Which player will the Forum bash in 2011 ?

[Spartan117]

Why do we need to bash??? The worst of them is better than the best of us.

I suggest a new thread

Who are we gonna LOVE and why??

 

[Tiger_Watto]

I agree Blake is likely to cop it - but it would likely be undeserved (as were the majority of attacks on Halatau who used to regularly make tough metres when the front row were flacid)!

Blake's stats this year were as good as Chris & better than the likes of Beau Champion who had a top year!

He had some shockers but with experience he is improving massively - unlike Beau Ryan who seems to be going downhill. If Ayshford copped a warning from Sheens mid-season - Ryan needs an off-season rocket just to stay in the top 25 mix with the kids we have coming up (just from the 20s Faleula Finau gets the majority of wraps but Sama Sauvao is class also).

I just hope none of the Premiership winners cop it now Fitzy & Skando are gone!! All those blokes are club immortals by being part of that achievement alone in my eyes!

I am old enough to know that premierships are what players' dreams and post-football careers are built on - they are as rare and as difficult to achieve as a male pregnancy & that all of the staff & players involved in the 2005 title deserve my undying respect, admiration and gratitude as a long suffering supporter who for so long had craved just ONE premiership!

Of course now I want more titles - however I will never underestimate the past contribution of any of our Finals squad in 2005!! (That includes Bronson, Johnny Wilson, Dean Collis & big Ray - but screw McDonnell)!

Criticise - just don't assassinate players who are perceived as being not as good as some of our other genuine superstars!!

In regards to the thread title question - I will suggest that both Bryce & Keith will cop far more than their fair share from those who think Fuifui is the full prop package!!!

x2 :sign:

 

[Flippedy]

I just hope that we are going so well, as a team next year, that we won't want to bash anyone. 😱pen_mouth: Perhaps I'm being a little naive, but hey, I'm an optimist at heart.

 

[Novocastrian_Tiger]

If Moltzen comes back as our starting fullback, watch the poisoned arrows fly!!!

 

[Spartan117]

What about Halatau..Red

I miss him… 😢

I Liked Dene Halatau but He added very little value to the Dogs this season and Im not sure where he would fit in the current Tigers Team,

Who would we drop from the 2010 top 17???

 

[underdog]

What about Halatau..Red

I miss him… 😢

I Liked Dene Halatau but He added very little value to the Dogs this season and Im not sure where he would fit in the current Tigers Team,

Who would we drop from the 2010 top 17???

he was injured for most of the year with the dogs though, and when he finally did get a run, their season was already a write off. Halatau was a victim of bad timing in 2010, he'll be one to watch in the "new-look" Dogs team of 2011.

 

[Spartan117]

he was injured for most of the year with the dogs though, and when he finally did get a run, their season was already a write off. Halatau was a victim of bad timing in 2010, he'll be one to watch in the "new-look" Dogs team of 2011.

Where will he play, I'm thinking Bench at best.

Did they sign him for 2 or 3 years???

 

[TheDen]

Liam Fulton for mine if its not Beau

 

[steve-o]

Liam Fulton for mine if its not Beau

liam fulton? hes our best defender IMO. so he threw an intercept pass when he was filling in at 5/8 when benji was off. so wat? he was out of position n hes not a ball player
i for one will not be bagging him

 

[Yossarian]

Liam Fulton for mine if its not Beau

liam fulton? hes our best defender IMO. so he threw an intercept pass when he was filling in at 5/8 when benji was off. so wat? he was out of position n hes not a ball player
i for one will not be bagging him

You seem to think that player bashing is an evidence based practice!!! :laughing:

 

[bob56]

Liam Fulton for mine if its not Beau

liam fulton? hes our best defender IMO. so he threw an intercept pass when he was filling in at 5/8 when benji was off. so wat? he was out of position n hes not a ball player
i for one will not be bagging him

You seem to think that player bashing is an evidence based practice!!! :laughing:

He may have thrown the match loosing ball against the Chooks, but threw an almost math winning pass to Lui against the Steelers. I shall also not be bagging him.

 

[cunno]

The player will pick themself.

 

[benjibrotown]

No doubt at all.. 5.Beau Ryan

 

[redemption]

If Lote does not improve both his positional defence and work under the high ball some barbs may rightly be thrown his way!

Taniela may have at times looked ungainly under the high ball (with arms fully out-stretched) - but he had a happy knack of defusing most bombs that came his way!

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

No doubt at all.. **18.Beau Ryan**

Edited for accuracy :wink: :laughing: