Tallyn Da Silva #270

[mtd#2]

If he goes to Manly puts him in competition with Ashton Large

It also competes in the sense that he goes from one basket case club to another 😅😅

 

[Tim Sheens]

I wonder if Benji chose to keep Da Silva on the bench this week, or did he get a push from Richo ?

Surely Benji and the rest of the coaching staff are smart enough between them to have eventually worked out that he has long been wrong on his use of Api and are finally remedying the situation.

If Richardson needed to push him on this, out the door is where he would need to push him.

 

[hugh1954]

Love Sukka long term, give him a permanent bench spot and he will turn into our Jacob Preston also would love to see Da Silva given decent $$$ and have Api tutor him for a couple of season from the bench when Api needs shorter Minutes as he ages

 

[Stevec]

According to NRL 360
Wests Tigers are going to release TDS in the next 7 days
Disgraceful ! TDS is a potential super talent
In 2 years Api will be retiring and TDS will be at his prime
Surely there must be a way to keep him
I of course want to keep Api but surely TDS can play somewhere else other than as No 9 !
I'm fed up with losing Talent
Wests Tigers the " Repco " spare parts supplier to the rest of the league

I want to see INCOMING not OUTGOING
Here's an Idea Selwyn Cobbo is on the outer at Broncos as he just doesn't get along with Madge ! Maybe he might gel with Benji
Need Richo to be proactive

 

[Needaname]

Try the common dominator Uncle Ronald M strikes again

Previous promises.

 

[Needaname]

You are right in saying he is not going to be an 80min per game NRL number 9 at any club just yet.
I’m guessing his bigger concern is the fact Benji seems to think Api can continue to play 80mins each game.

He can.

 

[Needaname]

Love Sukka long term, give him a permanent bench spot and he will turn into our Jacob Preston also would love to see Da Silva given decent $$$ and have Api tutor him for a couple of season from the bench when Api needs shorter Minutes as he ages

Does Sukkar dominate the NSW cup? That’s where Preston was at prior to being signed by Canterbury from the Bears.

 

[Tim Sheens]

He can.

Sure, he can, the trouble is we win two and a half times more often when Api doesn’t play 80, so why would you choose to do it?

 

[mtd#2]

I remain hopeful it could be a loan deal for Tallyn as opposed to moving on...

 

[tigahhh]

I remain hopeful it could be a loan deal for Tallyn as opposed to moving on...

you and me both!

 

[Aceshigh]

I remain hopeful it could be a loan deal for Tallyn as opposed to moving on...

That would be best case 👍

 

[Telltails]

So over the off field stuff with this club, as if the onfield stuff is hard enough to deal with.
Is there another club that releases more players to strengthen other clubs, than us mid season for nothing in return??

 

[tigahhh]

So over the off field stuff with this club, as if the onfield stuff is hard enough to deal with.
Is there another club that releases more players to strengthen other clubs, than us mid season for nothing in return??

exactly
idk how we can expect consistency in our team when the noise off field is so loud

 

[mtd#2]

So over the off field stuff with this club, as if the onfield stuff is hard enough to deal with.
Is there another club that releases more players to strengthen other clubs, than us mid season for nothing in return??

If he went to the cowboys for a loan or swap I'd take Jason Taumololo off their hands for front row rotation depth

 

[Merlot]

I would back TDS in over Api ,for the long haul . A good back up to Api if /when Tallyn goes is Billy Walters - if the coin is right

 

[Tucker]

who ? Ciraldo used the excuse he wasn’t ready yet then took the dogs job a couple months after

benji’s done the best recruitment out of any coach, the talent we’ve been able to secure considering the basket case we’ve been for years was outstanding , no other coach has been able to do it . he has pull with players and you can see they play for him . There’s life there after watching plodders for years .

So he’s performed the best recruitment drive of any coach, yet is still struggling to avoid his 3rd straight spoon?
What does that tell you?

 

[Tiger_Yoshi]

So he’s performed the best recruitment drive of any coach, yet is still struggling to avoid his 3rd straight spoon?
What does that tell you?

He can’t coach?

 

[Tucker]

People can love and adore Benji, all good, I support that.

But the results suggest he simply can’t coach at this level, doing what he’s doing.

He can do plenty of other good and helpful things for the club.

He is clearly in the wrong job.
Head of football with a mandate to control recruitment is his wheelhouse

 

[Chunk]

He is clearly in the wrong job.
Head of football with a mandate to control recruitment is his wheelhouse

Does that include keeping juniors because that isn't going too well for him lately.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

I remain hopeful it could be a loan deal for Tallyn as opposed to moving on...

So these dribblers Hooper & Riccio on 360 think we’ll just release TDS by June 30.

Why would we? He’s under contract for another season and we don’t have another adequate backup if Api goes down.

It just won’t happen unless we get something significant in return.