Wests Tigers Team v Newcastle Rd 13

[Elderslie_Tiger]

Good side on paper BUT I don't think the 1 to 17 will be the side that takes the field I think Madge might be using the smoke and mirrors approach this weekend around the 1,9 and the bench

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

I reckon Grub could be a smokey for Walters as well.

 

[hsvjones]

I think we owe Rowdy this weeks game as he has been excellent in the centres the last month for our defence. Plus its his 250th and you know he wont let you down.

 

[Madge]

Good side on paper BUT I don't think the 1 to 17 will be the side that takes the field I think Madge might be using the smoke and mirrors approach this weekend around the 1,9 and the bench

I was thinking that - If Doueihi is ruled out then Mbye to 1, Walters to 9 and Reynolds on to the bench it would seem.

 

[Magpie1969]

I like the side considering injuries. Garner has been poor.

 

[Rowdy12]

Garners miss on Hiku for his first try last week was embarrassing

Scoring 2 tries against a QLD Cup Standard line up a couple of weeks ago just hid how bad he has been going

 

[avocadoontoast]

Hopefully Garner in the starting line up, McIntyre back to bench in place of Rowdy.

He hasnt been playing well at all tbh and I am glad he has been dropped this week.

He's been out of form but he is a bit of a threat in attack. I prefer McIntyre in the middle.

 

[Elderslie_Tiger]

Good side on paper BUT I don't think the 1 to 17 will be the side that takes the field I think Madge might be using the smoke and mirrors approach this weekend around the 1,9 and the bench

I was thinking that - If Doueihi is ruled out then Mbye to 1, Walters to 9 and Reynolds on to the bench it would seem.

Great minds think alike

 

[Madge]

Hopefully Garner in the starting line up, McIntyre back to bench in place of Rowdy.

He hasnt been playing well at all tbh and I am glad he has been dropped this week.

He's been out of form but he is a bit of a threat in attack. I prefer McIntyre in the middle.

Cant disagree with both your points just feel like we need to get the foundation right first with defence and McIntyre and Lawrence have proved they can.

 

[TheDaBoss]

Is Grant Injured ?

Twal?

I'm lost... where is harry ....

happy told Madge if he doesn't rest him this week he's done..

Career gone

 

[Geo]

Not upset that Twal is out in favour of Eisenhuth. Twal looked short of a gallop and I think that Eisenhuth has been more than capable until Twal is 100% right to go.

Garner on notice it would seem.

Only problem is the only way to get a gallop is play First Grade..no reggies to get match conditioning and the training paddock is not the same..

 

[TheDaBoss]

I prefer Walters at DH over Reynolds imo

 

[Elderslie_Tiger]

Not upset that Twal is out in favour of Eisenhuth. Twal looked short of a gallop and I think that Eisenhuth has been more than capable until Twal is 100% right to go.

Garner on notice it would seem.

Only problem is the only way to get a gallop is play First Grade..no reggies to get match conditioning and the training paddock is not the same..

Twal ruled out by injury

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Not upset that Twal is out in favour of Eisenhuth. Twal looked short of a gallop and I think that Eisenhuth has been more than capable until Twal is 100% right to go.

Garner on notice it would seem.

Only problem is the only way to get a gallop is play First Grade..no reggies to get match conditioning and the training paddock is not the same..

This is true. I guess the point I am making is that it's not totally unfortunate that Twal is out as Eisenhuth has been playing very well.

 

[Newtown]

Good side on paper BUT I don't think the 1 to 17 will be the side that takes the field I think Madge might be using the smoke and mirrors approach this weekend around the 1,9 and the bench

I was thinking that - If Doueihi is ruled out then Mbye to 1, Walters to 9 and Reynolds on to the bench it would seem.

I hope that Doehi doesn't play injured again.

 

[Geo]

Not upset that Twal is out in favour of Eisenhuth. Twal looked short of a gallop and I think that Eisenhuth has been more than capable until Twal is 100% right to go.

Garner on notice it would seem.

Only problem is the only way to get a gallop is play First Grade..no reggies to get match conditioning and the training paddock is not the same..

Twal ruled out by injury

Yes the discussion was about the previous week..

 

[hobbo1]

I watch the official West’s Tigers team list “eye of the tiger”
Before opening this thread ...
Got to 9 and 🤮

 

[walter]

Let’s see how we go without Harry grant the kids been the best player by a mile the knights pumped us in the first round worried about talau s defencive reads in the centres the kid on the wing who knows could be good could be rubbish

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Had an odd thought, wonder if Doueihi is scrubbed what the odds are that Mbye will go to fullback, Brooks to hooker and Grub to starting five-eighth?

 

[TYGA]

Mbye had to be dropped. I like what Madge is doing but you can’t put up with poor form from your captain.