Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[batboy]

Tapau did not want to stay,money was certainly part of it but an even larger part was the way JT treated Robbie.

I heard him say "Look, JT is a mate - And I wish them luck" Or words to that effect after he left...

He left for big money - and we were hitting cap trouble.

 

[cochise]

You are cracking me up today.

That movie was full of dorks.

Surely only a dork would use the word dork?

 

[Stevec]

If you had a choice between api and liddle who would you choose? I’m choosing api every day and we already have back ups who’s are on par with liddle it’s a wise move to let him go

Yes obviously Api and I have gut feeling Rua will be a good back up
I was basically thinking many of our departures over the years seem to do better elsewhere .I wish Liddle all the best

 

[Bula]

Topgun 2 was good if anyone hasn't see it yet.
There are a lot of close parallels with Tom Cruises character and my own..

Four foot seven and washed up?

 

[PJ_]

Four foot seven and washed up?

Wish I had his money

 

[Stevec]

If we want top 4 or even top 8 next year it's simple just recruit 3 powerforwards similar to Papalii .They must be able to crash thru the advantage line. Also recruit 2 centers like Ramien or Olam as our centers not up to it .
Well easier said than done I want 5 recruits and how are we doing so far ?
So Far zero ! What worries me is I think Tim and Benji have been trying but no luck so far . Maybe November ?

 

[tiger_scott]

There hasn't been a great deal of announcements made by any club. Mainly resignings. Think that'll be all we'll see until Nov 1.

 

[BAGNF05]

Brooks on 950k-1mill not a good buy... Brooks on 650k good buy!

It all comes down to value.

Most of us wouldn't have minded Mbye on 400k.

He played at a minimum contract level

 

[BAGNF05]

Blore has been cruelled by injury. Solid defender and hopefully will kick on with the ball in hand next year as well. Going to be a lot of expectation on him so he will need to have a huge off-season.

Wonder if it’s all bad luck or is his preparation just very Wests Tigers.

 

[BAGNF05]

Nor Was Benji, Nor was Madden, Nor is Doueihi, Nor is Hastings.....
Can you see a pattern forming?

Joey Johns would flat out refuse to play with our forwards I would be prepared to wager.

 

[tiger_scott]

Joey Johns would flat out refuse to play with our forwards I would be prepared to wager.

Mate....he's retired now 😁

 

[wonka]

Wonder if it’s all bad luck or is his preparation just very Wests Tigers.

To be fair Blore was always injured at Penrith also.

 

[SeanT]

Good halves are worth more than that and Brooks is a good half.

So good that he hasn't played finals in 9 years.

He has deficiencies in his game and it doesn't matter who is coaching, they seem to still be there.

500k

 

[tiger_scott]

So good that he hasn't played finals in 9 years.

He has deficiencies in his game and it doesn't matter who is coaching, they seem to still be there.

500k

I believe that had the off-season move to the Knights happened, the Knights (and Brooks) play finals. Behind a pack containing Klemmer, 2 x Saifiti, Frizzel, Barnett and with Ponga at the back, they just lacked direction, which he would have provided. Moot point now, but that's what I think.

 

[balmain boy]

Brooks on $1.1 mill final year backended contract either we pay all of it and he plays for us or we pay about 60% and he plays for knights
Pretty sure Tim wants to keep him .So think they will offer newcontract
2023 - 2025 $2.3 mill
Same as his $1.1 MILL 2023
600k 2024
600 k 2025
So they can say new contract 3 years $2.3 mill or 767k per year
Its sounds better
But what do they think 9 years not enough to perform as great half but
Its the 10th year will be the breakthrough year !

That's incorrect.

If we were to extend him it would be something like
2023 600k
2024 600k
2025 600k

He gets the benefit of length of contract, we get to spread out his value evenly across all seasons.

Even at 600k he's overpaid. 500k would be about right considering the levels his kicking game and general confidence has deteriorated too.

But also why would Brooks want to re-sign? He's shown his loyalty in the past. This may be his last contract, if he wants to have a crack at finals footy somewhere else then he'll sign elsewhere come November and push for a release. Considering the amount of crap Brooks gets for his failures here, why would he continue to set himself up to be ridiculed?

 

[bptiger 0]

To be fair Blore was always injured at Penrith also.

Ur correct digger blue , he has played very little over the last 3 years , wish people would do there research before bagging the club .

 

[Bula]

If we want top 4 or even top 8 next year it's simple just recruit 3 powerforwards similar to Papalii .They must be able to crash thru the advantage line. Also recruit 2 centers like Ramien or Olam as our centers not up to it .
Well easier said than done I want 5 recruits and how are we doing so far ?
So Far zero ! What worries me is I think Tim and Benji have been trying but no luck so far . Maybe November ?

I don't know how they would fit in a rotation but I would not like Stef, Papalali'i and Pole running at me in succession.
Then once out to the backs for Douehi to hatch it before Twal dies with it on the fifth.
Brooks then falcons the bloke in the third row with a wimpy little chip kick.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

So good that he hasn't played finals in 9 years.

He has deficiencies in his game and it doesn't matter who is coaching, they seem to still be there.

500k

I believe blaming one player for the failings of the club is a bit harsh. I am happy for Sheens to determine his worth.

 

[Stevec]

That's incorrect.

If we were to extend him it would be something like
2023 600k
2024 600k
2025 600k

He gets the benefit of length of contract, we get to spread out his value evenly across all seasons.

Even at 600k he's overpaid. 500k would be about right considering the levels his kicking game and general confidence has deteriorated too.

I hope your right $1.8 mill over 3 years better than $2.3 mill its just I read somewhere the proposed $2.3 mill. If he accepts the 1.8 than given he is legally entitled to the 1.1 for next year he would be adding 2 years for an extra 350k pa .hope you are right

 

[tony soprano]

Spot on mate. I don't understand the tendency in some posters to want to discredit POM.

It's called eljerkositus.