Wests Tigers v Manly TRIAL ..*Spoilers

[avocadoontoast]

How can Roberts-Davis play State Cup before NRL and NRL..

Apparently he's very fit.

 

[Guest]

How can Roberts-Davis play State Cup before NRL and NRL..

He's unlocked access to the multiverse...

 

[hobbo1]

Mikaele way down on Madge's list...wonder if that is a prelude for things to come? Will hopefully get down to the old girl to watch this one.

Mikaele comes across as a slacker to me ..bordering on plodderism .

Can be damaging at his best, but struggled to find it last year. Maybe that was partly due to injury but hopefully he can find some form again this year

Jesse Sue 2.0

 

[Tiger_Steve]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

 

[weststigerman]

Weren't there a few people talking up Josh Rizk as a star of the future? I remember people were debating against signing Mansour or James Roberts because they might block his path to first grade.

Why is he only on the bench in the flegg squad?

 

[pawsandclaws1]

(Taken from Western Suburbs Magpies Official Supporters Forum on f/b)

Wests Magpies State Cup Trial Team vs Blacktown Workers Sea Eagles Official
1. Tyronne Roberts-Davis
2. Allan Fitzgibbon
3. William Kei
4. Kiah Cooper
5. Zac Cini
6. Joe Taipiri
7. Tyler Field
8. Ky Rodwell
9. Zach Dockar-Clay
10. Austin Dias
11. Tom Freebairn
12. Regan Hughes
13. Edenn Rogers-Smith
Interchange:
14. Max Altus
15. Kel Obrien
16. Justin Frain
17. Curtis Wilson
18. Israel Ogden
19. Iverson Fatimau
20. Semisi Kioa
21. EJ Lui
22. TJ Mclean
23. Mavoni Tuifua
24. Ali Allouche
25. Kurtis Preece
Coach: Ben Gardiner

Max Altus is a former Farrar Ag High Tamworth student and Aust Schools Hooker. I'll be interested to see how he goes. Tamworth has always been a strong Tiger area.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Weren't there a few people talking up Josh Rizk as a star of the future? I remember people were debating against signing Mansour or James Roberts because they might block his path to first grade.

Why is he only on the bench in the flegg squad?

Josh Rizk is a very good player. It's a trial and depends on what the coach wants to achieve from it. Jordan Hill on one wing is a player to note and Scolari well I've always liked him.

 

[cochise]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

 

[weststigerman]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

 

[Tiger_Steve]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

I think there’s a chance Laurie for 1 and Mbye for 6 round 1.

 

[weststigerman]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

I think there’s a chance Laurie for 1 and Mbye for 6 round 1.

Maybe but I think it would be unlikely given Mbye hasn't trained at 6 at all, and without a trial under his belt. I think it's more likely Mbye at 1 and Laurie at 6, but even that I think is unlikely.

 

[cochise]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

I think there’s a chance Laurie for 1 and Mbye for 6 round 1.

So do I, Laurie and Madden both playing for starting position rd 1

 

[cochise]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

I think there’s a chance Laurie for 1 and Mbye for 6 round 1.

Maybe but I think it would be unlikely given Mbye hasn't trained at 6 at all, and without a trial under his belt. I think it's more likely Mbye at 1 and Laurie at 6, but even that I think is unlikely.

In my opinion Madden needs a much improved game this weekend to get the 6.

 

[Geo]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Packer...

 

[weststigerman]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

I think there’s a chance Laurie for 1 and Mbye for 6 round 1.

Maybe but I think it would be unlikely given Mbye hasn't trained at 6 at all, and without a trial under his belt. I think it's more likely Mbye at 1 and Laurie at 6, but even that I think is unlikely.

In my opinion Madden needs a much improved game this weekend to get the 6.

Who do you think will take it off him if Mbye is injured round 1?

 

[Speed2burn]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

I think there’s a chance Laurie for 1 and Mbye for 6 round 1.

Maybe but I think it would be unlikely given Mbye hasn't trained at 6 at all, and without a trial under his belt. I think it's more likely Mbye at 1 and Laurie at 6, but even that I think is unlikely.

In my opinion Madden needs a much improved game this weekend to get the 6.

Who do you think will take it off him if Mbye is injured round 1?

Get Talau there to tackle his rig out and just play second fiddle to Brooks. Not confident madden can step up just yet but hey he could prove me wrong this Sunday

But anyways I think mbye will be right by the.

 

[cochise]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

I think there’s a chance Laurie for 1 and Mbye for 6 round 1.

Maybe but I think it would be unlikely given Mbye hasn't trained at 6 at all, and without a trial under his belt. I think it's more likely Mbye at 1 and Laurie at 6, but even that I think is unlikely.

In my opinion Madden needs a much improved game this weekend to get the 6.

Who do you think will take it off him if Mbye is injured round 1?

No he isn't?

 

[Cairnstigers]

Well if Fitzgibbon has a blinder for the magpies he may still get a spot in the 30
But he would need to blow off the cobwebs and ready show us what he has got
I would like to see him break a few tackles and run in some long range tries

Is that asking to much

 

[weststigerman]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

I think there’s a chance Laurie for 1 and Mbye for 6 round 1.

Maybe but I think it would be unlikely given Mbye hasn't trained at 6 at all, and without a trial under his belt. I think it's more likely Mbye at 1 and Laurie at 6, but even that I think is unlikely.

In my opinion Madden needs a much improved game this weekend to get the 6.

Who do you think will take it off him if Mbye is injured round 1?

No he isn't?

He’s not playing the trial with a hamstring injury which has one of the more unpredictable recovery timelines. So yes I think there is at least a 50/50 chance he might be unavailable.

 

[cochise]

Didn’t want to start a new thread but who do we think has the most to gain this Sunday?

For me it’s Tuki Simpkins. He could come out of the blue and jag a top 17 spot if he plays as well as he did last week. Huge opportunity I reckon.

Laurie and Madden as well. At least one of them will have a spot in round 1, could be a head to head battle for a position in the starting 13.

Yep, Laurie for me.

Feels like Madden will be 6 round 1 unless he has a shocker. There are no other options being trialed.

Laurie has the opportunity to win the fullback spot from Mbye. He might get it by default if Mbye is out for round 1 but if he has a big game he'd be hard to leave out even with Mbye.

I think there’s a chance Laurie for 1 and Mbye for 6 round 1.

Maybe but I think it would be unlikely given Mbye hasn't trained at 6 at all, and without a trial under his belt. I think it's more likely Mbye at 1 and Laurie at 6, but even that I think is unlikely.

In my opinion Madden needs a much improved game this weekend to get the 6.

Who do you think will take it off him if Mbye is injured round 1?

No he isn't?

He’s not playing the trial with a hamstring injury which has one of the more unpredictable recovery timelines. So yes I think there is at least a 50/50 chance he might be unavailable.

Exactly, so you can't say he is out. He is out this weekend as a precaution.

Edit. Sorry I missed the if in your post