Time to give Sironen another run

[Goose]

Should not have been dropped in the first place.
I reckon a bit of spite was involved in his axing.

 

[sideline_eye]

I think he was dropped to make way for ET wasn't he? He must have been on fairly thin ice at the time but seems to be using his time in ISP well and now looks to be the next backrower of the the rank.

 

[strrretch]

surely he is a good bench option

 

[Carefactor]

Still doesnt put his size and body on the line in my opinion .

 

[magpiecol]

Should not have been dropped in the first place.
I reckon a bit of spite was involved in his axing.

Rubbish!!!

:roll

 

[Doc_Tiger]

Did he ever have a standout game in firsts?

 

[gallagher]

Did he ever have a standout game in firsts?

I was really impressed with him very early. But that was probably under sheens it seems so long ago. It's sounds like he's working hard on his game so maybe another run in firsts may give him a boost to kick on.

 

[Chevy]

He would of haved to improve to deserve a call up,he had four season to settle into fg which is rediculous and still couldn't deliver the goods.

 

[gallagher]

He would of haved to improve to deserve a call up,he had four season to settle into fg which is rediculous and still couldn't deliver the goods.

Yeah, he seemed to be in the comfort zone. He needed a kick.

 

[bp_tiger]

he is now playing to his standard, NSW CUP. the bloke just does not have it, sorry.

 

[pHyR3]

Did he ever have a standout game in firsts?

I was really impressed with him very early. But that was probably under sheens it seems so long ago. It's sounds like he's working hard on his game so maybe another run in firsts may give him a boost to kick on.

so when he was in the halves??

at best it looked like he had good potential for the 2nd rower, but once he started being required to make 10+ runs a game at proper forwards and 25+ tackles his impact dropped very quickly

 

[TopTiger]

Hasn't lived up to the hype, not too late for him to lift his game but needs to do this in Reggies first!

 

[gallagher]

Did he ever have a standout game in firsts?

I was really impressed with him very early. But that was probably under sheens it seems so long ago. It's sounds like he's working hard on his game so maybe another run in firsts may give him a boost to kick on.

so when he was in the halves??

at best it looked like he had good potential for the 2nd rower, but once he started being required to make 10+ runs a game at proper forwards and 25+ tackles his impact dropped very quickly

Yeah, that's true. Disappointing.

 

[GoldXR50Leroy]

Has he been any good since being sprung playing away from home?

 

[Patts]

I agree he needed to be dropped and it doesn't sound like he's smashing the door down to be reinstated BUT the question is he a better option than Lovett? Because Lovett isn't up to first grade standard either (yet).

BTW I notice JJ Felise is coming off the bench in the reggies this weekend! Has he been injured because it was only a month ago he had a great game against the Broncos in first grade. Why the demotion??

 

[Tigerdon]

I agree he needed to be dropped and it doesn't sound like he's smashing the door down to be reinstated BUT the question is he a better option than Lovett? Because Lovett isn't up to first grade standard either (yet).

BTW I notice JJ Felise is coming off the bench in the reggies this weekend! Has he been injured because it was only a month ago he had a great game against the Broncos in first grade. Why he demotion??

Siro's ball skills are better. He wouldn't have bombed that try last week. Lovett is more of a worker. Neither are killing it.
It was always said JJ Felise would be nursed the year because of his young age. Even if he was going good he'd have time off.

 

[Nors05]

Apart from Halutau (and obviously Farah) Sironen is our best option as bench utility. If Halutau needs a breather, put him on at 9\. If Halutau can go 80, no worries, put Sironen at back row/lock

 

[gallagher]

Maybe lovetts attitude is the difference between him and Siro. Neither are world beaters.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I agree he needed to be dropped and it doesn't sound like he's smashing the door down to be reinstated BUT the question is he a better option than Lovett? Because Lovett isn't up to first grade standard either (yet).

The difference between Lovett and Siro is that Lovett has a go. He's all heart. Siro showed glimpses but played as though first grade was his birth rite the majority of games he played. Hopefully when gets his chance again he doesn't take it for granted and plays like he has to earn it.

 

[Club_Sandwich]

he is now playing to his standard, NSW CUP. the bloke just does not have it, sorry.

X2\. Bench utility at BEST