Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

We have not had a youngster carry so much expectation since Jake Mullaney was carving up the 20’s
What a name what a flashback he was called the next big thing I remember a interview with him and his mum and it was an eye opener the mum was talking like he had played 100 first grade games and MOM in the GF it was crazy the cart before the horse 🐎 was miles Infront
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Just one question, what do you suspect caused us to go from 66-18 winners against the Cowboys to 0-74 some 6 weeks later? The easy answer is injuries to two key players, but that would be papering over cracks.

If you think Joffa is not part of that, well let’s just agree to disagree.
I actually think these things have far more variables than people like to admit.

For example (obvious ones too) -

1) Api out - not only is he our best player and captain, but he leads the tempo in defence, whether it's line speed or kick chase, he mops up ineffective tackles around the middle and facilitates more metres in attack (I'm underselling his contribution here)

2) Brooks out - On form, our best runner and kicker of the football. Our best attacking threat this year. Solid edge defender. Has the capacity, on occasion, to alter momentum.

3) Momentum. The modern game is a momentum machine. The best defensive sides disrupt momentum either through pressure or suffocation. It sounds like a lazy analysis, but it can get away from you in a game. If you get the jump early, points can come thick and fast. Cows built momentum and didn't slow it down. Even we, several times this year, have rode momentum heavily. The Dogs, Canberra and Cows first game just to name a few.

4) Attitude. Both us and the cows. They were inverted from last game. They wanted revenge and we, I think, have been looking around the sheds a little bit more lately pre game and dropping our heads. The Canberra game and the Brooks/Api injuries have cruelled belief and subsequently attitude.

5) Luck. Last time, we got every bounce of the ball, this time, we couldn't buy good fortune. Knock ons into certain tries. No look hail Mary passes finding hands. Balls bouncing at 90 degrees into a chasing prop's arms, key forward passes being missed. It was their night and it all fell their way.

6) Combinations. Our edges have been decimated, both by injuries and selections. The edge - half - centre link is the most important in rugby league defensive structures, and we had a new centre combination (again), a new five eighth, Bateman in the middle rather than on an edge, and both Papali'i on a different side and Blore coming in for just a handful on games each.

I think there's several other considerations as well.

Look, having Joffa on the bench for 32mins instead of Seyfarth is something I think we'd all prefer. But I don't see him having much of an influence on that outcome.
 
I actually think these things have far more variables than people like to admit.

For example (obvious ones too) -

1) Api out - not only is he our best player and captain, but he leads the tempo in defence, whether it's line speed or kick chase, he mops up ineffective tackles around the middle and facilitates more metres in attack (I'm underselling his contribution here)

2) Brooks out - On form, our best runner and kicker of the football. Our best attacking threat this year. Solid edge defender. Has the capacity, on occasion, to alter momentum.

3) Momentum. The modern game is a momentum machine. The best defensive sides disrupt momentum either through pressure or suffocation. It sounds like a lazy analysis, but it can get away from you in a game. If you get the jump early, points can come thick and fast. Cows built momentum and didn't slow it down. Even we, several times this year, have rode momentum heavily. The Dogs, Canberra and Cows first game just to name a few.

4) Attitude. Both us and the cows. They were inverted from last game. They wanted revenge and we, I think, have been looking around the sheds a little bit more lately pre game and dropping our heads. The Canberra game and the Brooks/Api injuries have cruelled belief and subsequently attitude.

5) Luck. Last time, we got every bounce of the ball, this time, we couldn't buy good fortune. Knock ons into certain tries. No look hail Mary passes finding hands. Balls bouncing at 90 degrees into a chasing prop's arms, key forward passes being missed. It was their night and it all fell their way.

6) Combinations. Our edges have been decimated, both by injuries and selections. The edge - half - centre link is the most important in rugby league defensive structures, and we had a new centre combination (again), a new five eighth, Bateman in the middle rather than on an edge, and both Papali'i on a different side and Blore coming in for just a handful on games each.

I think there's several other considerations as well.

Look, having Joffa on the bench for 32mins instead of Seyfarth is something I think we'd all prefer. But I don't see him having much of an influence on that outcome.
Payten put posters in every corner of the Cows training facility of the 66-18 scores even in the showers and dunnies to shame and motivate them for revenge.
And it worked, great coaching.
 
Cash.😂
Wests Magpies of the late 1950's were known as the millionaire's club due to funding from Wests Leagues Club, and they were able to buy some great players.
With us getting all these $$$ coming in, we'll be the millionaire's club of the 2020's....... but we'll still have shit players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Back
Top