Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Jedi_Tiger]

The Liddle discussion was about trying to sigh Grant or Brandon Smith etc and not resigning Liddle for 2022 !

 

[izotope]

Given the events at Suncorp tonight can put a skewer in Harry

 

[happy_tiger]

Given the events at Suncorp tonight can put a skewer in Harry

I dunno .......could be a smokescreen ...stops the possible questions .....

Harry won't be back either way

 

[tony soprano]

Given the events at Suncorp tonight can put a skewer in Harry

I dunno .......could be a smokescreen ...stops the possible questions .....

Harry won't be back either way

Classy guy knows when not to keep going.


Really end of an era.


Apart from benji

 

[happy_tiger]

Given the events at Suncorp tonight can put a skewer in Harry

I dunno .......could be a smokescreen ...stops the possible questions .....

Harry won't be back either way

Classy guy knows when not to keep going.


Really end of an era.


Apart from benji

Amazing career his percentage of games he played to game he could of played is utterly amazing

 

[tony soprano]

Given the events at Suncorp tonight can put a skewer in Harry

I dunno .......could be a smokescreen ...stops the possible questions .....

Harry won't be back either way

Classy guy knows when not to keep going.


Really end of an era.


Apart from benji

Amazing career his percentage of games he played to game he could of played is utterly amazing

? the best in my era.

 

[tony soprano]

Haha they’re still not confirming it

 

[happy_tiger]

Given the events at Suncorp tonight can put a skewer in Harry

I dunno .......could be a smokescreen ...stops the possible questions .....

Harry won't be back either way

Classy guy knows when not to keep going.


Really end of an era.


Apart from benji

Amazing career his percentage of games he played to game he could of played is utterly amazing

? the best in my era.

He overtook my next best (Lewis) a while ago ...probably not even close now

 

[tony soprano]

Given the events at Suncorp tonight can put a skewer in Harry

I dunno .......could be a smokescreen ...stops the possible questions .....

Harry won't be back either way

Classy guy knows when not to keep going.


Really end of an era.


Apart from benji

Amazing career his percentage of games he played to game he could of played is utterly amazing

? the best in my era.

He overtook my next best (Lewis) a while ago ...probably not even close now

Thurston close but not as good.

 

[tony soprano]

Bizarre belemey said thought it a good idea in case he decides to pull pin and smith refused to confirm it’s his last year.


Unless it’s all a smoke screen not to make the gf a cam smith show who knowS.

 

[Tiger5150]

Given the events at Suncorp tonight can put a skewer in Harry

I dunno .......could be a smokescreen ...stops the possible questions .....

Harry won't be back either way

Classy guy knows when not to keep going.


Really end of an era.


Apart from benji

Amazing career his percentage of games he played to game he could of played is utterly amazing

? the best in my era.

He overtook my next best (Lewis) a while ago ...probably not even close now

Thurston close but not as good.

A Johns still the first picked in any team, Smith second.

 

[happy_tiger]

Bizarre belemey said thought it a good idea in case he decides to pull pin and smith refused to confirm it’s his last year.


Unless it’s all a smoke screen not to make the gf a cam smith show who knowS.

Again he might be leaving the Storm going to Brisbane ..saluting the fans

 

[Balmainian]

Surely Smiths done!
I’m betting Next week we will see the last game of one off the best players to ever play the game run out For the last time.
I’m not a Cameron fan but he has been a joy to watch over the years, in saying that I hope the storm get flogged next week!!!!!

 

[izotope]

Bizarre belemey said thought it a good idea in case he decides to pull pin and smith refused to confirm it’s his last year.


Unless it’s all a smoke screen not to make the gf a cam smith show who knowS.

Don't believe it for a second, they all know

 

[tony soprano]

Bizarre belemey said thought it a good idea in case he decides to pull pin and smith refused to confirm it’s his last year.


Unless it’s all a smoke screen not to make the gf a cam smith show who knowS.

Don't believe it for a second, they all know

Smart fielding the million farewell questions/drama

 

[happy_tiger]

Given the events at Suncorp tonight can put a skewer in Harry

I dunno .......could be a smokescreen ...stops the possible questions .....

Harry won't be back either way

Classy guy knows when not to keep going.


Really end of an era.


Apart from benji

Amazing career his percentage of games he played to game he could of played is utterly amazing

? the best in my era.

He overtook my next best (Lewis) a while ago ...probably not even close now

Thurston close but not as good.


A Johns still the first picked in any team, Smith second.

Did you mean p...........rick in any team

 

[JC99]

Melbourne know he’s retiring. Now the media will focus on his retirement another week and they can work on winning the GF without any outside drama really. Bellamy and Smith aren’t dumb lol

 

[voice_of_reason]

A Johns still the first picked in any team, Smith second.

Did you mean p...........rick in any team

I suspect then it would have been Cam Smith first...

 

[twentyforty]

Cam Smith to the Titans. According to Benny Elias.

 

[Deleted member 3518]

I can't believe some on here are happy to not make at least a play for Harry Grant if he comes on the market some are content with Liddle and Simpkin, i guess some are happy to finish 9th too
change it up
if we could get Harry and keep Simpkin and land JAC or Suali awesome, if it means losing Liddle then so be it

Liddle has more talent than Harry Grant... Lids has just been injured that's all... big difference in how he provides service... very noticeable... Harry is a good player but I wouldn't say he is better than Liddle... both has strengths and I would back Liddle instead of Harry

Maybe but Harry has ticker, he's a winner, has football sense and leadership. He's priority No 1 for me, even before JAC

We had Harry this year without speed in the backline and where did it get us? Harry is great don’t misunderstand but what Wests Tigers lack is speed. Outside backs with speed is an absolute no. 1 priority if we want to play finals footy.

We were better once Kepoa got on that wing . He just needs to work on his hands . But you could see the uplift in attack just having a guy who can turn half chances into full chances just by running faster than the previous bloke.
I honestly think Fullback and backrower are our most cause for concern . We have Blore and luci atm , and no one else . Garner has a foot out the door , Chee kam is a 15 at best , and McIntyre isn’t signed yet.
I’m not that worried about 9 . Liddle is more than capable . I really don’t think it’s wise to throw 800k at grant , despite how good he played this year . It’s bad cap management. If you look at it as wins and losses , how many wins and losses does grant offer over Liddle to warrant paying him 3 times the money ?

We have to be smarter . Damien Cook is the incumbent in the Aus team and he’s hardly the scheming genius , Cam, Robbie , and those types were. You can win just as many games with that type .
You can also win a lot with physical types like Friend , Radley , the other Smith , Isaac Luke etc.
We lost heaps of games because of instability and fragility on the edges , and lazy, tired uncommitted forwards in the middle .
It always seemed to start where benji, Joey , Garner were , and move inside . Then it was a concertina effect through the defensive line .