Wests Tigers Team v Gold Coast

[Guest]

Can't win an NRL game with Mbye in the centres.

Have we ever won with him in the centres?


I'd rather see Packer play there.


We only won 7 games last year, 5 of those (Rds 3, 6, 7, 10, 14) Mbye was in the centres, he scored tries in three of those five.........but otherwise a pretty convincing point of view.

Pretty primary school way to judge a performance......He scored a try.

I gamble for a living and have an extensive data base.
His ratings in all those games in all facets of the game were inadequate for an NRL player.

His maximum possible performance this weekend based on all his games over the past 2 seasons is a 5/10.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Can't win an NRL game with Mbye in the centres.

Have we ever won with him in the centres?


I'd rather see Packer play there.


We only won 7 games last year, 5 of those (Rds 3, 6, 7, 10, 14) Mbye was in the centres, he scored tries in three of those five.........but otherwise a pretty convincing point of view.

I can’t believe you got downvoted for this.

 

[Tiger5150]

Oh well. Another Tommy commemoration game down the toilet,

Gold Coast will target the weak link known as Mbye.

Game over before it starts.

Mbye is a good defender mate . If anything we just got better defensively , and sacrifice our attack. Put him next to Cini , and AD , and that’s a stronger defensive structure there .

Brooks covering for Joey with Garner on the inside , and Luci next to AD , Mbye covering for Cini.
I actually like it .
If it works , it might be hard for Roberts and and TalU to get a run in a few weeks

I see that posted here often.

Unfortunately for the team it isn't true.

He was consistently one of the worst defenders all last year. ***Statistically*** he was a horror show. His "good defence" is a forum myth.

Im not sure that you fully grasp the meaning of the word statistically.


https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/wests-tigers/moses-mbye/

 

[hodgo]

what i struggle with is the knock on seyfarth. That dude has a motor and is in everything. He is always back chasing he is always in the play. Yes i agree there are better ball runners but i doubt any other forward he has does the distance and 1% he does.

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Oh well. Another Tommy commemoration game down the toilet,

Gold Coast will target the weak link known as Mbye.

Game over before it starts.

Mbye is a good defender mate . If anything we just got better defensively , and sacrifice our attack. Put him next to Cini , and AD , and that’s a stronger defensive structure there .

Brooks covering for Joey with Garner on the inside , and Luci next to AD , Mbye covering for Cini.
I actually like it .
If it works , it might be hard for Roberts and and TalU to get a run in a few weeks

I see that posted here often.

Unfortunately for the team it isn't true.

He was consistently one of the worst defenders all last year. Statistically he was a horror show. His "good defence" is a forum myth.

Gold Coast will run around him, through him and over him.

Mbye was one of our best backline defenders last year.

Sorry, but saying that doesn't make it true.
If only it did for the team's sake.
They'll need a traffic cop to control the flow of players exploiting his weaknesses.

I can only pray that it's a clever ruse by Madge to mess with their heads before he's benched when the final team is named.

Defensively he’s far better than Talau, Leilua and Nofo.

Mbye goes alright .. Nofo is the worst of that list .

Nofo is one of the worst defenders I’ve ever seen.

He is the modern day Brooks, no confidence and no faith in his players inside or outside.

Noffo will be a better overall player if he trusts the systems and players around him.

 

[Guest]

Oh well. Another Tommy commemoration game down the toilet,

Gold Coast will target the weak link known as Mbye.

Game over before it starts.

Mbye is a good defender mate . If anything we just got better defensively , and sacrifice our attack. Put him next to Cini , and AD , and that’s a stronger defensive structure there .

Brooks covering for Joey with Garner on the inside , and Luci next to AD , Mbye covering for Cini.
I actually like it .
If it works , it might be hard for Roberts and and TalU to get a run in a few weeks

I see that posted here often.

Unfortunately for the team it isn't true.

He was consistently one of the worst defenders all last year. ***Statistically*** he was a horror show. His "good defence" is a forum myth.
Im not sure that you fully grasp the meaning of the word statistically.


https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/wests-tigers/moses-mbye/

Yep. Wrong year. That's a simplistic tally of THIS year.

Comprehension should still be taught in schools.

 

[Tiger5150]

Can't win an NRL game with Mbye in the centres.

