Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[avocadoontoast]

would you trade
Tommy for JAC
Nofo for JAC
Brooks for JAC

NO!

I'd think hard about maybe trading Brooks but none of the others. And, I still want Momorovski back.

I'd trade Tommy T or Nofo in a heartbeat for JAC. They can keep Momirovski.

So, Nofo for JAC, they keep Momo and you pay JAC FB money. Talk about sell your soul.

Well I wouldn't have signed Momo anyway. He's not needed. And I think JAC is a far superior player to Nofo.

 

[Russell]

I would trade nobody.

If we want him to play FB - we will have to pay far too much anyway, let alone adding a top junior.

He would not be worth half that. Rather have Johnston, or maybe Staines, if we are desperate for a FB.

I don't think we are, I think we already have one, so we are only looking for a winger with speed.

JAC does not have anything else to offer. 500k should be more than enough - if not, we do to him what he did to us. See ya!

You said the other day you'd pay $650k for JAC.

If you go back I said and I quote "650k Max."

Not after last night, playing with an ordinary team, and we are an ordinary team.

My figure is now 500k Max. as a winger only.

 

[Russell]

would you trade
Tommy for JAC
Nofo for JAC
Brooks for JAC

NO!

I'd think hard about maybe trading Brooks but none of the others. And, I still want Momorovski back.

I'd trade Tommy T or Nofo in a heartbeat for JAC. They can keep Momirovski.

So, Nofo for JAC, they keep Momo and you pay JAC FB money. Talk about sell your soul.

Well I wouldn't have signed Momo anyway. He's not needed. And I think JAC is a far superior player to Nofo.

So FB money and two players for an untried FB.

Glad you aren't our recruitment officer Avo.

 

[JC99]

I would trade nobody.

If we want him to play FB - we will have to pay far too much anyway, let alone adding a top junior.

He would not be worth half that. Rather have Johnston, or maybe Staines, if we are desperate for a FB.

I don't think we are, I think we already have one, so we are only looking for a winger with speed.

JAC does not have anything else to offer. 500k should be more than enough - if not, we do to him what he did to us. See ya!

You said the other day you'd pay $650k for JAC.

If you go back I said and I quote "650k Max."

Not after last night, playing with an ordinary team, and we are an ordinary team.

My figure is now 500k Max. as a winger only.

One game and he’s down $150k yeesh ?

 

[Aesopian]

I would trade nobody.

If we want him to play FB - we will have to pay far too much anyway, let alone adding a top junior.

He would not be worth half that. Rather have Johnston, or maybe Staines, if we are desperate for a FB.

I don't think we are, I think we already have one, so we are only looking for a winger with speed.

JAC does not have anything else to offer. 500k should be more than enough - if not, we do to him what he did to us. See ya!

You said the other day you'd pay $650k for JAC.

If you go back I said and I quote "650k Max."

Not after last night, playing with an ordinary team, and we are an ordinary team.

My figure is now 500k Max. as a winger only.

One game and he’s down $150k yeesh ?

Only as good as your last game lol

As of now he's a nuffie

 

[avocadoontoast]

would you trade
Tommy for JAC
Nofo for JAC
Brooks for JAC

NO!

I'd think hard about maybe trading Brooks but none of the others. And, I still want Momorovski back.

I'd trade Tommy T or Nofo in a heartbeat for JAC. They can keep Momirovski.

So, Nofo for JAC, they keep Momo and you pay JAC FB money. Talk about sell your soul.

Well I wouldn't have signed Momo anyway. He's not needed. And I think JAC is a far superior player to Nofo.

So FB money and two players for an untried FB.

Glad you aren't our recruitment officer Avo.

Russ if you were recruitment officer Tui would still be fullback, Liddle would be on $5m a season and Rowdy would have just re-signed to 2030.

 

[avocadoontoast]

I would trade nobody.

If we want him to play FB - we will have to pay far too much anyway, let alone adding a top junior.

He would not be worth half that. Rather have Johnston, or maybe Staines, if we are desperate for a FB.

I don't think we are, I think we already have one, so we are only looking for a winger with speed.

JAC does not have anything else to offer. 500k should be more than enough - if not, we do to him what he did to us. See ya!

You said the other day you'd pay $650k for JAC.

