Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[tigerballs]

Maybe we didn't let him go. Maybe he said he didn't want to commit to WT once his contract finished up. Or he could be homesick and wanting to return to QLD. Could be a bunch of reasons. If they're not in it for the long haul, no point keeping them around.

Might be because he's not going to play NRL

 

[Vicious]

Terrell is far more aggressive, makes much more impact, can break tackles and offload, while still tackling effectively. Twal is a workhorse but the second an opponent touches him he falls to the ground like a sack of spuds.

They are two completely different players.

I don’t see Terrell as someone who can bust tackles and put fear into the opposition.
At times he’s looked ok off the back of highly aggressive carries from his Roosters team mates, nothing plenty of our current forwards could not do themselves.
As I’ve said, he’s a good reliable player, but if you want or expect him to be the point of difference, you will be very disappointed.
Take his two games for Samoa against England as an example.

 

[Vicious]

Vicious, I like you and your input, even though we disagree on Bula, but May no better than Twal?

I don’t think there is much difference.
One thing for certain, we desperately need Bula to go to another level and play like he did against the Cowboys at Leichhardt much more consistently if we are to make a big improvement as a team in 2025.

 

[balmain boy]

I don’t see Terrell as someone who can bust tackles and put fear into the opposition.
At times he’s looked ok off the back of highly aggressive carries from his Roosters team mates, nothing plenty of our current forwards could not do themselves.
As I’ve said, he’s a good reliable player, but if you want or expect him to be the point of difference, you will be very disappointed.
Take his two games for Samoa against England as an example.

This season:

Twal: 26 tackle breaks, 565 post contact metres, 6 offloads, avg metres 80, tackling 97.2%, line breaks 0.
May: 64 tackle breaks, 1087 post contact metres, 40 offloads, avg metres 110, tackling 97.75%, line breaks 6.

May is also 3 years younger, and a far superior player.

Yes it's easier to look good in a better team with better players but May was still largely a bench prop and still punched out very impressive stats.

 

[gregjm87]

Terrell is far more aggressive, makes much more impact, can break tackles and offload, while still tackling effectively. Twal is a workhorse but the second an opponent touches him he falls to the ground like a sack of spuds.

They are two completely different players.

To add to this whilst Twal is an excellent tackler he is a horrible defender. He is one of the better front on defenders in the game but; he has no line speed. He is slow to get up and get back for the next tackle. He doesn't work from the inside out to prevent overlaps from happening.

 

[Tiger Tarl]

May would be our best prop. Will tighten the middle and will be our pack leader. I hope Benji and our CEO are all over it. IMO, it's no coincidence that he was in Samoa camp with captain Luai when the news dropped he was free to look. Much needed signing for us.

 

[PabloX]

Forget Hohepa Puru, just signed with the Sharks ffs

 

[weststigerman]

Forget Hohepa Puru, just signed with the Sharks ffs

Done. I didn’t know who he was before this post anyway.

 

[innsaneink]

@Kelce68 Walker gone for half the year, JWH gone,
now Terrell May & Brandon Smith shown the door smh

When did Smith get punted?
Missed that one

 

[Flippedy]

* Behind a superstar team and proven cheating.

Superstar team? Only in some years, won their first premiership with a bunch of mostly nuffies and have consistently performed well with lots of players who were unwanted at other clubs.

 

[BAGNF05]

Superstar team? Only in some years, won their first premiership with a bunch of mostly nuffies and have consistently performed well with lots of players who were unwanted at other clubs.

FMD Four of them are favourites to end up immortals 😂

 

[Darty the winger]

Have listened to the boys for a long time and their knowledge is in their tagline “unqualified opinion and unwavering bias”

That most recent podcast name will look ridiculous in a couple weeks to come. I didn’t even get to that trade part yet. Got a better chance of the snake coming out of retirement

Exactly these guys are Manly fans and are wanting this to happen. Not actually happening 🤦🏻‍♂️

 

[The Chad]

Forget Hohepa Puru, just signed with the Sharks ffs

Good, underrated pick-up by the Sharks. Brained them in KOE.

 

[The Chad]

When did Smith get punted?
Missed that one

He's not been cut. Story today saying he won't be re-signed beyond 2025. Very different story.

 

[Darty the winger]

TIGERS SET TO POACH YOUNG GUN​

The Tigers have plenty of good young halves in their ranks and are set to poach another one from the Dragons' junior ranks.

Levi Valesini is only 18 but has already played first grade against grown men for Albion Park in the Illawarra league.

The teenager had a ground-breaking year in 2024 - he was named Group 7 under 18 player of the year and also Illawarra South Coast Laurie Daley Cup MVP.

He's in talks with the joint venture and is likely to start next season playing for Wests Magpies in the SG Ball Cup.

"Levi is a real prospect and there has been plenty of interest in him," his manager Pierre Tannous told Wide World of Sports.

What position does he play ?

 

[Darty the winger]

This season:

Twal: 26 tackle breaks, 565 post contact metres, 6 offloads, avg metres 80, tackling 97.2%, line breaks 0.
May: 64 tackle breaks, 1087 post contact metres, 40 offloads, avg metres 110, tackling 97.75%, line breaks 6.

May is also 3 years younger, and a far superior player.

Yes it's easier to look good in a better team with better players but May was still largely a bench prop and still punched out very impressive stats.

Twal unfortunately is a reserve grader at best, he would not make any other NRL team.

 

[Kaito]

When did Smith get punted?
Missed that one

What Chad said mate, not cut free to look for 2025

 

[crazycat]

Dolphins are the last club that would need JAC, they already have Isaako, Bostock and Junior Tupou.
The only possible landing spots for JAC are Parramatta where it is highly likely he will be in 2025.
The Panthers might have a look at him if he comes cheap enough for them, otherwise Wests Tigers if we believe he is a better option than Charlie Staines.
I’ve always been a Charlie Staines fan, but was disappointed with his lack of impact last season. If we could sign JAC for no more than 350k for 2025 and was able to offload Staines to accomodate him, than why not.

Charlie Staines is one player I want us to keep.
Give him 1 season with Luai. 2022 he was playing a grand final and him linking up with Luai + Turuva who is used to the Penrith system. Who knows.

I even wonder if Naden would improve with Luai around.


When we talk about trading players, we miss the team aspect. Naden, Luai, Staines and Api kinda know of each other and have played together. Add Turuva who has a good combo with Luai then we see a backline that knows where people will be, what they will do.

Naden has to go, he is way too busted. But we should stop punting Staines immeaditly and see how he goes with a Penrith winger and 5/8 around him.

 

[carltonleach]

What position does he play ?

Pretty sure he’s a half back

 

[Tiger_Yoshi]

Dragons have gone off Douhie…😩😩😩