I used to feel the same way a while back. Yes he has been poor this year but for the last couple of years he's obviously cracked NSW starting side and reserves a couple of times so must not have been that poor.
If this was a one off case, I would understand this feeling of yours but after having cycled through so many people who have wanted to leave after performing well here, it's the constant inability to support our most elite players which seems to push them off the edge.
In any career, you want to see growth in the way that you want to grow. It's simple that Stefano isn't ready for a leadership role and wants to improve more as a front rower than as a leader. Let's be honest, it's probably tougher physically at Melbourne or Roosters etc but mentally/ emotionally, it seems to be tougher here.
Not everyone is cut out for leadership and those who turn their backs on us may have good careers in other teams but rarely (e.g. Tedesco) do they turn out to be good leaders (Matterson, Moses, Aloiai, Woods etc)