Why’s everyone dancing around it. The problem is Benji.
Not trying to butt heads- but why is it Benji that is the problem?
The problem pre-dates Benji.
If I had to put the cross hairs anywhere...it's the '5 year plan'.
And not in the way people think.
It's not STICKING to a 5 year plan. The club makes statements about adapting change....puts in place structures & 5 year plans....then changes parts of it every couple of years.
This isn't the same 5 year plan Tim Sheens had.
Or the 5 year plan Madge had.
Or the 5 year plan Cleary had.
I can see some value in upgrading the support staff around Benji. I believe Hodgo is better than Farah was as an assistant already. Bringing in an experienced guy to sit beside Benji wouldn't hurt- but it has to be the right experienced guy. Anthony Griffin has always been talked about as a great development coach- from his time way back to the Broncos. Not surprisingly- he was part of the Panthers rebuild for a time too.
Changing Benji now starts a brand new 5 year plan. Restarts all the current schemes, systems, roster plans etc.
We are getting better players into the club. The key now is to STICK with the plan. See it through. Actually commit to something.
We are a rubbish club with a bunch of rubbish players. Losing guys like TDS & Galvin might sound terrible at the moment. But who are they, really? There are MAYBE 3-4 guys in the club that I would say must be kept. The rest are really quite replaceable.
Don't compare the CURRENT Tigers to the CURRENT Bulldogs. Gould started that rebuild in 2021. Richo started in 2024. I remember the Tigers taking the wooden spoon away from the Bulldogs not that long ago.
We will lose far more players before we are done. And I'm sure it will be a terrible day for the club we never recover from. Until we do.
TDS would make ZERO difference this weekend against the Roosters when we are already without Bula, Luai & Api. We will struggle, not because Tallyn is gone, but because there is no Bula, Luai & Api.
Context is needed. We are on as many wins as last season already. We have lost more games by 4 points than by 40 points compared to last season.
Our current bludging prop is dropped to KOE. Last year, our biggest bludging prop joined the Storm. We are in a stronger position there too.
We need back rowers & centres. The club has added KPP for next season already.
Benji might be in charge of a team not winning games. But, compared to last season, there is overall improvement. The club needs to get the squad balance right.