Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[BAGNF05]

So just wondering, if we still can’t get any big signings to come, are we still blaming Madge or will it be Sheens?

I think the chance for big signings are over, we missed them all, there isn't anyone exciting left available as far as I understand?

Or do you mean 2023

I think the only big signing that was missed was Matt Burton, he has a big future ahead of him. And he reportedly only went to Dogs to follow Barrett. Not to many others signed up for other clubs this year that would be considered big signings that would've justified their huge salaries IMO.

I have asked you the question in one of your other posts but I’ll ask again just who is good enough for WTs

Not a question of who is good enough from my end, it was a statement saying a 4year deal for Finucane is too long IMO so was happy our club didn't get railroaded into offering him that. Ditto for JAC, time will tell if he is a $700k a year player who influences results once he is taken from the comfort of a top-notch roster and continual top 4 team. I'd be willing to bet he flounders at Canterbury, same as he would at WT.
So in answer to your question, there are PLENTY of players who are good enough to represent our club and I wouldn't say no to many of them (just like I never said Finucane or JAC aren't good enough to play for WT). Whether or not they would provide good value if they were on exorbitant money or length of contract is another matter entirely.

What you are essentially saying as that players lower their performance to the standards that exist at our club. Which I can’t disagree with. Answer why and you get Pascoe’s job.

Well it is basically common knowledge that you can come here as a player, underperform massively, yet still get picked every week. Our club is the pushover club where players run the show regardless of who the coach is or who is involved in the front office.

Can’t disagree as it seems that way. This is why I am happy we didn’t sack Madge. Send a message that we expect the players to get the club out of this mess. If they’re not up for it, on your bike.

 

[tony soprano]

We need a backup fullback and a centre more than anything. Talau could miss a lot of games and Doueihi is our only other option at fullback besides Laurie.

Find a young fullback in reserves somewhere who can cover the wing too if necessary.

Logan dillon?

Tex hoy maybe?

Well our new Coaching Director brought through Tedesco. I have no doubt he will have a positive influence on Dillon and all our players. I am really looking forward to his influence on our younger players.

Can't tell if sarcastic or not lol

I am a big supporter of Sheens and always have been. I believe it is a very smart (Gould called it shrewd but for other reasons imo) to bring him home.

Will sheens be chief negotiator in recruiting?

 

[JC99]

We need a backup fullback and a centre more than anything. Talau could miss a lot of games and Doueihi is our only other option at fullback besides Laurie.

Find a young fullback in reserves somewhere who can cover the wing too if necessary.

Logan dillon?

Tex hoy maybe?

I'll take Dillon over Tex Hoy.

Dillon isn't ready for first grade next year and that's what the backup fullback has to be ready for. Give him a development deal, he'll be ready in a few years.

 

[TigerNeddyK]

We need a backup fullback and a centre more than anything. Talau could miss a lot of games and Doueihi is our only other option at fullback besides Laurie.

Find a young fullback in reserves somewhere who can cover the wing too if necessary.

Logan dillon?

Tex hoy maybe?

Well our new Coaching Director brought through Tedesco. I have no doubt he will have a positive influence on Dillon and all our players. I am really looking forward to his influence on our younger players.

Hoy is not a good defender, at all

 

[Goanna57]

So just wondering, if we still can’t get any big signings to come, are we still blaming Madge or will it be Sheens?

I think the chance for big signings are over, we missed them all, there isn't anyone exciting left available as far as I understand?

Or do you mean 2023

I think the only big signing that was missed was Matt Burton, he has a big future ahead of him. And he reportedly only went to Dogs to follow Barrett. Not to many others signed up for other clubs this year that would be considered big signings that would've justified their huge salaries IMO.

I have asked you the question in one of your other posts but I’ll ask again just who is good enough for WTs

Not a question of who is good enough from my end, it was a statement saying a 4year deal for Finucane is too long IMO so was happy our club didn't get railroaded into offering him that. Ditto for JAC, time will tell if he is a $700k a year player who influences results once he is taken from the comfort of a top-notch roster and continual top 4 team. I'd be willing to bet he flounders at Canterbury, same as he would at WT.
So in answer to your question, there are PLENTY of players who are good enough to represent our club and I wouldn't say no to many of them (just like I never said Finucane or JAC aren't good enough to play for WT). Whether or not they would provide good value if they were on exorbitant money or length of contract is another matter entirely.

So you know for a fact JAC is on $700k ?

