys next move ?
He's top 30 and off contract.
Should he be kept as a flegg/ cup player or just let to explore opportunities elsewhere?

I haven't seen much progression from him.
Click to expand...
Its interesting isn't it that if a player stays in Flegg and stars we would think he is a star of the future but a player the same age who has played almost exlclusively NSW cup or NRL for the last 2 years we all (including me) think he is done. Mayby its just part of his development although I think his arms are too short 🙂
 
Tom Shines said:
I’m not disagreeing with you as to what he turned into .. but at one time as a junior Feledy did have some wraps and played U19 for NSW …the previous admin poached him from Manly and probably had to offer him a Top 30 to deal to acquire him … club just needs to get better picking some of these kids
Click to expand...
All true..but we tend not to focus on attributes which will enable the next step to NRL..Speed/size/work rate/athletism...KPIs that can predict their future
Dont tell me Bellamy doesnt do just that.. not a science..but basic footy smarts
Not in abundance at WTs pre Richo
 
Bellend said:
Josh Feledy has reached his ceiling at the Tigers time to cut and move on for both parties.
Click to expand...
Probably true, but it was close to his best game of the season last weekend, he was very strong with all his carries.
Does he look like being a regular NRL player ? At this stage probably not as a centre as he looks a touch too slow to compensate for his lack of size.
I would be advising him to try and add about 5kgs of muscle and then see how he goes as an attack minded back rower in the Euan Aitken mould.
 
Last edited:
With feledy i have seen a few people say he has improved a fair bit this year. If that's the case he is crazy young surely you keep him over a naden or a faatape. Or are we saying he hasn't improved at all?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 634 (members: 41, guests: 593)
Back
Top