Stefano Utoikamanu #241

It’s annoying that we took him in as a youngster and help develop him. Payed him overs for the faith of him sticking it out. Even though he wasn’t playing to a consistent high level often enough. Then he wants to sod off, Wayne ker!
Or.. we needlessly cycled through 4 coaches in less than 4 years which no doubt hampered the development of Stef and many other players and left him feeling another club would be better for his long term career.
 
Club needs a culture shift. Ideally Utoikamanu is part of that. But if not, or if we don't change how we play in the middle, it makes no real difference.

We cannot continue to lose the physical battle. It's nothing to do with size, or power running. It's stopping the opposition dominating the ruck, winning the wrestle, slowing our play & the Tigers not holding the opposition through the middle of the field.
 
Or.. we needlessly cycled through 4 coaches in less than 4 years which no doubt hampered the development of Stef and many other players and left him feeling another club would be better for his long term career.
Settle down captain negative!
Wow, what a surprise a team coming last 2-3 years in a row changing coaches that often. I would of expected them to be the most stable of clubs during this time?!?
I dont get your support for the club, we all know they are going crap. There’s no need to rubbish everything they are doing to correct it. With your rational we should expect to come last for ever, as there’s no point to go to a struggling club if your a good player.
I’ve said for a while now that clubs in the bottom 1/3 of clubs should get salary cap exceptions terraced up to the last team. Due to the lower clubs needing to offer more money to attract good players.
Otherwise the game becomes too boring same teams always at the top.
 
Settle down captain negative!
Wow, what a surprise a team coming last 2-3 years in a row changing coaches that often. I would of expected them to be the most stable of clubs during this time?!?
I dont get your support for the club, we all know they are going crap. There’s no need to rubbish everything they are doing to correct it. With your rational we should expect to come last for ever, as there’s no point to go to a struggling club if your a good player.
I’ve said for a while now that clubs in the bottom 1/3 of clubs should get salary cap exceptions terraced up to the last team. Due to the lower clubs needing to offer more money to attract good players.
Otherwise the game becomes too boring same teams always at the top.
I don’t think you’ve read that many of my recent posts but thanks for the feedback.

No doubt it’s turning into something like EPL with a big six clubs. A draft for elite U21’s would be my preferred fix.
 
Last edited:
Settle down captain negative!
Wow, what a surprise a team coming last 2-3 years in a row changing coaches that often. I would of expected them to be the most stable of clubs during this time?!?
I dont get your support for the club, we all know they are going crap. There’s no need to rubbish everything they are doing to correct it. With your rational we should expect to come last for ever, as there’s no point to go to a struggling club if your a good player.
I’ve said for a while now that clubs in the bottom 1/3 of clubs should get salary cap exceptions terraced up to the last team. Due to the lower clubs needing to offer more money to attract good players.
Otherwise the game becomes too boring same teams always at the top.
The draft was supposed to fix this and in AFL has definitely leveled the playing field and given lower placed clubs the opportunity to get of the canvas (still a bludger of a sport though…)
Players and player agents strangled this at birth in the NRL. Our very own Terry Hill (God rest his soul) in fact challenged this in court and won. A time where player (and agent) power was put ahead of the best interests of the sport.
The salary cap has worked to an extent, but it’s laughable when you compare certain rosters to think they are not rorting or at the very least operating in the margins. For instance, sign on with us for the final two years of your contract for way under and we will use our connections on the board to get you a media gig to supplement your income and set you up after footy. You probably have plausible deniability as a club with regards breaching the salary cap, but it’s not operating in the spirit of what the salary cap was intended to achieve.
Players should be given an assigned fair market value by the NRL when they are off or coming off contract. It doesn’t need to be an exact science, $100k bands would be fine. A player can sign for unders but the assigned fmv is what is counted in the cap. If a club wants to pay above the assigned value, they can, but the higher value is what’s included in the cap.
That would distribute talent more evenly within 3-4 seasons as players come off contract. You could provide some discount for an incumbent club resigning a player whose fmv has increased significantly during their time with the club. That would reward clubs who improved a players fmv while they were at the club.
 
The draft was supposed to fix this and in AFL has definitely leveled the playing field and given lower placed clubs the opportunity to get of the canvas (still a bludger of a sport though…)
Players and player agents strangled this at birth in the NRL. Our very own Terry Hill (God rest his soul) in fact challenged this in court and won. A time where player (and agent) power was put ahead of the best interests of the sport.
The salary cap has worked to an extent, but it’s laughable when you compare certain rosters to think they are not rorting or at the very least operating in the margins. For instance, sign on with us for the final two years of your contract for way under and we will use our connections on the board to get you a media gig to supplement your income and set you up after footy. You probably have plausible deniability as a club with regards breaching the salary cap, but it’s not operating in the spirit of what the salary cap was intended to achieve.
Players should be given an assigned fair market value by the NRL when they are off or coming off contract. It doesn’t need to be an exact science, $100k bands would be fine. A player can sign for unders but the assigned fmv is what is counted in the cap. If a club wants to pay above the assigned value, they can, but the higher value is what’s included in the cap.
That would distribute talent more evenly within 3-4 seasons as players come off contract. You could provide some discount for an incumbent club resigning a player whose fmv has increased significantly during their time with the club. That would reward clubs who improved a players fmv while they were at the club.
Great post champion @SwervinMervin but will Head Office ever see such reason?
 
Yeah that’s a furphy for sure.

