The squad is on the improve and the younger players will be better for a more positive season.
Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
Enmore_Tiger
Well-known member
I think those criticizing Luai are off their heads. I'm all in.
(and he didn't once totally break open a key Origin game that he was picked for lol...)
(and he didn't once totally break open a key Origin game that he was picked for lol...)
I agree 100% with ur take on some of our forwards , but if u can go back and see the amount of times that they get gassed and the opposition pure throw the middle , that’s why we need mongrel forwards who can play big minutes and have been round the traps , without them our pack is very light on
clontarfkid
Well-known member
Core problem..but not gonna happen/13th seen as a pass mark by many..its still a fail
Need to beef up our forward pack so that guys like Pole and Seaforth are on the bench
They are already likely on the bench when we full strength,
13. Twal
12. KPP
11. Sam Fainu
10. Sione Fainu
9. Korisau
8. May
14. Doueihi or Latu Fainu
15. Seyfarth
16. Pole
17. Hunt
It really doesn’t look too bad of a forward pack when we are full strength, but I do agree 2 good solid forward recruits are needed to beef up our depth just in case our spare and emerging forwards such as Geyer, Sukkar, Laulilli, Roberts, Godinet, Saukuru and Taupau-Moors do not show they are ready to be strong contributors at NRL level.
426Tlgerland
Well-known member
Still haven’t seen the see ya later list ,
Who is gone
Who is free to negotiate under contract
Who is gone
Who is free to negotiate under contract
An elite assistant coach is indeed needed.
- Backline in solid (1-5). Don’t think there is much value in chasing anymore outside backs unless they are younger development.
- Douiehi moves to 13 but plays as an additional half.
- Latu is getting better but he does still drift in and out of games especially at the back end and he does seem a bit injury prone.
- I think I would go hard at a small forward who can play dummy half and who is a very solid defender. A Brandon Smith/Cam McGuiness type player. I know we have Charlie Murray but I believe the player should be hooker who has transitioned into a forward (not the other way round) as the DH role is so specialised.
- I would also go after an impact middle who can punch out 30-40 minutes a game. This should ease the burden on Terrel who should be a 60 minute player.
Not sure who is out there but having those two inclusions would be great for the balance of the squad and closer to a top 8 position.
- Douiehi moves to 13 but plays as an additional half.
- Latu is getting better but he does still drift in and out of games especially at the back end and he does seem a bit injury prone.
- I think I would go hard at a small forward who can play dummy half and who is a very solid defender. A Brandon Smith/Cam McGuiness type player. I know we have Charlie Murray but I believe the player should be hooker who has transitioned into a forward (not the other way round) as the DH role is so specialised.
- I would also go after an impact middle who can punch out 30-40 minutes a game. This should ease the burden on Terrel who should be a 60 minute player.
Not sure who is out there but having those two inclusions would be great for the balance of the squad and closer to a top 8 position.
Adam O’Brien?
Come on we have had our time with wooden spoon lol 🤔🥴
Snidest 0
Well-known member
Stop misquotong everyone dickhead!
Your constant repetitive posts denigrating the quality of the better players in our squad just continue to further establish you as the dumbest MF on the forum - and given Axel and GI Jerkoff that is a very low bar indeed!
pawsandclaws1
Well-known member
When Bula was missing, we lacked the x factor and ball playing he brings from fullback. Turuva played really well but lacks the ball playing and extra zip of Bula. So while it is accurate to call our backs solid, we need to find one or two backs with x factor.
Don’t lose your pom poms, you will need them to cheer when we climb up to 10th on the ladder.
Correct, every team needs an elite fullback with x-factor.
No question Bula has a certain element of that in his game, but does he have enough of it to elevate our current squad into the top 8 ?
Once his contract is upgraded and extended he will become clearly our 2nd highest paid player behind Luai, therefore the expectation will be on those two to regularly provide the x/factor and match winning plays.
Maybe 2026 is the year they both step up and do this on a more regular basis, hopefully for the sake of all Wests Tigers fans they do.
Both are very good players, no question about that, my question and I’m not alone in saying that as a marquee player package, are they good to win us enough games to get into the 8 or better.?
I actually think Bula is a similar class of player. His speed, athleticism and size would all be quite similar. My criticism of Bula and why I agree he is not a million dollars player and not yet worth what we would be paying him is he hasn't got any other strings to his bow that other fullbacks have. He is no good at organising a defensive line, he is not a play maker, not a huge metre eater, not a kicking option.
He is an exceptional athlete and great in the air. I've little doubt he would look fantastic on the wing at a top team. He is not (yet) a top fullback that should be getting big dollars. But he is our best option and hopefully will become a very good fullback and a popular player, so I think we need to pay him the 900k or close to it.
happy_tiger
Well-known member
1
You are smart enough to know our current playing roster is simply not good enough to win a premiership and we are banking on our emerging players to make the necessary improvements to make us genuine top 8 contenders in 2026.
We should get further improvement from all 3 Fainu brothers and Pole, likely improvement from Luai, Bua and both May brothers.
Sukkar should be a much more confident and better player after getting plenty of NRL experience this season and both Laulilli brothers will be another year, older, stronger and better..
it’s unknown how quickly and how much improvement we get in 2026 from Makasini and we are hoping the likes of Roberts, Godinet, Taupau-Moors, Hayward, Andrew’s etc improve quickly to become genuine NRL contenders.
When you bank on youth and a couple of them become top class NRL players it is the perfect scenario, so I clearly understand the direction the club is heading and it’s not without hope of being a successful plan, but it’s also thwart with danger as if we fail to make the top 8 in 2026 or 2027 it realistically becomes yet another rebuild including the coach.
💯
You are smart enough to know our current playing roster is simply not good enough to win a premiership and we are banking on our emerging players to make the necessary improvements to make us genuine top 8 contenders in 2026.
We should get further improvement from all 3 Fainu brothers and Pole, likely improvement from Luai, Bua and both May brothers.
Sukkar should be a much more confident and better player after getting plenty of NRL experience this season and both Laulilli brothers will be another year, older, stronger and better..
it’s unknown how quickly and how much improvement we get in 2026 from Makasini and we are hoping the likes of Roberts, Godinet, Taupau-Moors, Hayward, Andrew’s etc improve quickly to become genuine NRL contenders.
When you bank on youth and a couple of them become top class NRL players it is the perfect scenario, so I clearly understand the direction the club is heading and it’s not without hope of being a successful plan, but it’s also thwart with danger as if we fail to make the top 8 in 2026 or 2027 it realistically becomes yet another rebuild including the coach.
Last edited:
You must have been swervin in 18-19
merv?
Roosters did exactly that.
You don’t need to buy a whole team, just the right 2-3 players…
Staff online
-
DempsModerator