Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Mighty_Tiger]

half the comp makes it the betting market is at about 130% thw boomies need to balance so $6 is pretty decent odds

I’m not in at $6, They aren’t generous odds.

Only 2 teams that have come last in 20yrs have made the top 8 the next season. Let alone our own record.

We have no depth, struggle at fullback, have no real centers or lock. We are 1 injury from being in all sorts.

Yes we have done well roster wise all thing’s considering but we still have massive flaws.

History is well well against us on all counts.

 

[leichhardtjunior]

No they need to look at the future and set up their squads accordingly ...took us 5 years to recover from 2005 GF win .....

When you still had minus Prince the best spine in WT's history and still couldn't attract quality forwards excited enough to play with that spine and the junior talent we had ...something isn't right ...is it

And after 2011 and some signing errors ......letting go players who went onto play SOO ......we still haven't played finals

We were equal premiership favourites in 2012

And before someone says we lost Tedesco for the season after 30 minutes ...many on here didn't think he should even get picked

Notice how the top sides are continually thereabouts to the Top 4 and Premierships ......we have had our chances twice now ...and completely and utterly screwed it up ......

Winning the premiership in 2005 closed our minds and hearts to many of our short comings

People now still want a return to that same footy that will fall flat on it's face in the modern game

Move with the future or die in the history ....

You’re talking about recruitment failures, poor club culture and DNA, bad management, etc, etc. Totally agree. But you loose me when you go down the hole, the 2005 premiership was a negative thing. It’s a success. It was an amazing achievement. Winning premierships is the whole point. So be disappointed with all the failures, but don’t rubbish the successes in the process. Ya just sound like a sook when ya do that.

 

[happy_tiger]

You’re talking about recruitment failures, poor club culture and DNA, bad management, etc, etc. Totally agree. But you loose me when you go down the hole, the 2005 premiership was a negative thing. It’s a success. It was an amazing achievement. Winning premierships is the whole point. So be disappointed with all the failures, but don’t rubbish the successes in the process. Ya just sound like a sook when ya do that.

Mate I loved winning as much as the next guy ....but that wasn't my point .....it was wasted on our club ..that's my simple point ...not sooking at all ...

 

[crazycat]

Because unlike 2005 and 2011, we were favourites to win the title in 2012 and completely shat the bed, resulting in Sheens getting the punt after being extended the year previous.

Just to clarify we were not title favourites.

We had a good side, but lost people. O'dwyer, Fifita and Gibbs.

South Sydney and Bulldogs were stronger, particularly when you account for the team changes we had to make.
Haslier in his wizdom swapped Ennis for Lichaa, Souths Kept Burgess and GI which IMHO would make them favourites for 2012. We clearly were busting cap, but we should have expected better from 2012...

Also the board woke up and realised they needed to think about Football and the coach!

 

[Buttface]

Just to clarify we were not title favourites.

We had a good side, but lost people. O'dwyer, Fifita and Gibbs.

South Sydney and Bulldogs were stronger, particularly when you account for the team changes we had to make.
Haslier in his wizdom swapped Ennis for Lichaa, Souths Kept Burgess and GI which IMHO would make them favourites for 2012. We clearly were busting cap, but we should have expected better from 2012...

Also the board woke up and realised they needed to think about Football and the coach!

I don’t agree with some of the rubbish that’s being posted about the 05, 10, 11, & 12 seasons, but I can assure you as a betting man we were equal favourites in 2012 and depending on the booky out right favourites.
To say that 2005 was a failure is complete rubbish. The aim every year is to win the GF we did that in 05 full stop. Melb cheated thief way to GF wins and still call that a successful year.
However, you could certainly say the following years 06,07,08 were complete failures as we did not capitalise on our GF win and although we had some injuries we also had no depth and no D.

 

[Merlot]

From The Australian paper, Rothfields comments below.


SHOOSH

● The relationship between one NRL chairman and his chief executive is at breaking point. Only one will survive the season.

● Huge pressure on the once invincible 2GB Continuous Call team in the ratings, with the ABC closing in on Saturdays and Triple M on Sundays. Trying to be funny doesn’t always work. Sometimes it can get stale. Listeners these days want to be informed. They want strong opinions and analysis.

● Drama at the Wests Tigers between Tim Sheens, Benji and Robbie.

● Everyone is talking about Anthony Griffin, Adam O’Brien and Justin Holbrook being under the pump. You can throw Kevvie Walters into that group as well. He needs to make the finals.

● Which huuuge-name NRL player will be offered an early release from his contract?

Toooommmmy Turbo

 

[sleeve]

It’s such a tough 1 all the bottom 4 teams have made huge improvements in there rosters and the teams from lasts years top 8 haven’t lost a huge amount of talent so it’s gonna be a really really tough year to make the top 8

Finnzo, you are spot on. Sheens said 2025 was the target to have the side ready for Benji ,that was realistic. Yes we have bought well, but we still do not have 13 quality players. The Dogs have bought well, and will challenge, Parra will drop a little, and the usual top sides are still ahead of us by a fair margin. I think we are 5 players short of a good side, and in the next 2 years we have to produce or buy these players. To do this requires smart planning, and money in the bank , and cap space. There is an urgency on the forum to buy, buy buy, but we could end up again with a crap roster in 2025. Baby steps are required at the moment.

 

[Red88_Tiger]

Finnzo, you are spot on. Sheens said 2025 was the target to have the side ready for Benji ,that was realistic. Yes we have bought well, but we still do not have 13 quality players. The Dogs have bought well, and will challenge, Parra will drop a little, and the usual top sides are still ahead of us by a fair margin. I think we are 5 players short of a good side, and in the next 2 years we have to produce or buy these players. To do this requires smart planning, and money in the bank , and cap space. There is an urgency on the forum to buy, buy buy, but we could end up again with a crap roster in 2025. Baby steps are required at the moment.

💯
And if we do buy don’t over pay. Got stuck with mbye packer and Renolds because even if we chipped in half they were still overvalued

 

[Tucker]

Just to clarify we were not title favourites.

We had a good side, but lost people. O'dwyer, Fifita and Gibbs.

South Sydney and Bulldogs were stronger, particularly when you account for the team changes we had to make.
Haslier in his wizdom swapped Ennis for Lichaa, Souths Kept Burgess and GI which IMHO would make them favourites for 2012. We clearly were busting cap, but we should have expected better from 2012...

Also the board woke up and realised they needed to think about Football and the coach!

100% we were favourites.
Sheens was extended in 2011 until 2014 but was released following the disaster that was season 2012. This triggered all his court action.

 

[Tucker]

💯
And if we do buy don’t over pay. Got stuck with mbye packer and Renolds because even if we chipped in half they were still overvalued

This is the encouraging thing with our recruitment drive this far. No massive bloated contracts yet.
The concern that many fans think Moses is worth $1.4 mil is the only worry.

 

[jadtiger]

This is the encouraging thing with our recruitment drive this far. No massive bloated contracts yet.
The concern that many fans think Moses is worth $1.4 mil is the only worry.

To me Bateman at 4 years is not an astute buy especially if we are paying as much as i have heard

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

I’m not in at $6, They aren’t generous odds.

Only 2 teams that have come last in 20yrs have made the top 8 the next season. Let alone our own record.

We have no depth, struggle at fullback, have no real centers or lock. We are 1 injury from being in all sorts.

Yes we have done well roster wise all thing’s considering but we still have massive flaws.

History is well well against us on all counts.

we have the forwards to make the 8 and forwards win matches backs determine by how much

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Toooommmmy Turbo

the nrl player will be Luke Keary to Parramatta and Mitchell Moses to Tigers

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

I didn’t think so, should be $16.
I got on it though.

on a market of 130% ?? almost 50% of clubs make the 8
$6 is about as good as it gets
as far as top 4 or winning GF those odds should be double what they are, they have those markets locked at 100%

 

[Tucker]

To me Bateman at 4 years is not an astute buy especially if we are paying as much as i have heard

Yes that’s a good point.
Hopefully he can provide ROI.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

We need to sign Mitchell Moses for 2023. That’s the only way we can make the semis.
We need to release someone like Alex Seyfarth so we can sign Mitchell Moses & Nathan Brown to finalise our top 30 for 2023. If we do that in my opinion we are definitely a top 8 contender. & maybe even higher It would be hard to get a release for Moses but I would be doing everything possible to get it done.

My Team
Laurie
To’a
Naden
Douiehi
Staines
Brooks
Moses (c)
Brown
Papali’i
Bateman
Ofahengaue
Koroisau
Klemmer
Bench
Smith (Development)
Blore
Pole
Stefano

Plenty of pace in backline & go forward in the pack do it Sheensy.

if Luke Keary gets released to Parramatta you never know Moses could be a tiger in 2023

 

[pawsandclaws1]

To me Bateman at 4 years is not an astute buy especially if we are paying as much as i have heard

Sheens describes his recruitment as the domino he wanted to fall. Is there further changes/recruitment to come? There has been no release of his actual contract figure which is as it should be. What value do you place on the recruitment of a player who potentially has the ability to influence a positive culture at the club?

 

[Tucker]

we have the forwards to make the 8 and forwards win matches backs determine by how much

If they all stay fit.
Our starting pack and bench look strong.
There is a massive drop off behind them though.

 

[Tucker]

Sheens describes his recruitment as the domino he wanted to fall. Is there further changes/recruitment to come? There has been no release of his actual contract figure which is as it should be. What value do you place on the recruitment of a player who potentially has the ability to influence a positive culture at the club?

I don’t get the domino reference.
Is that possibly just a bit of horn tooting on Sheen’s behalf?
Api is our best signing so far.

 

[Buttface]

on a market of 130% ?? almost 50% of clubs make the 8
$6 is about as good as it gets
as far as top 4 or winning GF those odds should be double what they are, they have those markets locked at 100%

Stop making sense the math. 👍
I said $16 coz it rhymed with 6. Just pointing out that your odds are never fair for the punter otherwise there’d be no booky.
But for a team with our record you’d think they could throw a couple of $ at us. Although that sentence is punter bias isn’t it.