Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Plus, we have a coach who has no idea what he’s doing

Thats a heavy statement, I'd say he does have some idea.

He has had a baptism of fire with various unusual situations to deal with, and he has less resources than every other club, so considering his circumstances, I'd say he's learnt a fair bit and has some idea.

And the other thing about Benji compared to other coaches is that I think he genuinely wants the club to succeed and wears his heart on his sleeve.

And its fair to say the players do hold him in high regard.
 
It's an observation not a criticism....if they wanted to loan Latu out last year was the time to do it. If it's about development they would put him in cup for the year with Andrews. It has zero to do with his development and everything to do with Benji keeping his job.

Forgarty and Fox are not taking us to the top 8 and we will be lucky to avoid the bottom 4 should we persist with AD in the halves .....
I don’t disagree. they should’ve had Latu at 7 in Cup for the long haul last year but decided yet again to waste time for him and the club itself.

that said, here we are and the circumstances have changed. while I can understand why you think Fogarty won’t get us to the 8, he’s the best option we have to play the role Marshall needs from his halfback.

and I say this as someone who wants Latu to be our long-term 7.
 
But you are saying that like the Benji critics dont agree or arent saying the same. Most of, if not close to all, agree with what you just said. Just because one says Benji cant coach doesnt mean they dont think the rest of the stuff you have pointed out. Or do you want them to state eveything that is wrong with the club every time the criticise Benji?
I like what you have to say and believe it or not agree with you
 
while I struggle with it myself, I’ll try and paint a picture based on what it is when it works…

at its core, Benjiball is based on repeat efforts and elite physical fitness. defensively that looks like multiple men in tackles and aggressive linespeed, hard scramble and tying in from the inside, kick pressure and supporting one another constantly.

in attack it manifests in offloads and second phase and wearing down opponents by constantly applying pressure with similar shapes and slight variations.

it requires belief, patience and cool heads, because it isn’t sexy or particularly polished.

the forward pack is typically mobile and toils. the backs have a low centre of gravity designed to break tackles and make ground.

in the spine, the 1’s main responsibility is to play through the middle corridor like an old school fullback and sniff around for offloads and take carries. the 9 looks to utilise their deceptive skillset to hold up the markers and the A and B defenders.

in the halves, one is the controlling and organising type that is typically the pass before the pass, while the other plays both sides out the back of shape like a typical fullback, arriving late to apply pressure and put defenders in two minds in good ball territory.

see wins against NZ in NZ, Newcastle at Campbelltown (2026) and Cronulla and St George (2025) for it’s best examples.

how’d I go?
Sounds good, when can we adopt that as normal practice.
 
So you feel you can attack others opinions and create strawmans without telling them why they are wrong? Bold strategy, Cotton.
It wasn’t my intention to attack your opinion and of course you are entitled to one I apologise if it came across wrong way. I’m sorry I don’t understand what strawmans or cotton means I am an old man can you explain please
 
I don’t disagree. they should’ve had Latu at 7 in Cup for the long haul last year but decided yet again to waste time for him and the club itself.

that said, here we are and the circumstances have changed. while I can understand why you think Fogarty won’t get us to the 8, he’s the best option we have to play the role Marshall needs from his halfback.

and I say this as someone who wants Latu to be our long-term 7.
I see where your coming from.... I just feel it will be a long tough year with no finals footy and Benji will get the ass anyway.....
 
It wasn’t my intention to attack your opinion and of course you are entitled to one I apologise if it came across wrong way. I’m sorry I don’t understand what strawmans or cotton means I am an old man can you explain please
Strawman is arguing a point the other person never made. It’s all good. I wasn’t saying you can’t support the guy. We all want him to succeed. It just doesn’t seem likely he will.
 
Strawman is arguing a point the other person never made. It’s all good. I wasn’t saying you can’t support the guy. We all want him to succeed. It just doesn’t seem likely he will.

Yes but why won't he succeed?

Is it because he's "............a coach who has no idea what he’s doing"

Sometimes black and white statements don't help, imagine if a journo came out and said this?
 
Back
Top