Your Ideal 2017: Farah, Taylor, Both or Neither?

Not sure how the option for "Farah In, Taylor In" would play out but had to include it nonetheless….

FWIW I went "Farah Out, Taylor Out". I'm over the saga. I'm over both of them and would love a fresh start with a new coach and team leadership.
 
I only voted both out because I believe Farah has to go for us to be able to keep Elijah Taylor.

If its one or the other I would prefer Taylor out
 
@bigsiro said:
Not sure how the option for "Farah In, Taylor In" would play out but had to include it nonetheless….

FWIW I went "Farah Out, Taylor Out". I'm over the saga. I'm over both of them and would love a fresh start with a new coach and team leadership.
Click to expand...

This is exactly how I feel. The best case scenario is for them both to go.

I reckon that we might fail that 100%. They both may be here.
 
My ideal would be Taylor out, Farah spends his last year sharing the role with Liddle, Liddle gets exposed to NRL, can take the reigns around Origin and let Robbie have his farewell tour while still allowing our long term combinations to develop.
 
If like to see Taylor finish his contract without any Farah influence for a year, then see how it's affected things… If it's the same or worse, Taylor goes and we don't look bad as a club for other coaches by letting him finish the shake up he was obviously employed to do...
 
If there is any fact that Moses and Brooks prefer playing without Farah then i want him out. If its just a JT thing then i like Farah mentoring Liddle. If i was a betting man id say Taylor wont be here next year and with the way he has been treated neither will Farah.

FYI - i voted both out, clean slate with a new coach who had full ownership of his team with no allegiances or hidden agendas.
 
@Blaze said:
If like to see Taylor finish his contract without any Farah influence for a year, then see how it's affected things… If it's the same or worse, Taylor goes and we don't look bad as a club for other coaches by letting him finish the shake up he was obviously employed to do...
Click to expand...

My thoughts exactly.
 
@gallagher said:
@Blaze said:
If like to see Taylor finish his contract without any Farah influence for a year, then see how it's affected things… If it's the same or worse, Taylor goes and we don't look bad as a club for other coaches by letting him finish the shake up he was obviously employed to do...

My thoughts exactly.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

X3
 
Both are contracted for next year. In the best interest of the club both go. The rift is creating to many problems the division amongst fans should see them both go.
 
idk why but i've voted farah in, taylor in.

farah's still a good player and if taylor can find a way to include him in teh game plan and farah can play to his game plan- it will add a whole new dimension to our team.

also, if farah refused to leave last year, idk what's going to change for him to leave this year.

i dont rate JT tbh. i dont think he's a good coach. whether it be coz of him or despite him, our younger generation has grown an extra leg and shown a lot of confidence so i'd be happy for him to remain here for the last year of his contract but 2017 top 4 is the only way to extend his contract.
 
Robbie is still the best hooker at the club but i voted for both to go as we need to look forwards not backwards.
 
If we are paying 950k for Farah (as we are contracted to do) and we can't offload him for a fair price then I want him in the NRL side.
The ideal situation is he finds another club who pick up his bill. Then we can sort out the DH position. At the moment we look very ordinary out of DH. We should beat Parra without half their team. But I don't think we are a worse side with no proper DH.
I've ticked keep both because I can't see Farah leaving unless some team makes a huge offer. Then we pick up a suitable replacement. Maybe I'm a pessimist but I can't see this happening.
 
Well I went with Farah out, Taylor in.
I just think that after everything that has gone on this year with Robbie on the bench, then dropped to reserves I would have thought that the team would be a bloody shambles right now.

But they are still going ok. I don't believe they will make the eight this year and maybe not next year but they are doing much better than I expected.

My thoughts are that the team are really behind the coach now.
Nothing like the crap that went on with the whole team after the Farah v Potter episode.
 
Got to say I'm surprised so many want to get rid of Elijah…thought he's been quite good for us.

ps I do realise its about jt
 
was it not mentioned somewhere else that the team had to make the eight for taylor to stay in 2017?

anyway,both parties cant be here in 2017- its too stressful for supporters. apart from the robbie taylor thing,the wests tigers have a cleanslate media wise.
things cant stay the same- ey have to change.
i vote for both to go.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 688 (members: 45, guests: 643)
Back
Top