Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[PJ_]

If I could trade Mbye for Watson it would be a no brainer

I’d trade Mbye for a packet of burger rings


Mmmm burger rings

Yum

 

[Mighty Mouse]

I hope it’s now very obvious to everyone that it was an appalling decision to let go of Marshall. A huge influence both on and off the field and now we have nothing. On ya madgey

 

[Needaname]

Signing suggestion.

Mark Nicholls currently at South Sydney.
Off contract this year / can be signed anytime.
31 years old.
98 first grade games.
Part of 3 clubs a recently strong South Sydney Squad
A premiership Melbourne side in 2017 and the Raiders.
Career bench player and won’t cost the earth.
Has a good attitude. Plays with a good level of toughness and awareness.
95% tackle efficiency.

https://www.rugbyleagueproject.org/players/mark-nicholls/summary.html

https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/rabbitohs/mark-nicholls/

 

[TYGA]

I hope it’s now very obvious to everyone that it was an appalling decision to let go of Marshall. A huge influence both on and off the field and now we have nothing. On ya madgey

Marshall’s time was up. He’s good for a few games or off the bench. He wasn’t going to accept that role at the tigers.

 

[TYGA]

Signing suggestion.

Mark Nicholls currently at South Sydney.
Off contract this year / can be signed anytime.
31 years old.
98 first grade games.
Part of 3 clubs a recently strong South Sydney Squad
A premiership Melbourne side in 2017 and the Raiders.
Career bench player and won’t cost the earth.
Has a good attitude. Plays with a good level of toughness and awareness.
95% tackle efficiency.

https://www.rugbyleagueproject.org/players/mark-nicholls/summary.html

https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/rabbitohs/mark-nicholls/

All time plodder makes Tamou look like
Gordon Tallis.

 

[Needaname]

Signing suggestion.

Mark Nicholls currently at South Sydney.
Off contract this year / can be signed anytime.
31 years old.
98 first grade games.
Part of 3 clubs a recently strong South Sydney Squad
A premiership Melbourne side in 2017 and the Raiders.
Career bench player and won’t cost the earth.
Has a good attitude. Plays with a good level of toughness and awareness.
95% tackle efficiency.

https://www.rugbyleagueproject.org/players/mark-nicholls/summary.html

https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/rabbitohs/mark-nicholls/

All time plodder makes Tamou look like
Gordon Tallis.

A plodder that gets picked every week in a top 4 side.
I’m not saying his a star. I’m saying his an option to add a fair bit of experience for a small amount.

 

[Demps]

Signing suggestion.

Mark Nicholls currently at South Sydney.
Off contract this year / can be signed anytime.
31 years old.
98 first grade games.
Part of 3 clubs a recently strong South Sydney Squad
A premiership Melbourne side in 2017 and the Raiders.
Career bench player and won’t cost the earth.
Has a good attitude. Plays with a good level of toughness and awareness.
95% tackle efficiency.

https://www.rugbyleagueproject.org/players/mark-nicholls/summary.html

https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/rabbitohs/mark-nicholls/

Wow

No thanks.

 

[izotope]

Signing suggestion.

Mark Nicholls currently at South Sydney.
Off contract this year / can be signed anytime.
31 years old.
98 first grade games.
Part of 3 clubs a recently strong South Sydney Squad
A premiership Melbourne side in 2017 and the Raiders.
Career bench player and won’t cost the earth.
Has a good attitude. Plays with a good level of toughness and awareness.
95% tackle efficiency.

https://www.rugbyleagueproject.org/players/mark-nicholls/summary.html

https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/rabbitohs/mark-nicholls/

Kind feel thats our whole forward pack

 

[jadtiger]

I hope it’s now very obvious to everyone that it was an appalling decision to let go of Marshall. A huge influence both on and off the field and now we have nothing. On ya madgey

Not at all it was overdue to let him go

 

[Needaname]

Signing suggestion.

Mark Nicholls currently at South Sydney.
Off contract this year / can be signed anytime.
31 years old.
98 first grade games.
Part of 3 clubs a recently strong South Sydney Squad
A premiership Melbourne side in 2017 and the Raiders.
Career bench player and won’t cost the earth.
Has a good attitude. Plays with a good level of toughness and awareness.
95% tackle efficiency.

https://www.rugbyleagueproject.org/players/mark-nicholls/summary.html

https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/rabbitohs/mark-nicholls/

Wow

No thanks.

The thing is.
This is what your going to get if your aiming for ‘a couple of players between 100 to 150 games’
Your going to get players between 25 - 30 years of age.
Your wanting to add a mix into the younger roster we have for balance.
Everyone wants a standout player with experience but unless your willing to spend some money your not going to get that.
I’ve just been reviewing top teams in a given year and these no nonsense players are a big part of them.
We really need a hard hitter more so than a solid defender especially with Twal in the side being able to assume that role, if we get Pangai as that player, we need a couple of these hard props.

 

[hobbo1]

Cameron Munster..

He’s cooked

 

[Tiger5150]

Cameron Munster..

He’s cooked

baked more likely

 

[Russell]

@Pawsandclaws rasied this in the Pangai thread and I think its worth a run in the actual Signings thread.

What about Ash Taylor alongside Brooks?

I know it seems counter intuitive and he seems on the outer but this guy is talented and IMO his strengths compliment Brooks. On his day one of the best kicking games in the comp, great pass. Is he an organiser?

I know it seems left field but I actually think it could work. I watched him tear us apart at Leichhardt a few years ago,

Absolute No from me.

 

[TheDaBoss]

I hope it’s now very obvious to everyone that it was an appalling decision to let go of Marshall. A huge influence both on and off the field and now we have nothing. On ya madgey

Oh come on not this again

 

[tony soprano]

I hope it’s now very obvious to everyone that it was an appalling decision to let go of Marshall. A huge influence both on and off the field and now we have nothing. On ya madgey

Oh come on not this again

Soon potter will be brought up again ?

 

[Russell]

I hope it’s now very obvious to everyone that it was an appalling decision to let go of Marshall. A huge influence both on and off the field and now we have nothing. On ya madgey

Mate give it a rest - he is gone and hopefully NEVER coming back!!!!!

Smartest decision Madge ever made.

 

[claws1]

Potter walked past me this morning at Austinmer Beach, he lives here. Go Weststigers!

 

[tigerap]

Potter walked past me this morning at Austinmer Beach, he lives here. Go Weststigers!

1.5meters?

 

[Camel2281]

If I could trade Mbye for Watson it would be a no brainer

I’d trade Mbye for a packet of burger rings

I'd trade M'Bye and give the buyer Burger rings on top. Worst value signing in the NRL

 

[Camel2281]

We've got enough guys who don't have a proper position, Watson is another one of those. He's okay but not sure he's necessary at the moment if we have Hastings and Mbye next year

Even if we get stuck with M'Bye next year I'd sign Watson. We don't owe Moses a first grade spot and he definitely doesn't deserve to be in first grade. Watson is the ideal modern 13/14. Hastings and Brooks will be our halves with AD in the centres. Moses should leave or play KOE