Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[tony soprano]

Dodged a bullet on Curtis Scott.

Let’s not prejudge this situation a la Reynolds, but yes, I agree, Scott seems to attract a lot of unwanted “attention” shall we say…

Agree innocent or guilty would be a distraction.

 

[tony soprano]

Zane Musgrove caught driving with a suspended license apparently

can we punt him on that

Not for that

 

[tony soprano]

Just say no to Fergo

I'd say yes bloke can play and cover a few positions.

It would best the most West tigers thing to do, pay overs from an ageing player, who doesn't want to be here, for one last hurrah who has burnt every other bridge through his own stupidity. Fergo has his always marched to the beat of his own drum, which I'm sure won't match Madge's team first mantra. So yeah seems like a match made in heaven, sign him up, why are we waiting.

Did parra pick him up or was that fake?

 

[JC99]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

Gee that's a spin if I've ever heard it... anything to defend Brooks

There's absolutely nothing inspiring about Brooks in his last few seasons. As a forward you work hard to get up the field and he kicks it dead. As a winger you work hard to get into a try scoring opportunity and he executes the play wrong

His defence has become a myth. 6th most missed tackles in the entire NRL. Sure he's better than some halfbacks but defence is probably the last thing I'm looking for in a halfback... Thurston and Lockyer couldn't defend at all.

Anyway it'll be Tamou captain for now while he's still around. 2023 the role is up for grabs

Was it the game at Leichhardt during the win against the Panthers when Brooks came from the other side of the field and ran down the Penrith attacker (it may have been Edwards) who was in the clear and headed for a try. That was inspirational.

Stats can be misleading. The more tackles you are required to make the more you are likely to miss. This is especially so for Brooks where forwards are instructed to run at him to tire him out and nullify his attacking game.

Gee one tackle, make him captain!

Wouldn't his tackle count be massively high if he was asked to make more tackles than anyone else? Don't see him topping the tackle count every week... makes just as many as any other halfback

 

[TigerWest]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

 

[JC99]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

 

[Demps]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

No, but it won’t change it either.

 

[Demps]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

No, but it won’t change it either.

1 more year and onto new problems.

People have said the club reads the forum and whatnot, if these things aren't discussed - we are accepting mediocrity instead of brain storming better options going forward.

Pretty simple rly.
It is... after all... a discussion board.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

No, but it won’t change it either.

1 more year and onto new problems.

People have said the club reads the forum and whatnot, if these things aren't discussed - **we are accepting mediocrity** instead of brain storming better options going forward.

Pretty simple rly.
It is... after all... a discussion board.

That is a myth. There is no accepting or not accepting. The only way to not accept it is to walk away completely.The only thing they will take the punters advice on is what kind badge design should they use for membership packages. If you think they look to this place for ideas on how to improve the football department, you are having a laugh

 

[Newtown]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

I would think that the other clubs would belittle our club desperation in utilising a 20 minute captain. No wonder the team looked like a pack of assorted chickens on the field last year.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

I would think that the other clubs would belittle our club desperation in utilising a 20 minute captain. No wonder the team looked like a pack of assorted chickens on the field last year.

They’d belittle us even more if we replaced him with a guy who hasn’t played in the NRL for 3 years and wasn’t even proven when he did.

 

[Demps]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

No, but it won’t change it either.

1 more year and onto new problems.

People have said the club reads the forum and whatnot, if these things aren't discussed - **we are accepting mediocrity** instead of brain storming better options going forward.

Pretty simple rly.
It is... after all... a discussion board.

That is a myth. There is no accepting or not accepting. The only way to not accept it is to walk away completely.The only thing they will take the punters advice on is what kind badge design should they use for membership packages. If you think they look to this place for ideas on how to improve the football department, you are having a laugh

It's not so much about "improving the football department".

But to ignore the fans' is a good way to lose them.

If you think they'd go... let's make.. Matt Lodge the captain without taking in how fans or the general public would respond wouldn't be ideal for them.

Arguments been had before.
It's a business.

Fans are a big part as stake holders.
So yes, their opinions matter.

 

[Newtown]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

I would think that the other clubs would belittle our club desperation in utilising a 20 minute captain. No wonder the team looked like a pack of assorted chickens on the field last year.

They’d belittle us even more if we replaced him with a guy who hasn’t played in the NRL for 3 years and wasn’t even proven when he did.

Sorry , I disagree. At least the person you are referring to shows emotion and has real leadership qualities.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

I would think that the other clubs would belittle our club desperation in utilising a 20 minute captain. No wonder the team looked like a pack of assorted chickens on the field last year.

They’d belittle us even more if we replaced him with a guy who hasn’t played in the NRL for 3 years and wasn’t even proven when he did.

Sorry , I disagree. At least the person you are referring to shows emotion and has real leadership qualities.

You are saying that as a supporter who is looking for positives. That’s not how the rest of the RL would view it.

 

[Newtown]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

Doesn't mean we can't complain about it.

I would think that the other clubs would belittle our club desperation in utilising a 20 minute captain. No wonder the team looked like a pack of assorted chickens on the field last year.

They’d belittle us even more if we replaced him with a guy who hasn’t played in the NRL for 3 years and wasn’t even proven when he did.

Sorry , I disagree. At least the person you are referring to shows emotion and has real leadership qualities.

You are saying that as a supporter who is looking for positives. That’s not how the rest of the RL would view it.

Let's wait for the season to begin and I am sure that there will changes in captaincy, vice or otherwise. It's all in Sheens' and Madge's hands.

 

[Demps]

Braith Anasta captained us for 5 games.

Cmon now.

 

[JC99]

Braith Anasta captained us for 5 games.

Cmon now.

At least he was on the field for 80 minutes. Better than James 'benchwarmer' Tamou

 

[JC99]

Hastings definitely has a lot of captain and leadership qualities in his arsenal.

For that alone , if I was looking in who should captain (I'd pick AD.. but with him out....) Hastings for mine ticks all the boxes and is so far ahead of anyone else in the team, 0 games in the jersey or not.

We've been using Tamou (15 minute turkey) and Brooks (doesn't talk and definitely doesn't lead from the front... like we've seen Hastings do in SL)

If you disagree, who else is there?

Watching your halfback putting much bigger players on their backsides inspire teammates and is leading from the front.

Let's see how Hastings performs when much bigger and much faster forwards either run at him or around him..

True Hastings will have quality players coming at him week in week out unlike English Super League competition he needs to be able to play at NRL level first let alone captain.
I would give it to Brooks and Twal

But Tamou is captain, can’t see him losing it?

He'll probably be captain again, problem is he spends 60 minutes of the game on the bench

There’s no probably about it.

There's a chance he will be co-captain with someone else but that's about it.