Have we ever won with him in the centres?


I'd rather see Packer play there.


We only won 7 games last year, 5 of those (Rds 3, 6, 7, 10, 14) Mbye was in the centres, he scored tries in three of those five.........but otherwise a pretty convincing point of view.

Pretty primary school way to judge a performance......He scored a try.

Pretty primary school way to avoid the point.....you said we ***cant*** win with Mbye in the centres and then asked if we have ever won with him in the centres. Now you know that the vast majority of our wins were with him in the centres. You are welcome.

I gamble for a living and have an extensive data base.

This is ***actually***, ***genuinely*** hilarious! You have an extensive data base, but somehow forgot that not only could we win with Mbye, but the majority of our wins last year were with him at centre.

Playing fantasy isnt "gambling for a living". I hope you dont have children depending on your "extensive database".


 

[Guest]

Can't win an NRL game with Mbye in the centres.

Have we ever won with him in the centres?


I'd rather see Packer play there.


We only won 7 games last year, 5 of those (Rds 3, 6, 7, 10, 14) Mbye was in the centres, he scored tries in three of those five.........but otherwise a pretty convincing point of view.

Pretty primary school way to judge a performance......He scored a try.

Pretty primary school way to avoid the point.....you said we ***cant*** win with Mbye in the centres and then asked if we have ever won with him in the centres. Now you know that the vast majority of our wins were with him in the centres. You are welcome.

I gamble for a living and have an extensive data base.

This is ***actually***, ***genuinely*** hilarious! You have an extensive data base, but somehow forgot that not only could we win with Mbye, but the majority of our wins last year were with him at centre.

Playing fantasy isnt "gambling for a living". I hope you dont have children depending on your "extensive database".


Yeah. Believe what you want.

In the middle of a Hawkesbury meeting when the team dropped.

Priorities.......leads to winning

 

[NZTiger]

Please please please, for the love of god, back up a win...WITH A WIN

 

[Roar_Power]

Oh well. Another Tommy commemoration game down the toilet,

Gold Coast will target the weak link known as Mbye.

Game over before it starts.

Mbye is a good defender mate . If anything we just got better defensively , and sacrifice our attack. Put him next to Cini , and AD , and that’s a stronger defensive structure there .

Brooks covering for Joey with Garner on the inside , and Luci next to AD , Mbye covering for Cini.
I actually like it .
If it works , it might be hard for Roberts and and TalU to get a run in a few weeks

I see that posted here often.

Unfortunately for the team it isn't true.

He was consistently one of the worst defenders all last year. Statistically he was a horror show. His "good defence" is a forum myth.

Gold Coast will run around him, through him and over him.

Mbye was one of our best backline defenders last year.

Sorry, but saying that doesn't make it true.
If only it did for the team's sake.
They'll need a traffic cop to control the flow of players exploiting his weaknesses.

I can only pray that it's a clever ruse by Madge to mess with their heads before he's benched when the final team is named.

Defensively he’s far better than Talau, Leilua and Nofo.

Mbye goes alright .. Nofo is the worst of that list .

Nofo is one of the worst defenders I’ve ever seen.

He is the modern day Brooks, no confidence and no faith in his players inside or outside.

Noffo will be a better overall player if he trusts the systems and players around him.

Wouldn't have too many players on his outside, being on the wing 🙂

Probably one for the Dad's Jokes thread...

 

[Tiger5150]

Oh well. Another Tommy commemoration game down the toilet,

Gold Coast will target the weak link known as Mbye.

Game over before it starts.

Mbye is a good defender mate . If anything we just got better defensively , and sacrifice our attack. Put him next to Cini , and AD , and that’s a stronger defensive structure there .

Brooks covering for Joey with Garner on the inside , and Luci next to AD , Mbye covering for Cini.
I actually like it .
If it works , it might be hard for Roberts and and TalU to get a run in a few weeks

I see that posted here often.

Unfortunately for the team it isn't true.

He was consistently one of the worst defenders all last year. ***Statistically*** he was a horror show. His "good defence" is a forum myth.
Im not sure that you fully grasp the meaning of the word statistically.


https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/wests-tigers/moses-mbye/

Yep. Wrong year. That's a simplistic tally of THIS year.

Comprehension should still be taught in schools.

