Wests Tigers v Raiders Live Game Thread

[goldcoast_tiger]

I think Talyor has friends in the right places ..probable is safe but would not be upset to see him punted.

He has failed to make the 8 two years in a row, and made our already bad defence worse, he has to go and go now.

Agree, he killed 2015 with Taylor ball
And killed 2016 with his cohesion policy ..
Crap coach .

Id prefer to have a five 8 that gets the football than a specialised hooker who throws a pass a game to absolutely nobody

You mean the one that he threw over the sideline , to no one today??

 

[851]

Who said a recognised hooker isn't required in the modern game ?

Hodgson was great today !

Hopefully Taylor's gone asap

I think Talyor has friends in the right places ..probable is safe but would not be upset to see him punted.

He has failed to make the 8 two years in a row, and made our already bad defence worse, he has to go and go now.

I agree re Taylor but is a different coach with the same cattle going to change much?

Well I think so, but why would you let Taylor have another year, he preached defence and cohesion in attack, we had our season on the line a full house and he couldn't get them up for this game, that is twice in 3 weeks.
He is clearly out of his depth, he is riding on the individual brilliance of a few players, when he needs to shine he has failed, twice in 3 weeks, and our defence is as bad as it ever was, he has no cred at all now, send him off with Farah. 😛ray:

 

[Telltails]

Knew it was going to be a long afternoon when we kicked it long from the get go. Mistake riddled performance - no where near ready for semis finals football. Still will never understand the cohesion argument when clearly there is no cohesion when the rotation with Halatau occurs.
Season done and dusted - and after that performance - can't blame Farah ,- so I guess it will have to be the "virus'.
The Raiders certainly going to give the finals series a shake - big ,strong, fast and mobile.

 

[hobbo]

I think Talyor has friends in the right places ..probable is safe but would not be upset to see him punted.

He has failed to make the 8 two years in a row, and made our already bad defence worse, he has to go and go now.

I agree re Taylor but is a different coach with the same cattle going to change much?

Well I think so, but why would you let Taylor have another year, he preached defence and cohesion in attack, we had our season on the line a full house and he couldn't get them up for this game, that is twice in 3 weeks.
He is clearly out of his depth, he is riding on the individual brilliance of a few players, when he needs to shine he has failed, twice in 3 weeks, and our defence is as bad as it ever was, he has no cred at all now, send him off with Farah. 😛ray:

Exactly… It was inevitable that Moses and to a lesser extent Brooks would come good at some stage (apart from today )
Taylor's a mouse .

 

[everett]

I think we should appreciate we are playing a very good side with not much weakness.

On current form they should beat Cronulla next week and be only one game away from GF.

Sorry but we need two good centres. Simona is just a dumb player and Kevin needs to improve his defence. Never been a Brooks fan and great forum members are calling for him to leave.

Lot of soul searching in the offseason

 

[everett]

I think we should appreciate we are playing a very good side with not much weakness.

On current form they should beat Cronulla next week and be only one game away from GF.

Sorry but we need two good centres. Simona is just a dumb player and Kevin needs to improve his defence. Never been a Brooks fan and great forum members are calling for him to leave.

Lot of soul searching in the offseason

 

[stevetiger]

I think Talyor has friends in the right places ..probable is safe but would not be upset to see him punted.

He has failed to make the 8 two years in a row, and made our already bad defence worse, he has to go and go now.

I agree re Taylor but is a different coach with the same cattle going to change much?

Well I think so, but why would you let Taylor have another year, he preached defence and cohesion in attack, we had our season on the line a full house and he couldn't get them up for this game, that is twice in 3 weeks.
He is clearly out of his depth, he is riding on the individual brilliance of a few players, when he needs to shine he has failed, twice in 3 weeks, and our defence is as bad as it ever was, he has no cred at all now, send him off with Farah. 😛ray:

Ideally JT is sacked now. That is the best decision if we can get rid of him without a big pay out. In stating that we are going to cop it with the Robbie payout is it a good idea to just give up the money and get rid of him.

It's not all JT's fault but he has so many mistakes in him. I don't blame him for the loss today or a couple of weeks ago but he has held this team back on numerous occasions and I'm not sure if his decision to shaft Robbie is the right decision.

 

[Guest]

He has failed to make the 8 two years in a row, and made our already bad defence worse, he has to go and go now.

I agree re Taylor but is a different coach with the same cattle going to change much?

Well I think so, but why would you let Taylor have another year, he preached defence and cohesion in attack, we had our season on the line a full house and he couldn't get them up for this game, that is twice in 3 weeks.
He is clearly out of his depth, he is riding on the individual brilliance of a few players, when he needs to shine he has failed, twice in 3 weeks, and our defence is as bad as it ever was, he has no cred at all now, send him off with Farah. 😛ray:

Exactly… It was inevitable that Moses and to a lesser extent Brooks would come good at some stage (apart from today )
Taylor's a mouse .

Give the Taylor bashing a rest hobbo, or you can have an offseason spell as well.

 

[hobbo]

I agree re Taylor but is a different coach with the same cattle going to change much?

Well I think so, but why would you let Taylor have another year, he preached defence and cohesion in attack, we had our season on the line a full house and he couldn't get them up for this game, that is twice in 3 weeks.
He is clearly out of his depth, he is riding on the individual brilliance of a few players, when he needs to shine he has failed, twice in 3 weeks, and our defence is as bad as it ever was, he has no cred at all now, send him off with Farah. 😛ray:

Exactly… It was inevitable that Moses and to a lesser extent Brooks would come good at some stage (apart from today )
Taylor's a mouse .

Give the Taylor bashing a rest hobbo, or you can have an offseason spell as well.

No problem, hope the same courtesy is given to the Farah bashers .

 

[innsaneink]

Farah has gone…. He is now opposition