Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

both of them have certainly fallen away. not worried about Fonua, he's 23 and still learning how to play 24+ games in grade. Hunt by all reports had some serious issues with his ribs.

don't mind Vaalepu. been around a long time and done a decent apprenticeship in QCup and in a handful of games for Melbourne. 27 next year, you'd be banking on him coming into his prime.
Vaalepu is an interesting one, has all the physical traits to be a good middle, is in what is supposed to be the best system in the NRL. What i have seen of him when he played first grade he looks very good, yet they seem to keep recruiting props to keep him out of the team....anyone watch enough QLD cup to offer an opinion?
 
I disagree …They have got AD as an option if need be , and only 1 hooker … could you imagine what happens if Api gets a serious injury early next season? Season would be derailed
Fair point TS. It's just the whole 'rob Peter to pay Paul' scenario. Yes AD would be the ideal depth right centre if To'a is injured but what happens if he's killing it at lock or half next season. I guess another unknown is whether Benji feels Makasini, Turuva, Bird or even Skelton are options at right centre.

Good teams have at least 2 NRL quality outside backs for each position (wing, centre, left & right) so if, touch wood it doesn't happen, say 2 of our first choice OBs are out for an extended period, we don't lose much.

Here's hoping Max Taotua & Tino Turuva take a giant leap forward next season too to throw themselves into the equation.
 
I disagree …They have got AD as an option if need be , and only 1 hooker … could you imagine what happens if Api gets a serious injury early next season? Season would be derailed
AD will be playing 13. with the size he'll be required to put on he's going to be more of a backrower than he is a centre. Saukuru's also converted to the edge. we're losing Feledy, Faataape, Staines and likely Naden from the 30, Olam too if you count him. Makasini and May are getting upgrades, but as you can see, we're light on.

Richardson showed his hand when TDS left. he re-signed Hope that week. they obviously think that with Hope, Murray and Haywood that there's enough there. if we can sign a Havili that'd be ideal, but I think they've done their shopping at 9 for the time being.
 
How good has Taylan been playing after so long out of the game he walked into the side and owned his position straight away his defense is great and is really dangerous with the ball.

500k per season is a bargain for the club if the news is true, let's hope his demons are well and truly in the rear-view mirror.

This is an example of a player getting an opportunity and his class shows that's where he belongs, hits the road running.
Now here's hoping Makasini shows us we have another blueblood this weekend, if so, our backline is very exciting for next season.
 
AD will be playing 13. with the size he'll be required to put on he's going to be more of a backrower than he is a centre. Saukuru's also converted to the edge. we're losing Feledy, Faataape, Staines and likely Naden from the 30, Olam too if you count him. Makasini and May are getting upgrades, but as you can see, we're light on.

Richardson showed his hand when TDS left. he re-signed Hope that week. they obviously think that with Hope, Murray and Haywood that there's enough there. if we can sign a Havili that'd be ideal, but I think they've done their shopping at 9 for the time being.
It's somewhat disappointing whatever has gone down between the club & Bud Sullivan too, obviously partially to get his $500K+ off our books with the halves we already have. But he would almost be the ideal bench player to play 15-20 mins at dummy half to give Api a break. The problem is his 2nd positional cover would be in the halves which we'll likely have AD/Latu on the bench to cover.

Off on a tangent here, I wonder whether a Seyfarth has the capability of playing dummy half in short stints. He has the tank & ball skills, whether he has the long passing game both sides in his repertoire for this like Charlie Murray has.
 
So am I idk what's going on atm but that should never of happened. Sorry wrong thread but couldn't resist . Still filthy.
They went all in on Ronaldo and tore apart an awesome team to afford him, been in decline ever since, now they're trying to build a winning team on value transfers. We can thank that muppet Andrea Agnelli for this disaster he caused all this. Elkan as well for allowing it as the owner. Sorry wrong thread. I'll stop now.
 
It's somewhat disappointing whatever has gone down between the club & Bud Sullivan too, obviously partially to get his $500K+ off our books with the halves we already have. But he would almost be the ideal bench player to play 15-20 mins at dummy half to give Api a break. The problem is his 2nd positional cover would be in the halves which we'll likely have AD/Latu on the bench to cover.

Off on a tangent here, I wonder whether a Seyfarth has the capability of playing dummy half in short stints. He has the tank & ball skills, whether he has the long passing game both sides in his repertoire for this like Charlie Murray has.
agree on Bud but his salary's just too high to carry on the bench. think he's better off at Souths where he's a good chance of being Cody's successor.

Seyfarth could but I'd probably steer clear.
 
AD will be playing 13. with the size he'll be required to put on he's going to be more of a backrower than he is a centre. Saukuru's also converted to the edge. we're losing Feledy, Faataape, Staines and likely Naden from the 30, Olam too if you count him. Makasini and May are getting upgrades, but as you can see, we're light on.

