Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan
Well-known member
Too soon to make a call on Tuki. He was brought in 2 years before he was ready, both in terms of skill and physicality. Seyfarth was another one who didn't look good enough, but that was only because he lacked size and strength. Now he looks the goods.
The period we're in now reminds me of Newcastle in 2016/17, although we're not that bad. They blooded kids way before they were ready. Those guys got smashed every week. But they got to learn how bad it could get, and that there is light on the other side. Saifiti bros were shadows of the players they are now.
Hell, even Payne Haas, probably the #2 front rower at the moment (after James Fisher-Harris), got monstered in his first season in the NRL (played 3 games, 15-20 minutes each off the bench, then got injured). Klemmer smashed him badly. The next season he came out and had one of the great rookie seasons. Probably the second best after Tim Smith in 2005.
Anyway, my point is that young players 21 years or younger can often look terrible when they are starting their first grade careers. It's no indicator of what type of player they'll be. Who would have thought that Tim Smith in 2005 would be a blip in rugby league history, while Cooper Cronk would go on to be one of the greatest players of all time. No one could have seen that coming.
The period we're in now reminds me of Newcastle in 2016/17, although we're not that bad. They blooded kids way before they were ready. Those guys got smashed every week. But they got to learn how bad it could get, and that there is light on the other side. Saifiti bros were shadows of the players they are now.
Hell, even Payne Haas, probably the #2 front rower at the moment (after James Fisher-Harris), got monstered in his first season in the NRL (played 3 games, 15-20 minutes each off the bench, then got injured). Klemmer smashed him badly. The next season he came out and had one of the great rookie seasons. Probably the second best after Tim Smith in 2005.
Anyway, my point is that young players 21 years or younger can often look terrible when they are starting their first grade careers. It's no indicator of what type of player they'll be. Who would have thought that Tim Smith in 2005 would be a blip in rugby league history, while Cooper Cronk would go on to be one of the greatest players of all time. No one could have seen that coming.