Top 5 WT of all time

[Gary_Bakerloo]

1\. Scott Prince
2\. John Skandalis
3\. Gareth Ellis
4\. Benji Marshall
5\. Brett Hodgson

 

[cktiger]

1\. Benji
2\. Farah
3\. Hodgson
4\. Ellis
5\. Prince

That's it for mine - don't know how anyone can leave Farah out.

 

[happy_tiger]

Hodgson
Marshall
Ellis
Farah
ONeill

 

[Spartan117]

For mine

1\. Benji Marshall
2\. Robbie Farah
3\. Gareth Ellis
4\. Brett Hodgson
5\. Mark ONeill / Skando

 

[bonstonker]

Hodgson
Marshall
Ellis
Farah
ONeill

i think the top 4 in any order doesn't bother me.

it's the 5th one that has me stumped.
i can't give it to prince because he really only had 1 good year with us.
he wasn't great in 04 or 06.

i think of a skando or buckets but think lawrence will soon pass them by.
was so happy that players like skando and buckets got to win a premiership.
easy to get up and put in when the side is doing well,but when on a poor team year after year,it really has to count for something when judging players contributions to a club.

 

[system]

Hodgo
Benji
Farah
Heighno
Ellis

 

[Joel Helmes]

Pretty easy for me -

Benji
Farah
Hodgson
O'Neill
Skandalis

 

[Juro]

1\. Hodgson
6\. Marshall
9\. Farah
10\. Skandalis
12\. Ellis

 

[tiger_rocket]

1\. Scott Prince
2\. John Skandalis
3\. Gareth Ellis
4\. Benji Marshall
5\. Brett Hodgson

I would change Farah in for Skando. Otherwise that's it.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Hbom]

1\. Benji
2\. Ellis
3\. Farah
4\. Hodgson
5\. Skandalis

Very hard leaving Ben Galea and Todd Payten out.

 

[Guest]

1\. Benji Marshall
2\. Robbie Farah
3\. Brett Hodgson
4\. Gareth Ellis
5\. Chris Heighington

Notable mentions to Taniela Tuiaki and Chris Lawrence.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

In no order

taniela tuaki
john skandalis
terry hill
benji marshall
robbie farah

 

[genoshan]

In order -

1\. Benji
2\. Hodgo
3\. Skando
4\. Ellis
5\. Farah

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Farah has to be rated ahead of Marshall imo. While Benji is a game breaker, theres no denying Farah has been the more consistant player since 03\. Hence Robbie twice coming within 1 point of a Dally M

1\. Farah
2\. Marshall
3\. Ellis
4\. Hodgo
5\. Prince

 

[underdog]

first four are easy - in no partcular order - Hodgo, Marshall, Farah and Ellis.

5th one?

I'm going with a bloke who never really gets tigers recognition, but tried his guts out in our awful side from 2000-2004, and never ever gave up on the footy field.

number 5 would be Darren Center.

Honourable Mentions:

Tuiaki
Heigno
GIbbs
Skando
O'Hara (lol jokes)

 

[tigermaniac]

Update on WT top 5

Marshall -127
Farah - 90
Ellis - 74
Hodgson - 72
Prince - 23.5
Skandalis - 20.5
Galea - 6.5
O'Neill - 4.5
Heighington - 4
Tuiaki - 3
Hill - 3
Gibbs - 2
Tuqiri - 1
Ryan - 1
Senter - 1
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[LaT]

1\. Hodgeson
2\. Skando
3\. Farah
4\. Fulton
5\. Ellis

So many players miss out though, plenty of contenders.

 

[Properossi]

Pretty easy for me -

Benji
Farah
Hodgson
O'Neill
Skandalis

SPOT ON!

 

[tiger_sean]

1\. Hodgeson
2\. Skando
3\. Farah
4\. Fulton
5\. Ellis

So many players miss out though, plenty of contenders.

No Benji?

Mine is
1\. Benji
2\. Robbie
3\. Hodgson
4\. Ellis
5\. Skando

 

[LaT]

1\. Hodgeson
2\. Skando
3\. Farah
4\. Fulton
5\. Ellis

So many players miss out though, plenty of contenders.

No Benji?

Mine is
1\. Benji
2\. Robbie
3\. Hodgson
4\. Ellis
5\. Skando

Close, but I chose heart over skill. Benji has plenty of heart too, and he loves the club….but those 5 players just represent what I love about the club the most.