 

[kade7]

https://youtu.be/F0pQcK8jVzo Dillon looks very good

 

[yeahcaz]

https://youtu.be/F0pQcK8jVzo Dillon looks very good

Is he deceptively tall

 

[Tiger5150]

https://youtu.be/F0pQcK8jVzo Dillon looks very good

THats actually a pretty impressive reel for a change. Hate to say it but runs like Teddy.

 

[frullens]

when is sheenious officially working?

He is basically already working with the club. He has booked another flight for end of October so hopefully it doesn't get cancelled again. Still would have to quarantine as well.

Serious question - do we know that Hastings and Gildart won't get 3-4 months delayed flying to Australia like sheens has?

If we have to start the season without Hastings it will be a debacle

 

[Fainu Brothers]

Scolari >>>>>>>Nofo

How is this being upvoted. I know everyone is in the 'we all hate Nofa' phase and admittedly he has been well below his best. But to say an untested rookie who has literally never played a game is better than last years Dally M Winger of the Year is just ridiculous. Even at his worst I really felt (unlike most here) that Nofa actually was trying really hard at the backend of the year. And also all of you guys constantly bemoan the lack of passion that anyone has for the Tigers jersey but he's one of the few that has actually been loyal to the club from the beginning. Yes he had a bad year and yes its frustrating for all of us but how about we try and back him and hope he gets back to form next season. If he doesn't then this conversation can hold a lot more weight.

I would like him a lot better if he stayed on his bloody wing and didnt run sideways

Scolari is faster and can defend

We've all said the same thing about Nofo eh.
Every game.
Running side ways like a headless chicken.
Absolutely woeful.

He's got a lengthy contract so he's not going anywhere but I hope he can regain form next year and run straight.

Scolari is very fast.
I hope we see him in grade.

Re Nofoaluma
If he decides to run stright, he is one of our best, the attack was always his only strength!
However, he is our chronic defensive weakness, is it his inability or discipline, but he did not show any sign of improvement in his 6-7 years. He is the NRL's undisputed champion in how not to position or read the game.
My verdict is: sell him at any cost!

Those Aldi special buys are always a hit.

Good Shout, unfortunately that is the Wests Tigers at

Great step, looks promising if we can hold on to him!


https://youtu.be/F0pQcK8jVzo Dillon looks very good

 

[tigger19]

Yeah same running style as teddy and quick, good passing game as well

 

[coivtny]

when is sheenious officially working?

He is basically already working with the club. He has booked another flight for end of October so hopefully it doesn't get cancelled again. Still would have to quarantine as well.

Serious question - do we know that Hastings and Gildart won't get 3-4 months delayed flying to Australia like sheens has?

If we have to start the season without Hastings it will be a debacle

It's a good question I've also wondered about. The thing that's working for Hastings and Gildart that isn't working for Sheens is that NSW should be over 80% double vaxxed by the time their ready to come. NSW will be very quick to get international travel going once we hit 80%.

 

[Shooter Mcgavin]

https://youtu.be/F0pQcK8jVzo Dillon looks very good

I usually am pretty cautious of getting hyped over players in the lower grades due to quality of opposition, though he looks really good!

 

[tony soprano]

https://youtu.be/F0pQcK8jVzo Dillon looks very good

THats actually a pretty impressive reel for a change. Hate to say it but runs like Teddy.

Dont see it

 

[Tiger5150]

https://youtu.be/F0pQcK8jVzo Dillon looks very good

THats actually a pretty impressive reel for a change. Hate to say it but runs like Teddy.

Dont see it

Something about the way he lowers his body height as he hits top gear.

 

[tony soprano]

https://youtu.be/F0pQcK8jVzo Dillon looks very good

THats actually a pretty impressive reel for a change. Hate to say it but runs like Teddy.

Dont see it

Something about the way he lowers his body height as he hits top gear.

Think Ted had more speed at his age.

 

[Tiger5150]

https://youtu.be/F0pQcK8jVzo Dillon looks very good

THats actually a pretty impressive reel for a change. Hate to say it but runs like Teddy.

Dont see it

Something about the way he lowers his body height as he hits top gear.

Think Ted had more speed at his age.

Maybe. He'll end up being his own man. Rare to see an actual impressive reel at this age.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

Isn’t that Dillon kid signed elsewhere or was that another of our up and comers?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Isn’t that Dillon kid signed elsewhere or was that another of our up and comers?

Jordan Hill. Apparently goneskies

 

[Odessa]

Isn’t that Dillon kid signed elsewhere or was that another of our up and comers?

Jordan Hill. Apparently goneskies

Do you think the talent scout comes up to the kid and says the Tigers are B/S come to a real club don't waste your time here ?