Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Alex Glenn is extremely underrated

When he doesn't play the Broncos defensively look very vulnerable and the score lines usually back that up

Look at the Saints semi as an example

A deal with him to the Titans is as good as done
 
I don't think Lawrence would make the starting side for any team other than us. He's ok, but no better than who everyone else has. He can't break the line other than occasionally 5m out from the line. No power in attack or defence.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Fact is - I'd be surprised if he's not in the bottom 4 starting second rowers in the game…
And he's our "best"? - I see that as a real issue...

Who is better than him ? On the left edge I'd have Kikau, Wade Graham (pretty close) & Tariq Sims (pretty close). I see Lawrence as one of the better edge second rowers in the game at the moment. He runs great lines with speed and power on that left edge and he makes his tackles most of the time.

He was probably our best forward last year and he is no plodder. Plus he is a good guy.

One in every bunch…
I havent put much thought into which edge, just back rowers in general...
But at a quick guess - If i'm thinking left edges.... Boyd Cordner, Joel Thompson comes to mind, as does Gavin Cooper... John Sutton, Tohu Harris, Tapine - Blokes like Gillett and Aubusson (played both) even Fellas like Ma'u, Glenn, Hoffman and Guerra are on par with him...

I get the loyalty and all that - I really do..... But loyalty don't equal numbers.

You'd be the only guy i've ever heard of have Wade Graham, Tariq Sims and Chris Lawrence there or there abouts on par...

I think that basically every player you mention is on par or worse than Lawrence. There are areas within our team that we need to improve on but I don't see that position as being a problem.

I know sometimes that fans overrate certain players but I also think that fans underrate certain players. Brooks is a guy who has been underrated for a while and Lawrence is another that fits that category. You see Tariq Sims play a great game and forget when Lawrence played a great game. Tariq Sims isn't consistently great. If you were talking about Frizzel that is a different story. Frizzel is a gun. Lawrence isn't in Frizzel's class but he is probably the best edge backrower in the game.

Soo… the guy that just won a premiership and captained the national side - is on par or worse than Chris Lawrence...

I think you need to get off the bong bro...
 
@ said:
I don't think Lawrence would make the starting side for any team other than us. He's ok, but no better than who everyone else has. He can't break the line other than occasionally 5m out from the line. No power in attack or defence.

Exactly!! In fact I think there are back rowers coming off the bench in some teams that are better footballers - and it hasn’t taken them 12 years of first grade to get there…
 
I might get crucified for this but I honestly think we should target Hayne. I think he is exactly what we need. His back end of the season was really good. We do need a centre and someone of his calibre and his valuable experience is too hard to turn down. Thoughts?? I also heard he is being targeted by the Dragons so maybe we can jag on of their centres If Hayne is to go there.
 
I dont know what all the fuss about Lawrence is about.

He is more than adequate at 2nd row, one of our better leaders and a true tiger - very loyal. He is an asset to the club and fans alike.

Lets start talking about Centre or something a little more relevant. That's where our issues lie currently.
 
@ said:
I dont know what all the fuss about Lawrence is about.

He is more than adequate at 2nd row, one of our better leaders and a true tiger - very loyal. He is an asset to the club and fans alike.

Lets start talking about Centre or something a little more relevant. That's where our issues lie currently.

Exactly, and wing also
 
@ said:
@ said:
I dont know what all the fuss about Lawrence is about.

He is more than adequate at 2nd row, one of our better leaders and a true tiger - very loyal. He is an asset to the club and fans alike.

Lets start talking about Centre or something a little more relevant. That's where our issues lie currently.

Exactly, and wing also

Ok then. So we basically need someone better that Nofo or Thompson? both their forms this year had their ups and downs, at lest Thompson is flexible with positions
 
@ said:
I might get crucified for this but I honestly think we should target Hayne. I think he is exactly what we need. His back end of the season was really good. We do need a centre and someone of his calibre and his valuable experience is too hard to turn down. Thoughts?? I also heard he is being targeted by the Dragons so maybe we can jag on of their centres If Hayne is to go there.

Would rather the one pushed out than Hayne and am happy enough with Lawrence on our left for the time being.
 
@ said:
@ said:
I might get crucified for this but I honestly think we should target Hayne. I think he is exactly what we need. His back end of the season was really good. We do need a centre and someone of his calibre and his valuable experience is too hard to turn down. Thoughts?? I also heard he is being targeted by the Dragons so maybe we can jag on of their centres If Hayne is to go there.

Would rather the one pushed out than Hayne and am happy enough with Lawrence on our left for the time being.

Dragons, lose Jason Nightingale (retired) and Nene MacDonald (Cowboys) .. but will have Euan Aitken, Tim Lafai and young Zac Lomax to play in the centres .. Jordan Pereira will take one wing and probably Kurt Mann the other .. If the Dragons to snare Hayne .. Hayne doesn't want to play on the wing, but the Dragons will want to keep young Zac Lomax - he's a future Kangaroo centre in the making - so I wonder if Tim Lafai is on the chopping block .. ?? Dragons also have a young centre playing ISP Cup named Reuben Garrick who is also a jet in the making .. go after him, or even Esan's brother Steven from the Dragons :wink:
 
@ said:
@ said:
I dont know what all the fuss about Lawrence is about.

He is more than adequate at 2nd row, one of our better leaders and a true tiger - very loyal. He is an asset to the club and fans alike.

Lets start talking about Centre or something a little more relevant. That's where our issues lie currently.

Exactly, and wing also

He was our best forward all year.
Ran hard, hit holes an held the ball well.
Stunned by the critics of him this year.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top