Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Fainu Brothers]

I’m hearing there’s a very good chance Richo will depart the club within the next week.

Absolutely devastating stuff….. Peter V’landys needs to do something because us fans don’t deserve to be held ransom by the HGB group.

I’m not sure how much more I can take as a fan anymore.

Gutted

 

[bptiger 0]

lol



Wish MERITON would buy us , it would be a drop in the ocean for him

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

As an old Magpie the Balmain sides of the 1980s were awesome. I know I'll leave great players out but players like Jack, Mick Neill, Pearce, Sirro, Blocker and Back Door were outstanding. I still think Elias was the best hooker I've ever seen and tough as nails too. Terrible human but great footballer.
Warren Ryan butchered you blokes in the 1989 GF.

Elias as a player changed how hookers were played he was outstanding
one of the best players I saw and he played for both clubs was the black pearl Ellery Hanley

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

Elias as a player changed how hookers were played he was outstanding
one of the best players I saw and he played for both clubs was the black pearl Ellery Hanley

When he first came across from the UK to play for us man he ripped teams apart, so elusive and fast.

 

[The Chad]

Hanley was in my Top 3 favourite footballers I've had the privelage of seeing play.

Wayne Pearce, Hanley & later on, Benji Marshall.

Obviously it's a biased list, but those 3 formed my footballing mind.

 

[crazycat]

Depends on how far you go back. Wests were dubbed ‘the millionaire club’ back in the 50’s & 60s. The whole battlers thing was brought into play by Roy Masters in the 70’s and has been carried forward from there.

Balmain have won the third most premierships in their time and were considered a top club early on, but that certainly hasn’t always been the case. From what I can remember growing up they were a pretty average team, their underdog status in the 1969 GF attests to that. The 1980s brought change when they had some great line ups going around. I don’t ever recall Balmain being considered classier though by any stretch of the imagination.

As for Collingwood, they’ve always been one of the most supported and successful teams. Not sure about universally hated unless you’re a Carlton supporter lol. I think the Swans were at one stage on a par with being most hated club especially when they first entered the AFL.

I really don't know re AFL, except the amount of hate I read about Collingwood seems to be a common factor. Swans are hated and rightly so, they are their Storm...

Who is your LEAST favourite AFL club? The survey results are in!

The votes have been counted.

sen.com.au

Apparently Collingwood is the most hated team.

I don't think there was any great Wests Magpies hate in the NRL. Strange Wests being called the "Millionaries club" during St George's massive Grand final stretch in the 50's.

 

[crazycat]

I’m hearing there’s a very good chance Richo will depart the club within the next week.

Absolutely devastating stuff….. Peter V’landys needs to do something because us fans don’t deserve to be held ransom by the HGB group.

I’m not sure how much more I can take as a fan anymore.

Man you look at the HGB directors

Our Directors - Holman Barnes Group

Holman Barnes Group is led by a group professionals who are skilled company directors and passionate supporters.

holmanbarnesgroup.com.au

It's like a picture of RSL board directors that basically don't leave the club and still demand a smoko balcony.

You compare that against a former State Premier (who is rather liked by most people).
Firing Barry O'Farrell is like the Dodgy cheap Lawyer firing the constitutional expert in "the Castle"

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I really don't know re AFL, except the amount of hate I read about Collingwood seems to be a common factor. Swans are hated and rightly so, they are their Storm...

Who is your LEAST favourite AFL club? The survey results are in!

The votes have been counted.

sen.com.au

Apparently Collingwood is the most hated team.

I don't think there was any great Wests Magpies hate in the NRL. Strange Wests being called the "Millionaries club" during St George's massive Grand final stretch in the 50's.

Collingwood are the AFL’s version of Souths. Even down to the jokes about their supporters. What’s the last thing a Collingwood and Souths fan says before they die? Watch this.

 

[bptiger 0]

He's not that good.

Our u talking about blore , if so he is miles better than we have , Bellamy doesn’t pick crap players , would have him back in a heart beat

 

[weststigers]

Our u talking about blore , if so he is miles better than we have , Bellamy doesn’t pick crap players , would have him back in a heart beat

Talking about Da Silva

 

[bptiger 0]

Talking about Da Silva

Just back from holidays , was not sure , I agree with you on da Silva

 

[Vicious]

Just back from holidays , was not sure , I agree with you on da Silva

Who the 2nd best part time hooker from Parramatta ?

 

[weststigers]

Who the 2nd best part time hooker from Parramatta ?

Aravinda Da Silva...used to get around for Sri Lanka

 

[Vicious]

Aravinda Da Silva...used to get around for Sri Lanka

I just hope he keeps that haircut, it will look good sitting on the Eels bench.
I shouldn’t say that he’s actually a very good young man and in time he will be an exceptionally good NRL number 9..
Who can begrudge him of leaving us for the big money he was offered, I just don’t think it was a good career choice as Ryley Smith is not much older and a tougher, more aggressive and more physical player at this stage of their careers.
I am confident TDS will be a better player than Api by the 2027 season, but we still couldn’t justify paying him the money he was asking for and what the Eels are supposedly paying him.

 

[tigahhh]

do they normally announce who’s in our leadership group for the season ? just seen manly announce theirs and wondered if we have something like that.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

do they normally announce who’s in our leadership group for the season ? just seen manly announce theirs and wondered if we have something like that.

Might be a delay in case there's a player exodus 😮.

 

[Vicious]

Might be a delay in case there's a player exodus 😮.

The Bears are struggling to attract players, maybe we can merge with them if worse comes to worse.
No HBG involvement it could be a good thing.

 

[BAGNF05]

The Bears are struggling to attract players, maybe we can merge with them if worse comes to worse.
No HBG involvement it could be a good thing.

They will just pick our best off one by one. No need for us.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

The Bears are struggling to attract players, maybe we can merge with them if worse comes to worse.
No HBG involvement it could be a good thing.

Lol are trying to start another forum war.

 

[hank37w]

As long as there's not a large magpie on the jersey who really gives a F, just can't see a big bird scaring the life out of the opposition.

If the Holman Barnes Muppet show is still around, this could be the Big Bird we have and I think that's pretty scary.



It is kind of a bit on the orange side though.