Tim Simona

Absolute brain dead. Going himself from dummy half and losing it. Kicking for JAC on the first. He had the right idea there, but geezus the season is on the line for sciences sake.
 
Apart from kicking it on the first (even then he could have been taken into touch, so not necessarily that bad a decision) I thought he had a good game.
That tackle to force the repeat set was massive.
 
He is a gun. He made a couple of mistakes and needs to be told not to go for the big play all the time but he is quality.

If we could retain JAC we'd have threats on both sides of the field.
 
@stevetiger said:
He is a gun. He made a couple of mistakes and needs to be told not to go for the big play all the time but he is quality.

If we could retain JAC we'd have threats on both sides of the field.
Click to expand...

Yup agree 100%
 
He kicks in-field far too often following a line break. Needs to learn to just take the tackle sometimes instead of go for the miracle play.

Looked dangerous today but he definitely made some dumb plays. Going for the try from dummy-half was the worst one.
 
By no means do i think he should be dropped. But im so sick of him kicking every time he is in the clear. Any player with half a brain realises its first tackle and you cut back in to take the tackle. Simple. His play from dummy half was disgraceful too. He needs a wake call.
 
The Myth is going to be eaten alive next week by a big and strong centre . Just makes up the numbers IMO.
 
Dumb kick and poor attempt from dummy half, but I thought he was good otherwise. Our best defensive outside back & did plenty of dirty work today.
 
He is a great player. The myth as snake states hasn't been beaten in a long time.

The play from dummy half though was Robbie like at his worst. Disgraceful. The kick on the 1st was also beyond stupid.

Great player but he needs a kick up the backside.
 
He is a very good player, especially defensively. You do not see many teams milking his side. In saying that he makes so many low percentage plays from long range breaks. Never seems to ever want to take the tackle, always goes the hail Mary option. You don't want to players scared to go for something when they think it is on, but you also have to know when to play the safe option and on tackle one a kick was never on
 
He was too inpatient, that kick was hail Mary, it would be brilliant if we scored, but he should have taken an easy option, and take the tackle.
He was very good in defence.
JAC is in a way similar to Naiqama, they shall play only in attack, and be replaced by defensive players when we defend (like in NFL).
 
Does some good things, with some stupidity thrown in for good measure.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 3,451 (members: 38, guests: 3,413)
Back
Top