If you go back I said and I quote "650k Max."

Not after last night, playing with an ordinary team, and we are an ordinary team.

My figure is now 500k Max. as a winger only.

One game and he’s down $150k yeesh ?

If we wait 3 more games we can buy him with Rowdy's money and still have $100k left over.

 

[izotope]

Don't forget the foxx is desperately trying to get to Sydney, so different situation as trying to entice say a keary over.

He wanted to be in Sydney last year to be close to family and unfortunately lost 4 family members this year.

Whatever happens he will be at a Sydney club in 2021 IMO.

 

[izotope]

REYNOLDS SUPER LEAGUE BOUND?

Wests Tigers utility Josh Reynolds could end up in the English Super League if that was an avenue he’d like to go down.

Brent Read told Triple M there could be a spot for Reynolds at Wigan, but a couple of dominoes would need to fall first.

“There’s a bit of movement in England at the moment and Josh Reynolds’ name is on the radar,” he said.

“There’s some interest from Leeds but Wigan is the interesting one. As I understand they’ve agreed to a deal with (Eels half) Jai Field, but he needs to play another game to take up that deal.

“The other moving piece there is Bevan French. There's some speculation he wants to come back to Australia, return to the NRL.

“If Jai Field doesn’t come to fruition or Bevan French comes home then that may open up a spot for Josh Reynolds.”

31-year-old Reynolds is contracted to the Tigers until the end of next year and is unlikely to be re-signed by the club given Billy Walters is coming through. A move to the UK could be a good move for the longevity of his career, given he’s more likely to get a longer deal there than in the NRL.

 

[avocadoontoast]

REYNOLDS SUPER LEAGUE BOUND?

Wests Tigers utility Josh Reynolds could end up in the English Super League if that was an avenue he’d like to go down.

Brent Read told Triple M there could be a spot for Reynolds at Wigan, but a couple of dominoes would need to fall first.

“There’s a bit of movement in England at the moment and Josh Reynolds’ name is on the radar,” he said.

“There’s some interest from Leeds but Wigan is the interesting one. As I understand they’ve agreed to a deal with (Eels half) Jai Field, but he needs to play another game to take up that deal.

“The other moving piece there is Bevan French. There's some speculation he wants to come back to Australia, return to the NRL.

“If Jai Field doesn’t come to fruition or Bevan French comes home then that may open up a spot for Josh Reynolds.”

31-year-old Reynolds is contracted to the Tigers until the end of next year and is unlikely to be re-signed by the club given Billy Walters is coming through. A move to the UK could be a good move for the longevity of his career, given he’s more likely to get a longer deal there than in the NRL.

That would be a great for the club and would free up a stack of cash.

 

[Russell]

I would trade nobody.

If we want him to play FB - we will have to pay far too much anyway, let alone adding a top junior.

He would not be worth half that. Rather have Johnston, or maybe Staines, if we are desperate for a FB.

I don't think we are, I think we already have one, so we are only looking for a winger with speed.

JAC does not have anything else to offer. 500k should be more than enough - if not, we do to him what he did to us. See ya!

You said the other day you'd pay $650k for JAC.

If you go back I said and I quote "650k Max."

Not after last night, playing with an ordinary team, and we are an ordinary team.

My figure is now 500k Max. as a winger only.

One game and he’s down $150k yeesh ?

Doesn't pay you to have a bad game Josh.

Unlike others I am not blinded by his speed - because that is all he has.

650k Max. if he was a FB and he is not - so 500k as a winger only.

 

[WeststigsRdaBest]

Talau will be a marquee centre..with Nofo on the books already...talau is worth more to me than the fox however I would love the fox

 

[JC99]

I would trade nobody.

If we want him to play FB - we will have to pay far too much anyway, let alone adding a top junior.

He would not be worth half that. Rather have Johnston, or maybe Staines, if we are desperate for a FB.

I don't think we are, I think we already have one, so we are only looking for a winger with speed.

JAC does not have anything else to offer. 500k should be more than enough - if not, we do to him what he did to us. See ya!

You said the other day you'd pay $650k for JAC.

If you go back I said and I quote "650k Max."

Not after last night, playing with an ordinary team, and we are an ordinary team.

My figure is now 500k Max. as a winger only.

