Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Vicious]

Was thinking wonder if there could be a consideration to let Seyfarth explore other options? With 3 new 2nd rowers incoming and previous interest from other clubs could he be surplus to requirements if they see others ahead of him? Free up a spot to go for a quality front rower??

There are no quality front rowers available and Seyfarth will now be part of our middles rotation.
He always does his job when playing as a middle coming off the bench, he was only starting on an edge as we had virtually no other options.

 

[Tito Santana]

Trey Mooney

He’s at the Raiders

 

[bptiger 0]

He’s at the Raiders

Think he has signed by the knights , I would have liked it if we had made a offer

 

[supercoach]

He’s at the Raiders

And talk he has signed with the Knights, but would be a great signing for us if he is still talking to clubs

 

[Leica_Tiger]

And talk he has signed with the Knights, but would be a great signing for us if he is still talking to clubs

I agree he is just what we need, mobile and tough plus not a “big name big pay packet” who could detract from our maturing pack.
Also think he could slot into lock to start games with Latu taking over to create havoc.
Hope Richo has this guy or similar in mind

 

[tigerballs]

Think he has signed by the knights , I would have liked it if we had made a offer

Depending on who's coaching next season.

 

[bptiger 0]

Depending on who's coaching next season.

He would be a good pick up

 

[Wiz]

Depending on who's coaching next season.

Who is an Issac Moses managed coach who could take over from the to be sacked Isaac Managed Adam O’Brien?

 

[innsaneink]

Who is an Issac Moses managed coach who could take over from the to be sacked Isaac Managed Adam O’Brien?

I dont know.
Who?

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

What’s this fixation with people constantly repeating that Brooks will be the main man cos DCE is gone. Do you not realise they have signed Fogarty? You see, Manly figured out in a year, what we couldn’t in 10. He is not a halfback or an organiser. He’s a runner. They probably already knew that when they signed him.

brooks will be ar St Merge if they can work out a deal

 

[tigertragic]

Who is an Issac Moses managed coach who could take over from the to be sacked Isaac Managed Adam O’Brien?

Most Issac Moses coaches aren’t travelling to well at the moment

Newcastle's Adam O'Brien, St George Illawarra's Shane Flanagan, Manly's Anthony Seibold, New Zealand's Andrew Webster and North Queensland's Todd Payten – on his books

 

[Lukic]

Brooks should probably head to the ESL. Not really sure what team would take him on. He's gonna be 32 next year at best is a fringe first grader at this point.

 

[Odessa]

Brooks should probably head to the ESL. Not really sure what team would take him on. He's gonna be 32 next year at best is a fringe first grader at this point.

Apart from a few game's I think he has gone backwards

 

[Tiger_Yoshi]

Brooks should probably head to the ESL. Not really sure what team would take him on. He's gonna be 32 next year at best is a fringe first grader at this point.

Do we really care anymore about Brooks and how his form is....he has shown the cliub made the right decision to let him go

 

[Wiz]

I dont know.
Who?

I don’t know either, but Isaac controls the club at present and no doubt he will want to slot another coach he manages in there. Maybe Isaac has some good assistant coaches ready to step up? Or I wonder if with Peter Parr becoming the new GM at Newcastle he will seek to cut the cord with Issac like the Broncos did when they got rid of Siebold.

 

[Odessa]

Do we really care anymore about Brooks and how his form is....he has shown the cliub made the right decision to let him go

Brooks should have had a better career should have been made 5/8 at the beginning of his career in the NRL

 

[Halbrowne61]

Brooks should have had a better career should have been made 5/8 at the beginning of his career in the NRL

Isn’t that where he started,with Moses as 7, way back when they were an upcoming dynamic duo at the Tigers ?
Think he moved to 7 after Moses left but my memory fading .

 

[ancient_magpie]

Brooks should have had a better career should have been made 5/8 at the beginning of his career in the NRL

Agree i said that 10 years ago I think blame Sheens.

 

[watersider]

Brooks should have had a better career should have been made 5/8 at the beginning of his career in the NRL

He's really no better as a 5/8 than he was as a halfback. I don't really agree. I think he's a below average half wherever you play him. The problem with him at 5/8 is that he stifles backline movements when the ball has gone wide with always taking the wrong option. He gets more chances to run out wide but I think he's more threatening as a runner through the middle. But wherever he plays he reads the game really poorly so he makes errors and misses opportunities and never knows when best to make the play. That's why I sort of think he's just as good (or bad) at halfback. If you could pair him with a 5/8 like Munster maybe he'd be better at half than his current form as a 5/8.

Irrespective, there are very few halves in the NRL who you'd say are worse than him, and half of them play for Newcastle.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

He really is that ex girlfriend people can’t let go of, despite claiming they are better off.