Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[pawsandclaws1]

Galvin will be one of the best in the years to come. Still under 20.Gll

He is a fittler, Laurie Daley type player.

This is more than just hype.

Daley was big and fast, used his pace, step, strength and had a great kicking game. He could play centre or 5/8 whereas Galvin's natural position will be in the forwards. Daley was yards quicker than Galvin and had the on field awareness to position his supports. One of our greats and making comparisons with him is not fair to Galvin.

 

[clontarfkid]

What is the "someone we want" doesn't want us ??

Of course...its gotta work for everybody..not just the player and his next team

 

[Dr_Ice]

At what point can the club do something though? Luai’s only played one game ffs! Maybe I only notice when it’s us but I swear this doesn’t happen to other clubs.
View attachment 20999

Yet he left the relationship he had with the whole Panthers squad

 

[Needaname]

Daley was big and fast, used his pace, step, strength and had a great kicking game. He could play centre or 5/8 whereas Galvin's natural position will be in the forwards. Daley was yards quicker than Galvin.

I wouldn’t class Daley as big, would be similar size to Issah Tago.
Fitler is the better comparison, 6’1/2 close to 100kg in his playing days. Not sure about the step.
Anasta and John Sutton other ones.
Remembering that Anasta played lock and backrow at the roosters primarily, Sutton was a backrower in that 2014 Souths team.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Spartan I'm of the camp if Galvin wanted to stay he already would have upgraded. He would be getting a massive payrise this and next year. Other thing is are we sure he's going to stay a 5/8. If he's not nearly a million a year is a lot of coin for a backrower or lock. If he is our future 5/8 permanently in the clubs eyes, great go crazy to keep him, if not let's just get some game time into Latu, the sooner he builds combinations with Luai the better.

well said if he was re signing with us then he does it this year and takes a payrise
galvin is as good as gooooone
turdesco 2.0
only fortunate thing is we have latu as a backup

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Daley was big and fast, used his pace, step, strength and had a great kicking game. He could play centre or 5/8 whereas Galvin's natural position will be in the forwards. Daley was yards quicker than Galvin and had the on field awareness to position his supports. One of our greats and making comparisons with him are not fare to Galvin.

Galvin will be more like the filter or anasta build playing that 13 role
Daley was never big enough to play in the forwards, was an ok centre ( in a great team and backline)and a very very good 6

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I wouldn’t class Daley as big, would be similar size to Issah Tago.
Fitler is the better comparison, 6’1/2 close to 100kg in his playing days. Not sure about the step.
Anasta and John Sutton other ones.
Remembering that Anasta played lock and backrow at the roosters primarily, Sutton was a backrower in that 2014 Souths team.

Daley was 6 foot tall, for a 5/8 that is not a bad size.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Galvin will be more like the filter or anasta build playing that 13 role
Daley was never big enough to play in the forwards, was an ok centre ( in a great team and backline)and a very very good 6

To be fair, he was a Kangaroo and NSW SOO rep. He was a great player and I agree in a great team.

 

[Buttface]

Possible but if the club he's going to doesn't want him till 27 and no players want to come back the other way or they are not what we need it makes it difficult.

There’s always an option

 

[Don Kershane]

Daley was 6 foot tall, for a 5/8 that is not a bad size.

I'll take my tape measure next time I go to Northbridge Hotel.

 

[TurnStyle]

Couldn't happen to a nicer club, good luck Newcastle with 10 years of Salary cap issues

Agree. I think they're stupid to do it.

 

[TurnStyle]

Yep that's the market value right there.

Ash Taylor was worth 1m because he got 1m.

Ofcourse that's not the true player value.

Penrith, Easts and Storm get players to stay for unders and perform. I am completely lost as to why they stay at Easts.

That's the interesting thing about player value: Newcastle think he's worth that, everyone else thinks they're mad...

But at the end of the day the value of anything is the amount someone will pay.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

That's the interesting thing about player value: Newcastle think he's worth that, everyone else thinks they're mad...

But at the end of the day the value of anything is the amount someone will pay.

This is so true but my opinion is the knights have Ka Ka for brains.

 

[Ermo]

Why wouldn’t Galvin go to the market place come November?? If I was a player I would be doing the same, fielding all the offers than going back to the club I really want to play for and seeing how close they can get to the money being offered. It also gives my agent time to drum up a frenzy.

Anyway as others have said we have him till October 2026 on average coin, so we can still get plenty of football out of him and there s always another kid wanting a chance at the NRL

Why don’t we wave the November 1 date and let him take offers now. If he signs somewhere else gives us plenty of time for Latu to play more games

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I for one am not concerned about the Galvin situation, if he chooses to leave we put Latu straight in, if he stays we ensure no clauses are in his contract and happy days. Either way for once in the Tiger's history we actually have strong back up options.

He won’t sign a contract without clauses. It’s the new in thing.

 

[liltiger]

He won’t sign a contract without clauses. It’s the new in thing.

With Isaac Moses as his manager guaranteed it would be full of get out clauses, especially now it's come out Luai has them, so he will know the club are willing to do it if they want to.

 

[weststigers]

With Isaac Moses as his manager guaranteed it would be full of get out clauses, especially now it's come out Luai has them, so he will know the club are willing to do it if they want to.

Reminds me of the old mortgage brokers. They used to churn their books by refinancing to other banks each year or 2 so they could get a new commission.

The get out clause favours the manager that wants to churn their clients every few years for more commissions.

 

[BAGNF05]

Why don’t we wave the November 1 date and let him take offers now. If he signs somewhere else gives us plenty of time for Latu to play more games

Richo did this with Stef and if he’s sees it coming , he’d do it again.

 

[Wiz]

Player agent commissions are paid monthly over the length of the contract, the same as when the player gets paid. They are not paid up front.

 

[craigtob]

Agree. I think they're stupid to do it.

Not sure with this, they seem to be able to make the semis often and attract top line players, with no one wanting out of club, not like our club at the moment ??