Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[TheKhan]

I've noticed the tigers have a digital membership which includes Kayo

only worth it if u use kayo all yr and not just for the NRL

 

[swag_tiger]

Maybe Pole and May can be our bash bros?
Or maybe I am to optimistic.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

I dont know why people seem to think Seyfarth finished the year strongly... Was it because he scored one decent try, that was created by Latu?

From what I remember he almost single handedly lost us the game against Souths at the back end of the year and was in the top 3 of worst disciplined players in the entire comp (penalties conceded to minutes played). He also let in soft tries when playing at second row at the back end of the year from rushing out of the line, leaving his half and outside backs isolated.

He has been in the squad for years now and his discipline and decision making has progressively gotten worse, which is very concerning.

If Seyfarth wasn't a local junior there wouldn't even be half the hype there is for him now. I just don't understand all the fanfare for a player who's been bang average for most of his time in first grade.

 

[Canadian Club]

He may have been, as you say one of the worst over the season, but do you have stats towards the end of the season that go against my impression that he was working hard on his discipline and that it actually improved.

I'm only going on my impression and was not using statistics.

In the first 12 games of the year he had 4 penalties and 1 sin bin.

In the last 12 games of the year he had 9 penalties and 1 sin bin.

He was actually worse at the end of the year. Its also worth noting that he has a much higher rate of giving away penalties when in the starting side and on the edge. Nearly all the games where he had zero errors and penalties were coming off the bench playing in the middle.

But he did score that one good try against Manly at the end of the year!

 

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

If Seyfarth wasn't a local junior there wouldn't even be half the hype there is for him now. I just don't understand all the fanfare for a player who's been bang average for most of his time in first grade.

Average?
You're being very generous.
He's camped in the bottom 10 percent of players in the NRL.

 

[Canadian Club]

If Seyfarth wasn't a local junior there wouldn't even be half the hype there is for him now. I just don't understand all the fanfare for a player who's been bang average for most of his time in first grade.

How many other teams in the comp would Seyfarth be a starting second rower come round 1?

If people were being realistic, it would be zero.

 

[upthetigers]

Average?
You're being very generous.
He's camped in the bottom 10 percent of players in the NRL.

He's one of the first picked in the 17 every week if we want to win games

 

[Kaito]

If Seyfarth wasn't a local junior there wouldn't even be half the hype there is for him now. I just don't understand all the fanfare for a player who's been bang average for most of his time in first grade.

Same for Sukkar & Tumeth, waste of spots

 

[Kaito]

I'm starting Porter on the right 4 now...

Edit: I know he's not top 30, but I'd give him the jumper over Sukkar, Seyfarth& Tumeth. Particularly Brandon, he's stubborn - should have got a deal elsewhere

 

[GNR4LIFE]

He's one of the first picked in the 17 every week if we want to win games

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

Want to have a look at Sukkar this season before we put him through the shredder.

 

[batboy]

If Seyfarth wasn't a local junior there wouldn't even be half the hype there is for him now. I just don't understand all the fanfare for a player who's been bang average for most of his time in first grade.

Word here is "He's starting to show some promise"
After 6 seasons in Top Grade, You'd certainly hope so.

Fantastic squad member,
But in reality, he'd be lucky to get 6 games a year at any other club.

 

[batboy]

Want to have a look at Sukkar this season before we put him through the shredder.

Same could be said for having him as our 2nd drop Back Rower (Where he currently is)

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

Same could be said for having him as our 2nd drop Back Rower (Where he currently is)

Your thoughts on him going forward?

 

[batboy]

Your thoughts on him going forward?

Don't have any Mate,
Done nothing to deserve a top 30 spot and we need 2 NRL backrowers in Front of him.
Where he goes from there is up to him.
He's a kid, Happy to keep him around in lower grades until he shows something...

Anyone claiming he's going to come on in the blink of an eye and instantly solve the back row issue
is not very realistic.

 

[bptiger 0]

I see molo has said he won’t play for the drag queens again , if he gets released would he be a good pick up , he hits the line hard and is a rugged defender, IF we got him we could play MAY as a lock , he plays big minutes and has a good offload .

So lets her ur thoughts people

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I see molo has said he won’t play for the drag queens again , if he gets released would he be a good pick up , he hits the line hard and is a rugged defender, IF we got him we could play MAY as a lock , he plays big minutes and has a good offload .

So lets her ur thoughts people

We need edges, not middles.

 

[Spartan117]

Want to have a look at Sukkar this season before we put him through the shredder.

Guys, He is still a kid.

Give him time to learn.

 

[Spartan117]

I see molo has said he won’t play for the drag queens again , if he gets released would he be a good pick up , he hits the line hard and is a rugged defender, IF we got him we could play MAY as a lock , he plays big minutes and has a good offload .

So lets her ur thoughts people

He dogged his Team mates whilst still under contract.

Absolute NO.

 

[ancient_magpie]

Want to have a look at Sukkar this season before we put him through the shredder.

He's only had 15 or 20 minutes in fg so far let's see how he goes in the trials not much else around for right sr