Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Buttface said:
Except for the first sentence I sorta agree.
But Simpkins was average here, I have never seen a hooker get sacked at the line as often as Jake, 3 times in one game. That has to be some kind of record. His decision making and delivery was slow, He had no idea on how to create space and time at the line. and a centremetre out from the opposition line is wear he got exposed.
I thought Lids was better but his thing was speed and injuries.
Click to expand...
Jake left Tigers at the age of 22.

I'd argue that any young hooker is going to have a series of deficiencies at such a young age.

Tallyn for example, who's 20, a similar age to when Jake was playing bit-part roles for us, has issues with service (at times), first-up contact and reliability on the goal line (as well).

That's just part of being a young footballer in the middle at NRL level.

Simpkin is no world-beater, but he's a good first grader who will play over 100 NRL games in my estimation. That is a damn good career, regardless of circumstance, if he gets there.
 
Last edited:
GNR4LIFE said:
As much as I dislike the Dogs, I don’t know why any player would willingly leave that club atm.
Click to expand...
GNR, it may be that his is not willing to leave, however Gus is also not willing to sign him that sees him leave or pursue Boxing like TPJ.
 
I've been told that WT see Latu as an out and out first grade half but not with the same ceiling as Galvin.

the pursuits of DCE and Reynolds indicate that they're trying to get a mentor in for the short-term to help him with increasing the height of said ceiling. for that reason, I don't think you'll see us pursue the likes of Metcalf and Sexton.
 
jrtiger said:
I've been told that WT see Latu as an out and out first grade half but not with the same ceiling as Galvin.

the pursuits of DCE and Reynolds indicate that they're trying to get a mentor in for the short-term to help him with increasing the height of said ceiling. for that reason, I don't think you'll see us pursue the likes of Metcalf and Sexton.
Click to expand...

Galvin is overrated imo, im not salty he's going i've just always had that opinion. I admit i have not seen much of Latu but what i have seen ive liked. Galvin is always going to be that player that is just a fitness freak and a competitor, which can get you a long way but i don't think he has the ceiling a lot of the pundits think he has.
 
Coastie_Tiger said:
Galvin is overrated imo, im not salty he's going i've just always had that opinion. I admit i have not seen much of Latu but what i have seen ive liked. Galvin is always going to be that player that is just a fitness freak and a competitor, which can get you a long way but i don't think he has the ceiling a lot of the pundits think he has.
Click to expand...
I certainly think Latu's the more naturally talented of the two, but it's what Galvin does before he gets the ball and what he does off it that puts him in that elite prospect class.

Latu needs to find his voice. he's also quite introspective from what I've seen. definitely more of a confidence player than Galvin from what I've seen, who tends to have the ability to flush what he did previously.

that's what sets them apart.
 
Coastie_Tiger said:
Galvin is overrated imo, im not salty he's going i've just always had that opinion. I admit i have not seen much of Latu but what i have seen ive liked. Galvin is always going to be that player that is just a fitness freak and a competitor, which can get you a long way but i don't think he has the ceiling a lot of the pundits think he has.
Click to expand...

Absolutely he is overrated. He does a lot of good things off the back of being arrogantly competitive and super fit. Both great attributes that will ensure he has a long and healthy career. However as far a pure natural talent goes he seriously lacks so many things
 
jrtiger said:
I've been told that WT see Latu as an out and out first grade half but not with the same ceiling as Galvin.

the pursuits of DCE and Reynolds indicate that they're trying to get a mentor in for the short-term to help him with increasing the height of said ceiling. for that reason, I don't think you'll see us pursue the likes of Metcalf and Sexton.
Click to expand...
If I had to choose between a fully fit Galvin or Latu for 5/8 I'd take Latu any day of the week for what he offers on both sides of the ball.

Jeez I'd love to know why whoever at the WT has formed that opinion. Sometimes being out of sight (i.e. injured) and the quiet one holds a player back.

I just hope Latu gets a solid half a season fully fit with Luai to show what he is capable of.
 
Coastie_Tiger said:
Galvin is overrated imo, im not salty he's going i've just always had that opinion. I admit i have not seen much of Latu but what i have seen ive liked. Galvin is always going to be that player that is just a fitness freak and a competitor, which can get you a long way but i don't think he has the ceiling a lot of the pundits think he has.
Click to expand...
Agree with that. I think he'll be a top 30-40 player in the NRL, but I think he lacks the speed and Walsh/Ponga/Moses/Cleary style brilliance to ever get to be a top 10.

IMO his best chance of doing that is getting a lot stronger and replicating what Yeo does but he thinks he's a 6.

Doesn't mean Latu is going to be better though, just means we might have dodged a bullet with Galvin.
 
Canadian Club said:
Completely disagree, it would screw up our cap and roster balance.

You can't have 7-8 props in a 30 man roster with the money that they are all on. Its not fantasy football. That's why its much more important to get a second rower and lock to free up Seyfarth and Twal to play prop.

If we were to get another FG quality prop (with KPP and a lock) that means that Sione, Twal and Seyfarth would all be in reserve grade. That's too much of the cap in grade. They would probably also look to leave, which puts you back to square one and having to replace them. Not to mention it would completely block the path of guys like Kit.
Click to expand...
Well I disagree Seyfarth has been playing second row and Terrell wants to play big minutes so move him to lock, that's props down by 2 and room for my suggested impact prop.
If KPP does sign, we have more depth at 2RF with Seyfarth in reserve grade, there has also been suggestions that Sione could be tried there as well.

As for those who have to play reserve grade, we need the depth look at the top teams compared to ours and there are always injuries, look at us now with Pole, he's a big out that's hard to replace with our lack of quality.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 713 (members: 3, guests: 710)
Back
Top