Last year was 83% What was your point again? Statistically he is a poor defender?

 

[Tiger5150]

Can't win an NRL game with Mbye in the centres.

Have we ever won with him in the centres?


I'd rather see Packer play there.


We only won 7 games last year, 5 of those (Rds 3, 6, 7, 10, 14) Mbye was in the centres, he scored tries in three of those five.........but otherwise a pretty convincing point of view.

Pretty primary school way to judge a performance......He scored a try.

Pretty primary school way to avoid the point.....you said we ***cant*** win with Mbye in the centres and then asked if we have ever won with him in the centres. Now you know that the vast majority of our wins were with him in the centres. You are welcome.

I gamble for a living and have an extensive data base.

This is ***actually***, ***genuinely*** hilarious! You have an extensive data base, but somehow forgot that not only could we win with Mbye, but the majority of our wins last year were with him at centre.

Playing fantasy isnt "gambling for a living". I hope you dont have children depending on your "extensive database".


Yeah. Believe what you want.

In the middle of a Hawkesbury meeting when the team dropped.

Priorities.......leads to winning

Oh man! Hawkesbury?!?!?

I take it all back.....not only are you legit, you are BIG TIME!!!!!

Remind me again, does your extensive database say if we have every won a game with Mbye in the centres?

 

[BAGNF05]

Well done Madge I think this is the best team going forward maybe with Blore to come in.

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Oh well. Another Tommy commemoration game down the toilet,

Gold Coast will target the weak link known as Mbye.

Game over before it starts.

Mbye is a good defender mate . If anything we just got better defensively , and sacrifice our attack. Put him next to Cini , and AD , and that’s a stronger defensive structure there .

Brooks covering for Joey with Garner on the inside , and Luci next to AD , Mbye covering for Cini.
I actually like it .
If it works , it might be hard for Roberts and and TalU to get a run in a few weeks

I see that posted here often.

Unfortunately for the team it isn't true.

He was consistently one of the worst defenders all last year. Statistically he was a horror show. His "good defence" is a forum myth.

Gold Coast will run around him, through him and over him.

Mbye was one of our best backline defenders last year.

Sorry, but saying that doesn't make it true.
If only it did for the team's sake.
They'll need a traffic cop to control the flow of players exploiting his weaknesses.

I can only pray that it's a clever ruse by Madge to mess with their heads before he's benched when the final team is named.

Defensively he’s far better than Talau, Leilua and Nofo.

Mbye goes alright .. Nofo is the worst of that list .

Nofo is one of the worst defenders I’ve ever seen.

He is the modern day Brooks, no confidence and no faith in his players inside or outside.

Noffo will be a better overall player if he trusts the systems and players around him.

Wouldn't have too many players on his outside, being on the wing 🙂

Probably one for the Dad's Jokes thread...

? good one.

There a loop hole in this discussion, he does come in field with his carries ?

 

[TigerWest]

Well done Madge I think this is the best team going forward maybe with Blore to come in.

Yes, we now have the luxury of some good depth in the team, just another back or 2 to go imo.

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Well done Madge I think this is the best team going forward maybe with Blore to come in.

Certainly a better pick than some of his other selections.

 

[yeahcaz]

If we’re struggling to attack at times, I’d like to see Simpkin and Liddle on the field at the same time. Also think having 2 ball running 9s keeps us unpredictable.

 

[Tiger5150]

Can't win an NRL game with Mbye in the centres.

Have we ever won with him in the centres?


I'd rather see Packer play there.


We only won 7 games last year, 5 of those (Rds 3, 6, 7, 10, 14) Mbye was in the centres, he scored tries in three of those five.........but otherwise a pretty convincing point of view.

I can’t believe you got downvoted for this.

Dwight doesnt like being proved wrong

 

[iofthetigers]

Oh well. Another Tommy commemoration game down the toilet,

Gold Coast will target the weak link known as Mbye.

Game over before it starts.

He is a better defender than Roberts, the better he plays the less we pay(when he finds someone to take him

 

[BAGNF05]

Well done Madge I think this is the best team going forward maybe with Blore to come in.

Yes, we now have the luxury of some good depth in the team, just another back or 2 to go imo.

One world class back and one edge back rower who makes all his tackles and scares thebeguzus out of people.