Richardson showed his hand when TDS left. he re-signed Hope that week. they obviously think that with Hope, Murray and Haywood that there's enough there. if we can sign a Havili that'd be ideal, but I think they've done their shopping at 9 for the

Half the board has got AD as the starting 7 next season …not the 13 …

If we have to rely on Hope next year as starting 9, I expect other teams to exploit him …just like they do other depth we have put up this year at various times eg Naden …

Murray and Haywood are unproven as NRL 9’s and are development players next season ..so does that mean they are unavailable for NRL selection until late in the season ?
 
Yep, Latu is not a right-sided 1/2, not now and probably not ever. We just re-signed an ex Junior in Andrews = d'ya reckon his parents said - oh, we don't mind if our MOM U/18 QLD SOO halfback is 2nd fiddle behind outstanding young 5/8 Latu? Latu will be our long-term 5/8 and Andrews will be our 1/2 come 2028 after Luai leads us to the GF in 2026 & 27 and settles into a mentor role for those kids.
You do realise Andrews played 5/8 and was completely outplayed by his halfback, up until the half got a concussion with 10 to go and then he started contributing...?

Andrews is most definitely a running 5/8, fullback or centre. At least at this stage
 
I appreciate you can only play AD at one position…but at least he can play at an NRL level at Center …. They have other options at 7 ( Latu ) and 13( Twal and others) ..

Will you be happy relying on Hope as starting 9 is Api is out ? Major red flag for me …
Fair point TS. It's just the whole 'rob Peter to pay Paul' scenario. Yes AD would be the ideal depth right centre if To'a is injured but what happens if he's killing it at lock or half next season. I guess another unknown is whether Benji feels Makasini, Turuva, Bird or even Skelton are options at right centre.

Good teams have at least 2 NRL quality outside backs for each position (wing, centre, left & right) so if, touch wood it doesn't happen, say 2 of our first choice OBs are out for an extended period, we don't lose much.

Here's hoping Max Taotua & Tino Turuva take a giant leap forward next season too to throw themselves into the equation.
 
I appreciate you can only play AD at one position…but at least he can play at an NRL level at Center …. They have other options at 7 ( Latu ) and 13( Twal and others) ..

Will you be happy relying on Hope as starting 9 is Api is out ? Major red flag for me …
With another big pre-season I think Hope can develop to be Api's understudy next season. He is one of the best hookers in NSW Cup.

But proviso is, we do need another hooker utility as you say. Murray is still unproven & Haywood's body won't be ready for another 12 months.

Once Bud is officially off our books, we have 3 spots left in our top 30 (maybe more depending on Bird) so a Siliva Havili would be ideal to rotate with Hope in the scenario that Api misses.
 
With another big pre-season I think Hope can develop to be Api's understudy next season. He is one of the best hookers in NSW Cup.

But proviso is, we do need another hooker utility as you say. Murray is still unproven & Haywood's body won't be ready for another 12 months.

Once Bud is officially off our books, we have 3 spots left in our top 30 (maybe more depending on Bird) so a Siliva Havili would be ideal to rotate with Hope in the scenario that Api misses.

Let’s see what the plan is…

If Hope ends up as the back up Hooker plan …let’s Hope for the best that his requirement for NRL time is limited … still would feel better with another option …

The squad is unbalanced in a couple of areas… hooker and outside backs shortage …oversupply of back rowers … need a bigger name in the middle
 
Half the board has got AD as the starting 7 next season …not the 13 …

If we have to rely on Hope next year as starting 9, I expect other teams to exploit him …just like they do other depth we have put up this year at various times eg Naden …

Murray and Haywood are unproven as NRL 9’s and are development players next season ..so does that mean they are unavailable for NRL selection until late in the season ?
I think Latu will be given every opportunity to play halfback with AD to do the bulk of his reps at 13. they might decide Latu isn't ready by R1 but it's prolonging the inevitable.

Hope got smashed by Penrith but he's had other games where he's done well. not worth writing him off yet and the club clearly thinks as much.

Development players can play from R1. I anticipate Haywood will probably start the year in Cup and begin to work his way up. I don't think he's too far off pending he can get used to the contact in the senior grades.
 
The fact it's a one-year deal leads me to believe it might be akin to the Daine Laurie situation...no space today, however 2027 we can find you a slot. For the Panthers its a win/win...comes to the Tigers and kills it, they get him back, comes here and stinks it up...sorry Mav that spot has not opened up for you.
Don't forget Perth come in 2027. So it may be a case where Mav wanted options to head there if he goes ok for us too
 
you don't rate him I take it?
Everyone would rate him higher if he could get through a season with no injuries, that's the only drawback.

When he's sound his form is good but when he tries to play with niggles his game suffers in defense and attack, some players can push through it, but he seems not able to.
 
Back
Top