Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[tigerman 0]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney

My thoughts are that hooker is way down the list of priorities for WT right now. We have a gun in Liddle and a fine prospect in Simpkins. How many hookers do we need?

And don’t forget SimpkiN

 

[GNR4LIFE]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney

My thoughts are that hooker is way down the list of priorities for WT right now. We have a gun in Liddle and a fine prospect in Simpkins. How many hookers do we need?

I’ve always thought if we want a hooker so bad, why not go for Mahoney. I’d rather pay 800 for him than 500 for Hodgson.

 

[240z]

Look at our spine.. Gun fullback, great five eighth with Doueihi, promising half Hastings and you got Liddle.. who? Need a better no.9 he's coming..

Laurie is not a gun fullback, he is a fullback that’s shows a ton of promise
Doueihi is not a great no6, rather a solid six having his second knee job in a few years
Hasting, we have no idea what he will produce in the NRL. My guess he will go ok but not sure he will be great.

Great summation @Supercoach

 

[240z]

Seyfarth Elliot

In for a big year I think...

Hopefully the Cedars pick him for the WC too.

I didn't realise he had a Lebanese background, with red hair I would have thought more Scottish
Either way he is a good prospect and I would be happy to see another international on the club honours board

 

[Camel2281]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney

My thoughts are that hooker is way down the list of priorities for WT right now. We have a gun in Liddle and a fine prospect in Simpkins. How many hookers do we need?

Liddle is not a Gun. He's unfit and has a poor passing game

 

[Demps]

Seyfarth Elliot

In for a big year I think...

Hopefully the Cedars pick him for the WC too.


I didn't realise he had a Lebanese background, with red hair I would have thought more Scottish
Either way he is a good prospect and I would be happy to see another international on the club honours board

He's the Lebanese Viking.
His mother is Lebanese.

Interesting eh

 

[yeahcaz]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney


Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

Lol how ? Mahoney is arguably a top 3 hooker in the comp and if you don’t think top 3, he’s definitely top 5 and he’s 23. Sign him for 2023 and you’d have him in the prime of his career, around our young and improving forward pack. He’d have already played for Queensland if parra weren’t so stupid. 600k is a bargain and id honestly offer 700 off the bat

Mahoney is a fraud. Leave it

Leave yourself ? watch something other than the dross our team puts up every week.

 

[Demps]

Mahoney is a star.

He'd be playing 9 for Qld if it wasn't for..

... Harry Grant.

 

[TigerWest]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney

My thoughts are that hooker is way down the list of priorities for WT right now. We have a gun in Liddle and a fine prospect in Simpkins. How many hookers do we need?

Liddle is not a Gun. He's unfit and has a poor passing game

How have you concluded that Liddell is not fit?

 

[JC99]

Seyfarth Elliot

In for a big year I think...

Hopefully the Cedars pick him for the WC too.


I didn't realise he had a Lebanese background, with red hair I would have thought more Scottish
Either way he is a good prospect and I would be happy to see another international on the club honours board

He's the Lebanese Viking.
His mother is Lebanese.

Interesting eh

Everyone you like is suddenly Lebanese Demps ?

 

[Demps]

Seyfarth Elliot

In for a big year I think...

Hopefully the Cedars pick him for the WC too.


I didn't realise he had a Lebanese background, with red hair I would have thought more Scottish
Either way he is a good prospect and I would be happy to see another international on the club honours board

He's the Lebanese Viking.
His mother is Lebanese.

Interesting eh

Everyone you like is suddenly Lebanese Demps ?

Big fan of Beirut Boy and new recruit.
isaiah papali'i
??

 

[Viking Warrior]

I know some are happy with Liddle but the club ritely or wrongly has identified hooker as a position we need to strengthen. Liddle needs to be able to play 80 imo

 

[bathursttiger1]

Mahoney is a star.

He'd be playing 9 for Qld if it wasn't for..

... Harry Grant.

Is he Lebanese? LOL

 

[Demps]

Mahoney is a star.

He'd be playing 9 for Qld if it wasn't for..

... Harry Grant.

Is he Lebanese? LOL

Reid Mohammed Mahoney
??

 

[nrlsurvivor]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney

My thoughts are that hooker is way down the list of priorities for WT right now. We have a gun in Liddle and a fine prospect in Simpkins. How many hookers do we need?

I’ve always thought if we want a hooker so bad, why not go for Mahoney. I’d rather pay 800 for him than 500 for Hodgson.

If we go for Mahoney it sends a message to Simpkin that he’s not wanted. Hodgson acts as as a bridge until Simpkin is ready to take the reigns.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney

My thoughts are that hooker is way down the list of priorities for WT right now. We have a gun in Liddle and a fine prospect in Simpkins. How many hookers do we need?

I’ve always thought if we want a hooker so bad, why not go for Mahoney. I’d rather pay 800 for him than 500 for Hodgson.

If we go for Mahoney it sends a message to Simpkin that he’s not wanted. Hodgson acts as as a bridge until Simpkin is ready to take the reigns.

Simpkin is still unknown. Mahoney is one of the best 9’s in the game

 

[tiger05premier]

It does matter what he’s on in Canberra we just need to put a value on him and offer that much. We don’t need to clean up their cap mess

They have.. but it appears Canberra won’t stump up the difference which is the sticking point..

Now the choice seems to be either increase our offer or move on..

Time to move on than

 

[Camel2281]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney

My thoughts are that hooker is way down the list of priorities for WT right now. We have a gun in Liddle and a fine prospect in Simpkins. How many hookers do we need?

Liddle is not a Gun. He's unfit and has a poor passing game

How have you concluded that Liddell is not fit?

The fact he's completely gassed every week 29 minutes in.