One game and he’s down $150k yeesh ?

Doesn't pay you to have a bad game Josh.

Unlike others I am not blinded by his speed - because that is all he has.

650k Max. if he was a FB and he is not - so 500k as a winger only.

He was just speed when he was with us he’s more than that now.

I’m happy with $500k-$600k, there’s no way you could go any more than that, he’s never played fullback why should he expect fullback money? Come here on winger money if you kill it at fullback we can upgrade you, seems fair to me

 

[JC99]

REYNOLDS SUPER LEAGUE BOUND?

Wests Tigers utility Josh Reynolds could end up in the English Super League if that was an avenue he’d like to go down.

Brent Read told Triple M there could be a spot for Reynolds at Wigan, but a couple of dominoes would need to fall first.

“There’s a bit of movement in England at the moment and Josh Reynolds’ name is on the radar,” he said.

“There’s some interest from Leeds but Wigan is the interesting one. As I understand they’ve agreed to a deal with (Eels half) Jai Field, but he needs to play another game to take up that deal.

“The other moving piece there is Bevan French. There's some speculation he wants to come back to Australia, return to the NRL.

“If Jai Field doesn’t come to fruition or Bevan French comes home then that may open up a spot for Josh Reynolds.”

31-year-old Reynolds is contracted to the Tigers until the end of next year and is unlikely to be re-signed by the club given Billy Walters is coming through. A move to the UK could be a good move for the longevity of his career, given he’s more likely to get a longer deal there than in the NRL.

That would be great for us fingers crossed. Would be a win win for everyone to be honest

 

[JC99]

I wonder if Josh is keen to go to England. He’s had a pretty shocker year and a half and it doesn’t look like he’s got a partner and kids or anything so it could be a good time for him.

 

[mike]

Talau will be a marquee centre..with Nofo on the books already...talau is worth more to me than the fox however I would love the fox

This is why we are ninth. Potential rated more highly than an actual marquee player. It beggars belief.

I’d have JAC here in a heartbeat over any ‘potential’ unproven rookie. Don’t get me wrong I really like Talau but JAC is already a marquee player and would bring so much to the club now.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Talau will be a marquee centre..with Nofo on the books already...talau is worth more to me than the fox however I would love the fox

This is why we are ninth. Potential rated more highly than an actual marquee player. It beggars belief.

I’d have JAC here in a heartbeat over any ‘potential’ unproven rookie. Don’t get me wrong I really like Talau but JAC is already a marquee player and would bring so much to the club now.

100%

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Talau will be a marquee centre..with Nofo on the books already...talau is worth more to me than the fox however I would love the fox

Nofoaluma has had a good year in attack and it is in the realm of possibilities that he will receive attractive offers from other clubs. If we jag JAC, Saab or Staines plus our current crop of young backs, the Club may feel it has sufficient depth in the outside backs.

 

[JD Tiger]

would you trade
Tommy for JAC
Nofo for JAC
Brooks for JAC

NO!

I'd think hard about maybe trading Brooks but none of the others. And, I still want Momorovski back.

I'd trade Tommy T or Nofo in a heartbeat for JAC. They can keep Momirovski.

So, Nofo for JAC, they keep Momo and you pay JAC FB money. Talk about sell your soul.

Well I wouldn't have signed Momo anyway. He's not needed. And I think JAC is a far superior player to Nofo.

I don't want to get side-tracked, but in what position do we think Momo will play in next year? He's really a centre, and we likely have BJ and MBye there, with Talau next in line. Where's Momo, second backup?

 

[avocadoontoast]

would you trade
Tommy for JAC
Nofo for JAC
Brooks for JAC

NO!

I'd think hard about maybe trading Brooks but none of the others. And, I still want Momorovski back.

I'd trade Tommy T or Nofo in a heartbeat for JAC. They can keep Momirovski.

So, Nofo for JAC, they keep Momo and you pay JAC FB money. Talk about sell your soul.

Well I wouldn't have signed Momo anyway. He's not needed. And I think JAC is a far superior player to Nofo.

I don't want to get side-tracked, but in what position do we think Momo will play in next year? He's really a centre, and we likely have BJ and MBye there, with Talau next in line. Where's Momo, second backup?

Reserve grade id imagine.