Stefano Utoikamanu #241

Give me Oregan Kaufisi and Jack Willliams for a combined $900k instead.
If that is true, we have to part ways.
The ROI is unacceptable at that cost.
We don’t know any numbers , Benji and Richo will keep it in house and after deal is done we will know , I think the 5 years could,be correct as I would offer him 5 but most likely at $ 750 k year 1 then adjustments via the cap each year after
 
We don’t know any numbers , Benji and Richo will keep it in house and after deal is done we will know , I think the 5 years could,be correct as I would offer him 5 but most likely at $ 750 k year 1 then adjustments via the cap each year after
$750k is a much better figure and we should only entertain more in future years once performance clauses are met based on him playing SOO & Test football. We don't want a David Fifita on our books.
 
Not sure how I feel about this. I see Pole come off the bench in our games and provide the impact needed to stay in the game. He is the more valuable prop in my opinion, from a long term perspective.
 
Doubt those numbers are anywhere near correct. That is way over his current value at the moment. The bloke hasn't done anything yet. He has never dominated 1 game. You aren't gonna pay him near 1 mill a year on potential. The tigers haven't learnt anything from past 'buys' if that's anywhere near the numbers they are talking about. $700-750k for 4yrs would be appropriate. After that his next contract if he is performing and at 28 years old and near peak as a prop and captain is when $1 mil a year over 4 should be talked about.
 
Doubt those numbers are anywhere near correct. That is way over his current value at the moment. The bloke hasn't done anything yet. He has never dominated 1 game. You aren't gonna pay him near 1 mill a year on potential. The tigers haven't learnt anything from past 'buys' if that's anywhere near the numbers they are talking about. $700-750k for 4yrs would be appropriate. After that his next contract if he is performing and at 28 years old and near peak as a prop and captain is when $1 mil a year over 4 should be talked about.
So we offer 700k

Penrith/Easts/Storm will offer him 750k and a chance to play finals.
Why would anyone stay?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
So we offer 700k

Penrith/Easts/Storm will offer him 750k and a chance to play finals.
Why would anyone stay?
I don't think those teams value Stefano that highly to be honest, probably a 600k / 3 year offer at most of those clubs.

Penrith are seemingly lining up Fifita with their JFH $ and Roosters have their 2 starting props cap wise with Collins & Leniu. Teams don't spend big $ on 3 props, Hargreaves wasn't on much this year. Storm won't make a competitive offer to Stefano unless they could move on NAS.
 
if we lose Stef who do we replace him with ?
A random player that offers exactly what he does at half the price? The guy hasnt produced shit since he has been here. He isnt worth more than 700/750 today. Are the Tigers willing to pay overs and buy him for 900 now in the hope he lives up to being that value and then repays the Tigers to stay on for another contract in 4 years time.....I doubt it with Richo around.
 
Last edited:
I see both sides when it comes to Stefano. He’s young and I think he will get better, but he should be doing better than what he’s currently doing. I wouldn’t pay him mega money yet, if we’re gonna give an upgrade I wouldn’t go higher than 700K. I could probably live with 750K max if we have to go that high but anything higher than that at this stage it’s just a waste of cap money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
If our halves and outside backs were good enough to generate tries then Stefano is coming off the back fence on the back of that momentum. There’s a term in NFL called complimentary football, meaning your defense thrives off your offense and vice versa. At the moment our backs are making our forwards look shit, and the frustration is very evident. Stef is elite. End of story.
 
If our halves and outside backs were good enough to generate tries then Stefano is coming off the back fence on the back of that momentum. There’s a term in NFL called complimentary football, meaning your defense thrives off your offense and vice versa. At the moment our backs are making our forwards look shit, and the frustration is very evident. Stef is elite. End of story.
Spot on.
 
If our halves and outside backs were good enough to generate tries then Stefano is coming off the back fence on the back of that momentum. There’s a term in NFL called complimentary football, meaning your defense thrives off your offense and vice versa. At the moment our backs are making our forwards look shit, and the frustration is very evident. Stef is elite. End of story.
Needs to start showing it. Start of story
 
Back
Top