Who do I thank?

@twentyforty said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192697) said:
@18thman said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1188528) said:
still need a fullback


AD doesn’t seem to be 100% committed. It shows in the way he meanders to the ball and appears his teammates are overestimating his pace. Watching the Rabbitohs last night, I thought Alex Johnston was the difference between them winning and losing. After what I’ve seen in the past few weeks, given the choice of LM, AD or AJ, I wouldn’t hesitate in having AJ as my FB. His positional play is far superior than LM’s and a shade better than AD’s. He matches LM for pace and appears to be 10 meters quicker than AD. Seems the PNG guys are on the outer at the Bunnies. AJ certainly wouldn’t have an issue in getting a decent contract imo.

I don't think anyone could question AD's commitment. He's out there clearly injured and still trying his butt off... He's had one ordinary game, previous to that he's been one of our best all season.
 
@Jedi_Tiger said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192765) said:
i would like to see next year
7 Brooks
6 AD
1 Alex Johnston
9 Harry Grant

That’s nice and all but I’d rather see😉
1.Kepaoa
2.Nofo
3.BJ
4.Talau
5.JAC
6.Doueihi
7.Brooks
 
If I’m honest we thank Bellamy for giving us grant on loan. We are not even half the side without him imo and would struggle

But Maguire has definitely earnt his stripes with our defensive steel
 
@Russell said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192763) said:
@twentyforty said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192697) said:
@18thman said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1188528) said:
still need a fullback


AD doesn’t seem to be 100% committed. It shows in the way he meanders to the ball and appears his teammates are overestimating his pace. Watching the Rabbitohs last night, I thought Alex Johnston was the difference between them winning and losing. After what I’ve seen in the past few weeks, given the choice of LM, AD or AJ, I wouldn’t hesitate in having AJ as my FB. His positional play is far superior than LM’s and a shade better than AD’s. He matches LM for pace and appears to be 10 meters quicker than AD. Seems the PNG guys are on the outer at the Bunnies. AJ certainly wouldn’t have an issue in getting a decent contract imo.

Don't need a new FB in my opinion. Give the one we have a decent go for God's sake.

He's only had a few games at FB, he is injured at the moment which has taken a bit off his limited speed.
He has had one bad game - let's hang him.

Like it or not he is there for this year anyway.

And I would think for a lot longer as well.

he has some bad habits he needs to change and they get found out by the better sides
 
@twentyforty said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192697) said:
@18thman said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1188528) said:
still need a fullback


AD doesn’t seem to be 100% committed. It shows in the way he meanders to the ball and appears his teammates are overestimating his pace. Watching the Rabbitohs last night, I thought Alex Johnston was the difference between them winning and losing. After what I’ve seen in the past few weeks, given the choice of LM, AD or AJ, I wouldn’t hesitate in having AJ as my FB. His positional play is far superior than LM’s and a shade better than AD’s. He matches LM for pace and appears to be 10 meters quicker than AD. Seems the PNG guys are on the outer at the Bunnies. AJ certainly wouldn’t have an issue in getting a decent contract imo.

Cody Walker was the difference between the bunnies loosing or winning.
 
This AJ kid isn’t the messiah some people think on here. Quite average to be fair. Hopefully he progresses well under Madge and can come good. Putting him in sides for this week and next week is premature.
 
@Madge said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192788) said:
This AJ kid isn’t the messiah some people think on here. Quite average to be fair. Hopefully he progresses well under Madge and can come good. Putting him in sides for this week and next week is premature.

He’s looked ok when we’ve beat up on the crap teams, definitely gone missing in games like penrith, Parra and souffs
 
@Tcat said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192784) said:
@twentyforty said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192697) said:
@18thman said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1188528) said:
still need a fullback


AD doesn’t seem to be 100% committed. It shows in the way he meanders to the ball and appears his teammates are overestimating his pace. Watching the Rabbitohs last night, I thought Alex Johnston was the difference between them winning and losing. After what I’ve seen in the past few weeks, given the choice of LM, AD or AJ, I wouldn’t hesitate in having AJ as my FB. His positional play is far superior than LM’s and a shade better than AD’s. He matches LM for pace and appears to be 10 meters quicker than AD. Seems the PNG guys are on the outer at the Bunnies. AJ certainly wouldn’t have an issue in getting a decent contract imo.

Cody Walker was the difference between the bunnies loosing or winning.


If you listened to the commentators you could easily form that opinion. They only had eyes for LM and CW. I thought LM had an average game and CW had a good game. But imo it was AJ’s two tries that got them home. Just an observation.
 
@Speed2burn said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192808) said:
@Madge said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192788) said:
This AJ kid isn’t the messiah some people think on here. Quite average to be fair. Hopefully he progresses well under Madge and can come good. Putting him in sides for this week and next week is premature.

He’s looked ok when we’ve beat up on the crap teams, definitely gone missing in games like penrith, Parra and souffs

He hasn’t even played a game for us yet ?
 
@Madge said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192827) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192808) said:
@Madge said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192788) said:
This AJ kid isn’t the messiah some people think on here. Quite average to be fair. Hopefully he progresses well under Madge and can come good. Putting him in sides for this week and next week is premature.

He’s looked ok when we’ve beat up on the crap teams, definitely gone missing in games like penrith, Parra and souffs

He hasn’t even played a game for us yet ?

Wow I had a total brain fade I read that as AD haha

Sorry bud
 
@twentyforty said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192824) said:
If you listened to the commentators you could easily form that opinion. They only had eyes for LM and CW. I thought LM had an average game and CW had a good game. But imo it was AJ’s two tries that got them home. Just an observation.

LM does some brilliant things but also makes a lot of mistakes every game.
He is certainly not as good as is is continually hyped up to be but he has the potential to be the best player in the NRL.
 
@Speed2burn said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192829) said:
@Madge said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192827) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192808) said:
@Madge said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192788) said:
This AJ kid isn’t the messiah some people think on here. Quite average to be fair. Hopefully he progresses well under Madge and can come good. Putting him in sides for this week and next week is premature.

He’s looked ok when we’ve beat up on the crap teams, definitely gone missing in games like penrith, Parra and souffs

He hasn’t even played a game for us yet ?

Wow I had a total brain fade I read that as AD haha

Sorry bud

haha you’re alright!
 
@WeststigsRdaBest said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192766) said:
@Jedi_Tiger said in [Who do I thank?](/post/1192765) said:
i would like to see next year
7 Brooks
6 AD
1 Alex Johnston
9 Harry Grant

That’s nice and all but I’d rather see?
1.Kepaoa
2.Nofo
3.BJ
4.Talau
5.JAC
6.Doueihi
7.Brooks


No way would i like to see JAC back at this Club, he has the wrong culture.
He left good riddance besides he would prefer to play at Souths.
Made me sick seeing a post on the NRL about how much he cares about indigenous round the COVID i don't care about anyone but me attitude.
 
Back
Top