Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

@boonboon said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317055) said:
@hbom said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317038) said:
What is Blake Lazarus doing?

At only 32 is really in his prime years as a half.

Hype for Volkman approaching that of Lazarus. I have no opinion personally.
 
I know we have Brooks but gee wiz I am glad we haven't got Croft... He is hopeless and would think he is close to been dropped. His time in Melb with the big 3 made him look like a superstar.
 
Now that Brooksy kicks goals, is he a less consistent version of Nikorima?
I like Niko, plus he has a chip on his shoulder for the Brissie Conko's...makes me like him more betterer.
 
@hsvjones said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317068) said:
I know we have Brooks but gee wiz I am glad we haven't got Croft... He is hopeless and would think he is close to been dropped. His time in Melb with the big 3 made him look like a superstar.

I’m not an advocate for Croft but a couple of times his team mates got in his rode last night isolating his options.
Imo he was better than Milford
But in no way do I want him with us
 
Update for all those who were devastated by the loss of San McIntyre.
You can travel out to Tugun this afternoon to watch him play for the Tweed Seagulls. Be quick as it's only a matter of time before coach Woolf recognises that McIntyre isn't up to Intrust Super Cup standard.
 
@hbom said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317064) said:
@boonboon said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317055) said:
@hbom said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317038) said:
What is Blake Lazarus doing?

At only 32 is really in his prime years as a half.

Hype for Volkman approaching that of Lazarus. I have no opinion personally.

I wonder if the hype will reach the heights of Kieran Kerr. I remember 2004 a lot of people wanted us to drop Scott Prince for him.
 
@red88_tiger said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1316887) said:
I really don’t understand why everyone is salivating over volkman after watching 1 game

The same salivation for Brooks after his first game...
 
I don’t understand why Aidan seezer doesn’t get a look in 2 years ago he got the raiders to Gf with a lot of help I might add but surley he has to be better than brooks I remember seezer kicking 3 field goals in 10 mins to beat sharks
 
@tigerap said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317130) said:
@red88_tiger said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1316887) said:
I really don’t understand why everyone is salivating over volkman after watching 1 game

The same salivation for Brooks after his first game...

Which unfortunately for us, was his best game
 
@finnzo said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317145) said:
I don’t understand why Aidan seezer doesn’t get a look in 2 years ago he got the raiders to Gf with a lot of help I might add but surley he has to be better than brooks I remember seezer kicking 3 field goals in 10 mins to beat sharks

100%.

He’s not afraid to take the line on.

Brooks just looks like this young kid who somehow has played 150 games.
 
@red88_tiger said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317099) said:
@hsvjones said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317068) said:
I know we have Brooks but gee wiz I am glad we haven't got Croft... He is hopeless and would think he is close to been dropped. His time in Melb with the big 3 made him look like a superstar.

I’m not an advocate for Croft but a couple of times his team mates got in his rode last night isolating his options.
Imo he was better than Milford
But in no way do I want him with us

Wouldn't be hard to be better than Milford. You wouldn't take him for a bet.
 
@imback said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317162) said:
Brooks just looks like this young kid who somehow has played 150 games

I really like Brooks but in truth his unrealised potential is just that.

150 games is way to much time and excuses.

He's on top dollar and as yet hasnt been worth it.

Time to start looking for another for 2022
 
I'm starting to think Brooks can have a decent season this year,I think playing a top team like the Raiders round one wasn't ideal and the team forgot about the game plan and made too many errors. With Madge and players backing Luke I think he will start to play some good footy,the only thing that does worry me is the long kicking game where I'm hoping douehi may help.
 
Backrow is where we have the least amount of depth. Canberra have excess. Their reserve grade backrowers are better than Garner & MCK. With CHN still to come back we should be Raiding the Raiders backrow stocks for this year.
 
The new rules have widened the gap between the top teams and the battlers. Our roster is better but we are no hope of bearing Storm, Raiders, Roosters, Rabbits Panthers, Eels, Knights unless they play poorly. Basically at best we are battling Sharks, Titans, Eagles, Warriors, Dragons for 8th spot.

Only players off contract that would make a difference to this would be Jaydn Sua, Dale Finucane, Brandon Smith, Xavier Coates.

There are no halves available and there is a scarcity as it is in the NRL. We are way off and it will take years to correct our young players have to be our stars.

The new rules are great but with the most lopsided competition in years the NRL should do away with the salary cap it’s not working at all.
 
@tyga said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317505) said:
The new rules have widened the gap between the top teams and the battlers. Our roster is better but we are no hope of bearing Storm, Raiders, Roosters, Rabbits Panthers, Eels, Knights unless they play poorly. Basically at best we are battling Sharks, Titans, Eagles, Warriors, Dragons for 8th spot.

Only players off contract that would make a difference to this would be Jaydn Sua, Dale Finucane, Brandon Smith, Xavier Coates.

There are no halves available and there is a scarcity as it is in the NRL. We are way off and it will take years to correct our young players have to be our stars.

The new rules are great but with the most lopsided competition in years the NRL should do away with the salary cap it’s not working at all.

Coates would be a good get but it's hard to spend good coin on a winger when we've already got a winger on good coin. Finucane would be an excellent signing as well as would Smith

Best way to get good halves is to try pick up a good rookie and keep them at your club forever, most clubs aren't letting their good halves go because they're so valuable.
 
@tyga said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317505) said:
The new rules are great but with the most lopsided competition in years the NRL should do away with the salary cap it’s not working at all.

It'd be worse than what it is now. If they implemented a draft system that might help.
 
@earl said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317509) said:
@tyga said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1317505) said:
The new rules are great but with the most lopsided competition in years the NRL should do away with the salary cap it’s not working at all.

It'd be worse than what it is now. If they implemented a draft system that might help.

I'm on record as a NO to the draft - still feel the same.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top