Who would you want to keep/let go for next year?

[kingbrooks]

The only ones I would keep:

1\. Mbye
2.
3.Marsters
4.
5.
6.Reynolds
7.Brooks
8.Packer
9.
10.Matulino
11.Lawrence
12.
13.

14.Liddle
15.Twal
16.Aloaia
17.

Keep as depth in reserve grade: Thompson

Everyone else can go.

 

[jadtiger]

I would start Twal ahead of both Matulino/Packer and get another prop to either start or go to bench

 

[Yossarian]

Hard to be clearheaded after that but MWZ and MCK aren't first 17 players. Taylor looks a shadow of himself. We need a good centre and some ground making back rowers.

 

[old_boy]

In a perfect world, out of all the players, coach, board and CEO.

I'd keep Twal, Mbye, Farah, Thompson, Rowdy, Fanua, Reynolds.

Everything else can be put in the dumpster.

 

[matchball]

Bar today, Thompson is going great. He deserves the wing spot.
Reserves he will leave and NRL teams would be lining up to take him.
Cheap and good heart.

 

[cqtiger]

The only answer is whoever is off contract.

Pointless paying someone to take one of our contracted players - no-one would want them anyway, not even Parra.

I honestly thought we would win today - a must win game, full house at Leichardt. So sad.

 

[Fade_To_Black]

Bar today, Thompson is going great. He deserves the wing spot.
Reserves he will leave and NRL teams would be lining up to take him.
Cheap and good heart.

Yep. He was horrible today but has been great apart from that. People calling for his head after 1 shocker have no idea. Plays with more guts and heart than another 10 of our players combined.

 

[upthetigers]

In a perfect world, out of all the players, coach, board and CEO.

I'd keep Twal, Mbye, Farah, Thompson, Rowdy, Fanua, Reynolds.

Everything else can be put in the dumpster.

Reynolds body looks cooked and we have him for 4 years.

 

[kingbrooks]

Bar today, Thompson is going great. He deserves the wing spot.
Reserves he will leave and NRL teams would be lining up to take him.
Cheap and good heart.

Id keep him cheap but I think you will find most of the good stuff he has done came from fullback. I think as a winger he wouldn't have clubs pounding down the door and alot of his impact is lost, and hes not neccesarily a terrific finisher as his size hurts him (EG - Today and Roosters).

 

[hobbo]

Eisenhuth…gone ...plodder
Taylor ...gone ... got nothing
MWZ ...piss him off ... gone .. go work at K-mart
Sue ...gone .... go dig trenches
Packer ..gone ... 44 minute man
Matalino... gone ...piss off home

More to come !

 

[matchball]

Bar today, Thompson is going great. He deserves the wing spot.
Reserves he will leave and NRL teams would be lining up to take him.
Cheap and good heart.

Id keep him cheap but I think you will find most of the good stuff he has done came from fullback. I think as a winger he wouldn't have clubs pounding down the door and alot of his impact is lost, and hes not neccesarily a terrific finisher as his size hurts him (EG - Today and Roosters).

Clubs would take him in a heartbeat and would most certainly get more money than he is now.
Where have you been all season? Today wasn't great but he deserves first grade starting spot.

 

[Geo]

Eisenhuth…gone ...plodder
Taylor ...gone ... got nothing
MWZ ...piss him off ... gone .. go work at K-mart
Sue ...gone .... go dig trenches
Packer ..gone ... 44 minute man
Matalino... gone ...piss off home

More to come !

did you run out of puff..

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Sack them all at this rate except for CL

Actually in all honesty, i would have MWZ rather leave than Kevvy

 

[hobbo]

Eisenhuth…gone ...plodder
Taylor ...gone ... got nothing
MWZ ...piss him off ... gone .. go work at K-mart
Sue ...gone .... go dig trenches
Packer ..gone ... 44 minute man
Matalino... gone ...piss off home

More to come !

did you run out of puff..

Nah … I’m a stayer ...
Looking for neurofen ...
Got any ?

 

[WestsBenTigers]

1\. Mbye
2\. Thompson
3\. Marsters
4\. Mahe
5.
6\. Reynolds
7\. Brooks
8\. Twal
9\. Farah
10.
11\. Lawrence
12\. Garner
13\. Eisenhuth

14\. Liddle
15\. Aloiai
16.
17.

 

[yeti]

Not the time to make a clear assessment after that pathetic performance.
But I would be very nervous if I was off contract, that's for sure.

 

[matchball]

Eisenhuth…gone ...plodder
Taylor ...gone ... got nothing
MWZ ...piss him off ... gone .. go work at K-mart
Sue ...gone .... go dig trenches
Packer ..gone ... 44 minute man
Matalino... gone ...piss off home

More to come !

did you run out of puff..

:laughing:

 

[Nucky_Thompson]

Eisenhuth…gone ...plodder
Taylor ...gone ... got nothing
MWZ ...piss him off ... gone .. go work at K-mart
Sue ...gone .... go dig trenches
Packer ..gone ... 44 minute man
Matalino... gone ...piss off home

More to come !

Eisen been very disappointing

 

[kingbrooks]

Bar today, Thompson is going great. He deserves the wing spot.
Reserves he will leave and NRL teams would be lining up to take him.
Cheap and good heart.

Id keep him cheap but I think you will find most of the good stuff he has done came from fullback. I think as a winger he wouldn't have clubs pounding down the door and alot of his impact is lost, and hes not neccesarily a terrific finisher as his size hurts him (EG - Today and Roosters).

Clubs would take him in a heartbeat and would most certainly get more money than he is now.
Where have you been all season? Today wasn't great but he deserves first grade starting spot.

He was a pretty good fullback for most of the year (bar Raiders) and most of the good things he did this year was from roaming around the field.

On the wing he really hasn't done a heap. When was his last real good game on the wing? Parra in R4? As I said, I would keep him as depth but I don't think hes the long term answer. Unfortunately size hurts him.

 

[Carefactor]

Well we can start shopping Packer around .. but who would want him :frowning: