Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[tigermate]

They’re saying he pretty much didn’t gel with what they were building. I reckon it was more freeing up cap space so they can shop and he would be easy to move on because he would be in demand. I think they might go after Paps for next year when Teddy’s off contract.

yeah who knows -- i think that's way too simple a case -- they're losing JWH... and TM was cheap for them -- but we'll see

 

[Tiger Morgs]

I have a question for everyone.
Who would you prefer to keep Galvin or Latu if you can only one.
I think I would take Latu if it means we keep all of the Fainu's

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

I agree, was thinking we'd have to give him what we were offering Stef.

Worth the risk though.

Wasnt Stef reportedly offered around twice as much as May is currently on $450 atm?
$600-650 maybe 7 at a push. Can't just throw money around willy nilly who else would be offering that much maybe the dogs?

 

[Halbrowne61]

Josh Addo-Carr yes or no?

Noooooooooooooo !!!

 

[Tito Santana]

If a player has done their time and is a talent, sign them up.

Id even have a sniff around Manase in a couple of years...

People should be given the chance to redeem themselves after their penance.

Yeah I’d be hanging around him in the shadows. Cloak and dagger like stuff……

Oh wait….

 

[Kaito]

If a player has done their time and is a talent, sign them up.

Id even have a sniff around Manase in a couple of years...

People should be given the chance to redeem themselves after their penance.

What a redemption story that would be Kelz

 

[Kelce68]

The thing is, is he truly remorseful? And a leopard doesn't change its spots. We don't want to add bad off field culture to the bad on field and training culture

Plenty of people have successfully turned their life around after a mistake. I'd argue the vast majority.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

What's he worth?

$500.000?

 

[TIGERS]

Noooooooooooooo !!!

Josh Addo Carr?

On a cheap one year contract?? Absolutely.

On a Justin Pascoe 5 year norton street squid pasta special multimillion dollar deal? Nope.

 

[AdelaideTiger]

Still not sold on Hertherington. Would much prefer a specialist edge backrow especially if Bateman goes.
Get May first then go hard for Nikora or Siua Wong or one of the young Melbourne backrowers few options out there

 

[ezybro]

Whatever Luai says goes is where I stand at the moment. Have a nice weekend y’all

 

[ezybro]

Food for thought🙏

 

[Chipofftheoldblock]

Josh Addo-Carr yes or no?

everyday of the week - Staines or Ado-Carr. Not a tough choice.
Game changer with speed to burn which we lacked.

 

[Chipofftheoldblock]

Still not sold on Hertherington. Would much prefer a specialist edge backrow especially if Bateman goes.
Get May first then go hard for Nikora or Siua Wong or one of the young Melbourne backrowers few options out there

Wong would be a fantastic edge backrower buy.

 

[TurnStyle]

If a player has done their time and is a talent, sign them up.

Id even have a sniff around Manase in a couple of years...

People should be given the chance to redeem themselves after their penance.

I think we are of the same view, however at the risk of being too pedantic on semantics, I would say they deserve the chance to earn their redemption.

By which I mean there'd be more clauses in their contracts than Golem dressed as a tiger at Halloween....

 

[TurnStyle]

Josh Addo-Carr yes or no?

NO.

History of dumb decisions (maybe not so much leaving wests...), as far as I know had a gentleman's agreement to return before reneging and going to the dogs for the big bucks the season after....

No thanks.

 

[TIGERS]

View attachment 16913Food for thought🙏

Ever thought of working for the SMH?

 

[Juice]

If a player has done their time and is a talent, sign them up.

Id even have a sniff around Manase in a couple of years...

People should be given the chance to redeem themselves after their penance.

Manase was looking to be one of the best 9’s in the comp before his incident. Would be worth giving him the chance although I’m pretty sure his shoulder is/was completely cooked, there’s a real possibility even without prison his NRL career could have been over by now

 

[Fainu Brothers]

If Luai wants May, make it so Richo!

Douhei, Bateman out

May, Hetherington in

Makes our pack very solid

 

[GNR4LIFE]

As mentioned by a few, the narrative of the Roosters offloading T. May pisses me off - as opposed to the crap we get cutting players.

Anyway, another positive of having Luai - he is absolutely a player other players want to play with. So here's hoping he's a draw for one or two of the May's.

Stef and Ice didn’t.