We’re still equal with Parramatta and have been at least semi-competitive in ten of our sixteen games by my count.

I’d hate to think were we could be if a few young guys hadn’t played pretty well this year.
Yes, some of our highly paid veterans are just not performing. It seems to have been the case with most of the clubs high profile signings for a decade or more now. Even the players Cleary brought to the club failed to fire......whilst taking hefty pay cheques.

There was a period of time when that was the case at the Roosters, they got the nickname of "The Transit Lounge" for a while there. It seems Wests Tigers have taken that title from them.
 
I concurr. Stef will kill it under strong leadership.
Strong "leadership" is the key word.
Stef does not have "Strong Leadership".
Needs to be in the background not having the responsibility to "Lead".
The focus to be on others; and let Stef play at his supplementary level, a clear head.
Not cluttered with the responsibility of others who may not be performing up to scratch?
 
It’s annoying that we took him in as a youngster and help develop him. Payed him overs for the faith of him sticking it out. Even though he wasn’t playing to a consistent high level often enough. Then he wants to sod off, Wayne ker!
I used to feel the same way a while back. Yes he has been poor this year but for the last couple of years he's obviously cracked NSW starting side and reserves a couple of times so must not have been that poor.

If this was a one off case, I would understand this feeling of yours but after having cycled through so many people who have wanted to leave after performing well here, it's the constant inability to support our most elite players which seems to push them off the edge.

In any career, you want to see growth in the way that you want to grow. It's simple that Stefano isn't ready for a leadership role and wants to improve more as a front rower than as a leader. Let's be honest, it's probably tougher physically at Melbourne or Roosters etc but mentally/ emotionally, it seems to be tougher here.

Not everyone is cut out for leadership and those who turn their backs on us may have good careers in other teams but rarely (e.g. Tedesco) do they turn out to be good leaders (Matterson, Moses, Aloiai, Woods etc)
 
I used to feel the same way a while back. Yes he has been poor this year but for the last couple of years he's obviously cracked NSW starting side and reserves a couple of times so must not have been that poor.

If this was a one off case, I would understand this feeling of yours but after having cycled through so many people who have wanted to leave after performing well here, it's the constant inability to support our most elite players which seems to push them off the edge.

In any career, you want to see growth in the way that you want to grow. It's simple that Stefano isn't ready for a leadership role and wants to improve more as a front rower than as a leader. Let's be honest, it's probably tougher physically at Melbourne or Roosters etc but mentally/ emotionally, it seems to be tougher here.

Not everyone is cut out for leadership and those who turn their backs on us may have good careers in other teams but rarely (e.g. Tedesco) do they turn out to be good leaders (Matterson, Moses, Aloiai, Woods etc)
The reason player want out is very simple we are not winning and playing in any finals games , with that comes the coach sackings , Poor recruitment , and just the media talking point or should I say bashing point , the club performs badly , looks bad , and has bad results , nothing changes until we learn to win and get up in the 8 , Richo needs to add 3 to 4 more quality players as our young guys are a couple years off and if we rush them we probably break them
 
The reason player want out is very simple we are not winning and playing in any finals games , with that comes the coach sackings , Poor recruitment , and just the media talking point or should I say bashing point , the club performs badly , looks bad , and has bad results , nothing changes until we learn to win and get up in the 8 , Richo needs to add 3 to 4 more quality players as our young guys are a couple years off and if we rush them we probably break them
Yeh.. and for someone like Stefano who was a gun throughout Juniors, I'm sure he would be frustrated looking at the players he dominated growing up playing Finals whereas he is winning Spoons.

It took some very special players like Haas, Carrigan, Capewell and Reyno etc who are all extremely good leaders for Broncos to get out of the cellar. Other teams like Knights, it took a generational talent like Ponga and leaders like Frizzell and an unwavering fan support of a single town team. For Bulldogs, I am putting it solely down to Gus to kickstart it and then it was Stephen Crichton, Mahoney and Ciraldo who have gotten them out of the bottom.

We can only hope Luai, Api and Richo do the same for us, but I am not holding my breath.
 
The reason player want out is very simple we are not winning and playing in any finals games , with that comes the coach sackings , Poor recruitment , and just the media talking point or should I say bashing point , the club performs badly , looks bad , and has bad results , nothing changes until we learn to win and get up in the 8 , Richo needs to add 3 to 4 more quality players as our young guys are a couple years off and if we rush them we probably break them
Our very young first grade players are actually serving an apprenticeship but like most apprenticeships it takes a substantial amount of time to become fully fledged tradesmen ( ie First grade [players). Does the club persist with them or replace them with seasoned first graders?
 
Our very young first grade players are actually serving an apprenticeship but like most apprenticeships it takes a substantial amount of time to become fully fledged tradesmen ( ie First grade [players). Does the club persist with them or replace them with seasoned first graders?

In the real world, You're not allowed to have more than one Apprentice for every 2 Qualified Tradesman - We seem to be the other way around...
We keep forgetting the bit where the Apprentices need proven tradesman to teach them the game....
And we also forget they should be on Apprenticeship wages....
 
I don’t think you’ve read that many of my recent posts but thanks for the feedback.

No doubt it’s turning into something like EPL with a big six clubs. A draft for elite U21’s would be my preferred fix.
Only problem with that is nobody would invests in juniors. I also like in the NFL that apparently they put all the gate takings from all clubs in a year and divide it equally amongst all the teams. This stops the unfairness from your Bronco like teams!
 
Back
Top