Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Bones said:
You can have it both ways. That’s what good team do. You don’t see top teams refuse to sign players because their juniors might come good in 3 years.

We have young guys like Pole, Matamua etc that are developing, but we also need some experience to guide them, on and off the field. How many times do you need to see our front rowers run for 50-60m a game and get completely dominated before you add some starch?

Klemmer also won Newcastles players player, so the guys who are actually in the trenches with him think he is their best. That’s in a team that has the Saifiti twins, Ponga and Frizell too, who would all walk straight into our side.
Click to expand...
I must be missing something with Klemmer.
If he signs and adds something to our rebuild and gets us outta the doldrums I’ll happily eat humble pie.
I just don’t see the need to waste time/money on a bloke who’s best years are behind him, Packer, Mataluino, Tamou.
I’ve read this thread for years now, spewing out babble of poor signings, bloke coming for their pension checks, if he’s not one of them I don’t what is.
 
teddy23 said:
Dom Young is good - however it’ll be a dog fight for him and don’t think wingers right now is something we desperately need or should overpay for

Think we should prioritise what’s going on with our spine for the next 12 months, then we can look at polishing up our backline giving our young kids like Asu Kepoua, Naden, Talau, To’a another season to showcase what they can do and working around that - that’s ignoring both Nofa and Ken who are premium wingers

Just my thoughts
Click to expand...
Must admit whenever I watched him for the Knights, seemed to drop the ball, very hot and cold. Then, after his games for England, I see he is 6’ 7’’ , 107 kgs and quick! Clearly he is progressing - we could definitely use him. Yes we need good forwards as a priority but we need players that have the will to never say die and have a good hard crack at winning the contest. Something lacking sadly recently.
 
Balmainian said:
I must be missing something with Klemmer.
If he signs and adds something to our rebuild and gets us outta the doldrums I’ll happily eat humble pie.
I just don’t see the need to waste time/money on a bloke who’s best years are behind him, Packer, Mataluino, Tamou.
I’ve read this thread for years now, spewing out babble of poor signings, bloke coming for their pension checks, if he’s not one of them I don’t what is.
Click to expand...
Packer came out of jail. Matulino had a dodgy knee. Tamou was way past it and overrated anyway.

Klemmer is 28. Fit. And keen
 
Packer , Matilino ,Ballin and Tamou were all really bad signings of aging former stars who were just after another year or two of good money before retirement
Dire Straights wrote song about it " money for nothing "
Re Klemmer at first I thought NO not again ! But surprised he only 28 it seems like he's need around forever but if fit maybe he's the exception
 
Thaiger said:
Must admit whenever I watched him for the Knights, seemed to drop the ball, very hot and cold. Then, after his games for England, I see he is 6’ 7’’ , 107 kgs and quick! Clearly he is progressing - we could definitely use him. Yes we need good forwards as a priority but we need players that have the will to never say die and have a good hard crack at winning the contest. Something lacking sadly recently.
Click to expand...
Good post. I've read at least one comment where Young is referred to as a winger. I believe this undersells his ability. I know he plays on the wing but he is a gamebreaker, an x factor player with the ability to finish when others cannot.
 
Stevec said:
Packer , Matilino ,Ballin and Tamou were all really bad signings of aging former stars who were just after another year or two of good money before retirement
Dire Straights wrote song about it " money for nothing "
Re Klemmer at first I thought NO not again ! But surprised he only 28 it seems like he's need around forever but if fit maybe he's the exception
Click to expand...

For 2-3 years Klemmer should be good value (depending on dollars) but i would be very wary of a 4th year
 
TigerSkins said:
Saw this half playing for Tonga this morning and he looks the goods .. maybe we should have a crack at him .. his name is Tiu Lolohea .. even kicked some shocking kicks at goal .. 🤣🤣🤣
Click to expand...
There is alot of talented players that don't kick on it seemed at times his stomach was more important then playing NRL I watched him in junior football and he was a stand out I think having beers and eating KFC is a problem for some players
 
Bones said:
You can have it both ways. That’s what good team do. You don’t see top teams refuse to sign players because their juniors might come good in 3 years.

We have young guys like Pole, Matamua etc that are developing, but we also need some experience to guide them, on and off the field. How many times do you need to see our front rowers run for 50-60m a game and get completely dominated before you add some starch?

Klemmer also won Newcastles players player, so the guys who are actually in the trenches with him think he is their best. That’s in a team that has the Saifiti twins, Ponga and Frizell too, who would all walk straight into our side.
Click to expand...
Diane Laurie got our players player this year.
Not much more to say really.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 214 (members: 12, guests: 202)
Back
Top