Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Moh said:
As mentioned by a few, the narrative of the Roosters offloading T. May pisses me off - as opposed to the crap we get cutting players.

Anyway, another positive of having Luai - he is absolutely a player other players want to play with. So here's hoping he's a draw for one or two of the May's.
Click to expand...
Stef and Ice didn’t.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Moh
So if Pole does want to go to Melbourne do we ask for NAS straight away? Or let the season play out?

The issue would be the big dollars NAS is on in this year's cap.

Bateman out.

If we land May & Hetherington I think we just play it out & keep Pole as bench impact on lower dollars.

The contract extension stated an upgrade this year & 2 years after that.

Obviously the upgrade doesn't happen.

8. May*
9. Korosaui
10. Twal
11. Bird
12. Sam Fainu
13. Hetherington*
14. Latu Fainu
15. Seyfarth
16. Hunt
17. Pole

18. Sione Fainu*
19. Da Silva
 
JB9918 said:
So if Pole does want to go to Melbourne do we ask for NAS straight away? Or let the season play out?

The issue would be the big dollars NAS is on in this year's cap.

Bateman out.

If we land May & Hetherington I think we just play it out & keep Pole as bench impact on lower dollars.

The contract extension stated an upgrade this year & 2 years after that.

Obviously the upgrade doesn't happen.

8. May*
9. Korosaui
10. Twal
11. Bird
12. Sam Fainu
13. Hetherington*
14. Latu Fainu
15. Seyfarth
16. Hunt
17. Pole

18. Sione Fainu*
19. Da Silva
Click to expand...
There is zero indication he would want to go down there early if he signs. If he did though, signing NAS would be a little silly given May has just come on the market. Any roster spot that becomes available, he should be no 1 priority.
 
Tom Shines said:
regardless of what he does .. the only barometer that matters is wins and losses …
Click to expand...
Tom, even a barometer isn’t all that useful on its own. Knowing it’s a low pressure event isn’t all that helpful without measuring humidity to know if there is water in the air.

Wins and Losses for us now is extremely telling. But to fight out of this mess it’s going to take five years of improvements on a number of gauges.
 
Mccarry said:
Tom, even a barometer isn’t all that useful on its own. Knowing it’s a low pressure event isn’t all that helpful without measuring humidity to know if there is water in the air.

Wins and Losses for us now is extremely telling. But to fight out of this mess it’s going to take five years of improvements on a number of gauges.
Click to expand...

it’s professional sport … wins and losses are the only things that matter at the end of they day … there aren’t participation awards like in the under 10s…

I have some doubts he will be here for 5 years personally… this is a tough gig and I’m assuming he doesn’t need the money or stress that badly …I do hope though he has a big hand in appointing his successor
 
Mccarry said:
Post 1.
Everyone who moaned and dished out of Richo for his patience should have a little smile now. Everyone who said he flew to England and so he needs to show results. Everyone who said he is all talk once he got home and still hardly signed anyone…

Smile because even when you are wrong, Richo has your back.

Richo predicted the offseason movement.

Richo waiting, despite the typical Aussie need for a leader to ‘look decisive’ is a powerful sign of his leadership

Even if he doesn’t sign anyone, I feel so happy to have a CEO in place who KNOWS RUGBY LEAGUE. A leader who doesn’t want to look good at his job, but instead wants to be good at his job.

Post 2 will be when he lands a couple of forwards to strengthen our pack.
Click to expand...
I will be the 1st to say I was wrong , but I just don’t see anything coming outr why , every other club is making signings that we could have really use , and please tell me what did he get out of England , NOTHING. But again if he has a rabbit up his sleeve I will apologise
 
Juice said:
Manase was looking to be one of the best 9’s in the comp before his incident. Would be worth giving him the chance although I’m pretty sure his shoulder is/was completely cooked, there’s a real possibility even without prison his NRL career could have been over by now
Click to expand...
Even if it was cooked... if its anything like the QLD system, inmates get all injuries, especially old / ortho "footy" injuries on 6 months incarceration these days.
 
We should go hard for May from roosters, he has the punch we need .
we should offer the stood down may a contract pending court , he wins he is with us .
if Bateman is going , Frizell or Elliot could work well
 
bptiger 0 said:
and please tell me what did he get out of England , NOTHING.
Click to expand...

He was doing some work over there for Rich Digital with his son … he has got a life after the Wests Tigers you know …if he got HBG to pick up the fare for his Business class seat ,,,, then even better ..
 
Tiger Morgs said:
I have a question for everyone.
Who would you prefer to keep Galvin or Latu if you can only one.
I think I would take Latu if it means we keep all of the Fainu's
Click to expand...
I really believe team Galvin & Benji will come to the realisation next season, that his size and speed will inhibit him staying at 5/8 and he is destined for the pack.
So Latu, hands down.
 
2025 pack - let me dream. lol. (If we want to be a top 6 side)

8. NAS
9. Api
10. May
11. Fainu
12. Frizel
13. Hetherington

Bench;
Klem,
Hunt
Twas/Seyfarth/ Sione
TDS/Latu/Bird

On the basis Pole to Melb, Bateman out. Frizelle early release + only 2 yr contract.

Would release Klem too to keep Sione on bench as a spot instead but not likely to have any takers.

Release AD for cap space to get both NAS and May. Yes short in centers but could find a smokey or have Bird / Toa / local junior play. Olam other spot or early retire him if his knee is bad.

Offload one of Naden, Sullivan - pay 50% of freight to release a spot and free up $.

Thanks for indulging
 
rugbygoated said:
The thing is, is he truly remorseful? And a leopard doesn't change its spots. We don't want to add bad off field culture to the bad on field and training culture
Click to expand...
Who knows if he's truly remorseful or not. Only those close know. But humans can, and do change, unlike leopards.
 
tigermate said:
2025 pack - let me dream. lol. (If we want to be a top 6 side)

8. NAS
9. Api
10. May
11. Fainu
12. Frizel
13. Hetherington

Bench;
Klem,
Hunt
Twas/Seyfarth/ Sione
TDS/Latu/Bird

On the basis Pole to Melb, Bateman out. Frizelle early release + only 2 yr contract.

Would release Klem too to keep Sione on bench as a spot instead but not likely to have any takers.

Release AD for cap space to get both NAS and May. Yes short in centers but could find a smokey or have Bird / Toa / local junior play. Olam other spot or early retire him if his knee is bad.

Offload one of Naden, Sullivan - pay 50% of freight to release a spot and free up $.

Thanks for indulging
Click to expand...
Bit of mongrel in that pack !
Reminds me a bit of Roach, Hemsley, McGuire etc.
 
Roosters are going to need half/hooker this year and they are fairly stocked with forwards.

I wonder if we can take Nat Butcher off their hands and give L Fainu or J Sullivan for a year loan deal ala Harry to us in 2020.

Do we have a third hooker behind Api? We could think about giving TDS to them for a year as well, he'll get some good exposure in the Roosters team.
 
tig_prmz said:
Roosters are going to need half/hooker this year and they are fairly stocked with forwards.

I wonder if we can take Nat Butcher off their hands and give L Fainu or J Sullivan for a year loan deal ala Harry to us in 2020.

Do we have a third hooker behind Api? We could think about giving TDS to them for a year as well, he'll get some good exposure in the Roosters team.
Click to expand...
Any loan to the Roosters, you’ll never see them again. Besides, no one wants Sullivan. He‘s dead weight.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 502 (members: 6, guests: 496)
Back
Top